Chapter 5 - Ismerie’s Drawing

That week in art class, the children were told to draw their families doing something together.
Most of the pictures turned out bright and easy: backyard swings, pancakes, bike rides, movie nights with oversized bowls of popcorn. Ismerie used a purple crayon for her own dress and a blue one for Orien’s sweater without even looking at him for reference.
She drew a white room with a yellow light, three children sitting close together, each holding a plate.
At the edge of the paper she drew the curved side of a toilet with its lid closed.
When her teacher, Ms. Pruitt, crouched beside the table, she smiled at first.
“Oh, I like how close everyone is,” she said.
Ismerie nodded. “We were eating dinner.”
Ms. Pruitt looked more carefully. “In the bathroom?”
“Yes.”
The answer came with the serene honesty of a six-year-old.
“Why were you in there?”
“Because Orien had to eat there. So me and Tavian did too.”
Ms. Pruitt stayed very still.
“Who told Orien to eat there?”
Ismerie continued coloring the cream tiles grayish-beige. “Mom.”
By three o’clock, the drawing sat on Mrs. Halden’s desk. By three-thirty, she had emailed Lucian asking if he could speak with her privately the next morning before class.
He almost missed the message. He was reviewing site revisions in his office and glancing through his inbox at speed. But the subject line—Quick Check-In About Orien and Family Dinner Assignment—caught him.
He responded yes.
That night he said nothing at home. He did not want to ask a question clumsily and tip everyone into defensiveness. But he found himself watching Orien with a new alertness.
When Nerissa asked the children how school had gone, Orien answered, “Fine.”
Tavian glanced at Ismerie.
Ismerie stared hard at her peas.
Lucian noticed both things.
After dinner, he tucked Ismerie in. She held onto his sleeve when he started to stand.
“Daddy?”
“Yeah, sweetheart?”
She hesitated. “If someone is mean but they’re still in your family, do you still have to be nice?”
Every parental instinct in him sharpened.
“You still have to tell the truth,” he said carefully.
She studied him, then let go of his sleeve.
May you like
“All right.”
He turned off her lamp and stood in the hallway for several long seconds afterward.