scribe

Chapter 3 - The Cost of Trying

Grace returned home because she said she needed time, and Jennifer let her.

It was one of the hardest things Jennifer had ever done.

She watched Grace walk back up the Whitfields’ front path alone. Derek opened the door before Grace reached it, which meant he had been watching. Grace glanced back once. Jennifer lifted two fingers against her steering wheel, their old signal for call me.

Derek closed the door.

Jennifer did not drive away for another five minutes.

That night, at 11:38, her phone buzzed.

A message from Grace contained eleven screenshots.

Jennifer sat up in bed at her apartment and opened them one by one.

The checking account showed ordinary household spending, prenatal copays, groceries, utilities. The savings history was different. Over nine months, seven transfers had gone to entities whose names Jennifer did not recognize. Four were labeled WHD Project Reserve. Two went to Blue Cedar Consulting. One went to an account ending in 4419 with no visible recipient name.

Total: $127,850.

Then Grace sent a photograph of a paper bill from the fertility clinic.

Under it she wrote: Found this in my desk. I thought we still owed them.

The bill showed a zero balance.

Jennifer called.

Grace answered on the third ring, whispering. “He’s asleep.”

“Where are you?”

“In the guest bathroom.”

Jennifer did not ask why she needed a bathroom to speak privately in her own house.

“I added the transfers,” she said. “One hundred twenty-seven thousand eight hundred fifty dollars.”

Grace was silent.

“Do you recognize Blue Cedar?”

“No.”

“WHD is Whitfield Development, right?”

“Yes.”

“Did you ever agree to move joint savings into Derek’s company?”

“No.”

The word came more firmly than anything Grace had said that afternoon.

Jennifer leaned against her headboard. “Then we stop guessing. Tomorrow, you download full statements. If you can access old tax returns, get those too. You should also make a list of every fertility expense you remember paying.”

“Jen…”

“What?”

“I signed things.”

Jennifer went still.

“What things?”

“I don’t know.”

Grace’s whisper cracked. “Last winter, after the second failed transfer, Derek brought home a folder. He said our accountant needed signatures for taxes and some insurance changes. I was on injections. I was exhausted. I signed where he marked.”

“Did you read them?”

“No.”

“Okay.”

“Don’t say okay like that.”

“I’m not judging you.”

“I am.”

Jennifer closed her eyes. “You were married. You trusted your husband. That is context, not stupidity.”

Grace began to cry quietly.

Jennifer stayed on the phone until the crying stopped.

The next morning they met at a bakery fifteen minutes from Grace’s house. Grace wore sunglasses though the sky was gray. She had brought an accordion folder from home.

“I told Derek I was meeting you for coffee,” she said.

“What did he say?”

“That you’ve always enjoyed making me unhappy.”

Jennifer nearly laughed. “That’s creative.”

“He said you don’t understand marriage because you’re not married.”

“That’s less creative.”

Grace almost smiled.

They chose a table in the back. Grace opened the folder.

Inside were clinic invoices, pharmacy receipts, insurance explanation-of-benefits forms, and copies of checks. Jennifer had spent the last decade in corporate procurement and compliance, which meant she lived in the unglamorous world where big lies often failed because two spreadsheets disagreed.

She did not pretend to be an accountant. She did know how to organize records.

For three hours they sorted.

The fertility treatments had been expensive. Painfully expensive. But the out-of-pocket total Grace could document was just under $61,000 over three years.

“Even if we’re missing something,” Jennifer said, “that is nowhere near one-sixty.”

Grace stared at the columns they had built on paper.

“He told me we emptied our savings because of me.”

Jennifer said nothing.

Grace pressed her lips together. “I stopped buying clothes.”

Jennifer looked at the sunglasses.

“I canceled physical therapy because the copay was forty dollars,” Grace continued. “I apologized every time I ordered takeout.”

Her voice was getting flatter, which Jennifer recognized as more dangerous than tears.

“I felt guilty for buying that dress.”

Jennifer reached across the table but stopped before touching her hand, giving Grace the choice.

Grace turned her palm upward.

Jennifer took it.

“There’s something else,” Grace said.

She pulled a folded envelope from the bottom of the accordion file.

The return address was the county assessor’s office.

“I found it behind some mail on Derek’s desk.”

The notice concerned a property Grace had inherited from her grandmother five years earlier: 6.4 acres of narrow wooded land along Hawthorne Road, outside the city limits. Grace had almost forgotten about it. The parcel produced no income. Her grandmother had kept it because it had once connected two larger pieces of family land.

Jennifer unfolded the notice.

At the top, under OWNER OF RECORD, was not Grace’s name.

It read:

May you like

CEDAR RIDGE ACCESS LLC.

Grace whispered, “I never sold it.”

Related Stories

Other posts