scribe

Chapter 5 - The Attorney Who Kept Looking at the Door

Michael Pierce’s office occupied the eighteenth floor of a glass tower three blocks from the courthouse.

Rebecca had known him since she was seventeen.

He drafted her college power of attorney when she studied abroad. He sat in the second row at her father’s funeral. He sent Diane flowers every anniversary of Samuel’s death.

He also, according to company records, had accessed Rebecca’s trust documents two days before a fictional surgeon named David Chen entered her life.

Officer Martinez did not attend the meeting.

“That would turn a voluntary conversation into something else,” she told Rebecca. “You are allowed to speak to your own attorney. But do not accuse him on my behalf, and do not attempt to obtain evidence illegally. If he gives you anything voluntarily, preserve it.”

Andrew insisted on coming.

Pierce greeted them with too much warmth.

“Rebecca. Andrew. Sit. Coffee?”

“No,” Rebecca said.

Pierce was fifty-one, silver at the temples, expensive navy suit, pale blue tie. He closed the office door and took his chair behind the desk.

“I assume this concerns the security incident Andrew mentioned.”

Rebecca watched his hands.

“What security incident?”

Pierce hesitated. “The suspected misuse of company information.”

“Who told you that?”

“Margaret called me.”

Andrew swore quietly.

Pierce frowned. “Is that a problem?”

“She was asked not to spread this around,” Rebecca said.

“No one told me I was prohibited from being informed.”

Rebecca placed a printed copy of Jennifer’s document on his desk.

Pierce looked down.

His face changed.

Not much.

Enough.

“Have you seen this before?” Rebecca asked.

“No.”

“The metadata says your firm created it.”

Pierce did not touch the page.

“Metadata can be manipulated.”

“The embedded software license belongs to Pierce Legal Services.”

“That is more concerning.”

Andrew leaned forward. “Mike, did your system get breached?”

“It is possible. Law firms are constant targets.”

“Did you report a breach?”

“No confirmed breach has occurred.”

Rebecca’s voice sharpened. “You just said it was possible.”

“Possible is not confirmed.”

“Did you download my trust summary six months ago?”

Pierce’s eyes flicked toward the door.

Rebecca noticed.

“Yes,” he said.

“Why?”

“For routine estate administration.”

“What administration?”

Pierce opened a drawer and took out a yellow legal pad. “I would need to review my notes.”

“You’re looking at them.”

“I said review, Rebecca.”

Andrew stood. “Enough. We have a problem involving forged documents, confidential information, and my sister losing almost thirty thousand dollars. Stop talking to us like opposing counsel.”

Pierce’s jaw tightened.

“I am trying to avoid making statements before I understand the facts.”

“Then help us understand them,” Rebecca said. “Did you create a limited proxy for my Marston vote?”

Pierce went completely still.

Andrew turned. “What proxy?”

Rebecca kept her eyes on Pierce. “A hidden page was embedded in a document the scammer sent me. It authorized Margaret to vote my trust units in connection with a Marston sale. My signature had been copied onto it.”

Andrew looked as if someone had struck him.

Pierce removed his glasses.

“Rebecca, if you have evidence of a forged legal instrument, you should give it to law enforcement.”

“I did.”

Again, his eyes moved toward the door.

This time Andrew saw it too.

“Are you expecting someone?” he asked.

“No.”

“Then why do you keep checking the hallway?”

Pierce’s voice cooled. “I don’t.”

Rebecca leaned back.

“Did Margaret ask you to draft a proxy?”

Pierce said nothing.

“Did she?”

“A draft may have been prepared as part of contingency planning.”

Andrew’s face darkened. “Without Rebecca’s consent?”

“A draft is not an executed instrument.”

“Did you put her signature on it?”

“No.”

“Who had access to the signature file?”

Pierce stood and walked to a credenza. “We maintain electronic copies of prior signed documents in the client-management system.”

“Who can access them?” Rebecca asked.

“Attorneys assigned to the matter. Certain administrators.”

“Margaret?”

“No.”

“Could you?”

“Yes.”

“Could your assistant?”

“Yes.”

“Could someone using your administrator credentials?”

Pierce turned slowly. “Yes.”

Andrew picked up the printed document.

“This firm has represented our family for sixteen years.”

“Seventeen.”

“That correction is not helping you.”

Pierce exhaled. “Listen to me. If someone compromised our system, I will cooperate fully. But if you turn this into a public accusation before we establish facts, you could damage the company during an already sensitive financing period.”

Rebecca stared at him.

“The company. Again.”

“What?”

“Everyone keeps telling me not to do anything that might hurt the company. I was targeted. My money was taken. My signature was copied. Someone tried to steal my vote, and your concern is the company.”

“My concern is containing harm.”

“To whom?”

Pierce had no good answer.

Andrew opened the office door. “We’re done.”

In the reception area, an assistant looked up from her desk. Behind her, a copier hummed.

Then the elevator opened.

Margaret Hayes stepped out.

All four people froze.

She recovered first.

“Andrew. Rebecca.”

Rebecca looked at Pierce.

“You weren’t expecting anyone?” she asked.

Margaret’s gaze moved between them. “Michael called me ten minutes ago.”

Pierce said nothing.

Andrew’s face went red. “You called her while we were sitting in your office?”

“I believed she needed to be informed.”

Rebecca felt something inside her settle.

Not certainty.

A line.

She turned to Margaret. “Did you ask Michael to draft a proxy for my Marston vote?”

Margaret’s expression hardened.

“A contingency proxy, yes.”

“Why?”

“In case you were unavailable when the lender deadline arrived.”

“My signature is on it.”

Margaret’s face changed for the first time.

“That is not possible.”

Pierce spoke quickly. “No executed proxy was authorized.”

Rebecca watched them both.

Then Margaret said something no innocent person should have known.

“Was the signature on page four?”

May you like

The hallway went silent.

Rebecca had never told her how many pages there were.

Related Stories

Other posts