scribe

Chapter 13 - DR. BROOKS

Dr. Lena Brooks’s office was on the second floor of a brick professional building between a pediatric dentist and an accounting firm.

The waiting room contained two armchairs, a low table, a plant that looked real, and a framed print that read: You can be responsible for your behavior without being responsible for another person’s feelings.

Cassian noticed the sentence and immediately disliked it.

Althea arrived two minutes after him.

They had agreed to drive separately.

“Hey,” she said.

“Hey.”

She wore black trousers, a cream blouse, and a camel coat. Cassian had the strange urge to tell her she looked beautiful, but he worried it would sound strategic.

So he did not.

At exactly six, Dr. Brooks opened the inner door.

She was a Black woman in her early fifties with short natural hair, silver-framed glasses, and the steady expression of someone unlikely to be impressed by dramatic declarations.

Inside her office, Cassian and Althea sat on opposite ends of a long sofa.

Dr. Brooks took the chair across from them.

“I read the intake forms,” she said. “You both described the same argument, which is more unusual than you might think.”

Cassian glanced at Althea.

Dr. Brooks continued. “My first question is not who was right. It’s why are you here?”

Althea answered first.

“Because I love my husband, but I don’t want to live in a marriage where I need his approval to be an adult.”

Cassian shifted.

Dr. Brooks looked at him.

“And you?”

He had prepared several answers.

Because I want to save my marriage.

Because I said something I regret.

Because my wife asked me to come.

He chose the one that frightened him.

“Because I don’t know if she’s exaggerating.”

Althea turned toward him.

Cassian continued before she could speak.

“And if she isn’t, then I don’t know how I missed it.”

Dr. Brooks nodded.

“That’s useful.”

Cassian was surprised.

“I expected you to say it was defensive.”

“It is defensive. It can still be useful.”

For the next twenty minutes, Dr. Brooks asked them to describe the night at the door without explaining motives.

Only observable facts.

Althea said she announced she was leaving for a planned event.

Cassian asked whether she was informing him or requesting permission.

She said she did not need permission.

He referenced losing his job and said it did not put her in charge.

Then he told her to stay or return the next morning to pack her bags.

She left.

When they finished, Dr. Brooks looked at Cassian.

“What were you trying to make happen?”

“I wanted her to stay.”

“How?”

Cassian hesitated.

“By making clear there would be consequences.”

“What consequence?”

“Leaving the marriage.”

“Did you actually want the marriage to end?”

“No.”

“So the consequence was not a boundary you intended to enforce. It was pressure intended to change her decision.”

Cassian felt heat rise in his neck.

“When you say it like that, it sounds manipulative.”

Dr. Brooks remained neutral.

“How would you say it?”

“I was angry.”

“That describes your state. Not your strategy.”

Cassian looked down.

Althea’s hands remained folded in her lap.

Dr. Brooks turned to her.

“What did the statement mean to you?”

“That my place in the home could be threatened if I didn’t comply.”

“Did you believe he would physically prevent you from returning?”

“No.”

“Did you believe he might emotionally punish you if you stayed?”

Althea took longer to answer.

“Yes.”

Cassian looked at her.

“What does that mean?” he asked.

Dr. Brooks raised a hand slightly.

“Let her finish.”

Althea swallowed.

“It means coldness. Withdrawal. Questions that don’t stop until I’m exhausted. Making me explain myself until I’m not even sure what I wanted anymore.”

Cassian’s expression tightened.

“I don’t do that on purpose.”

“I know.”

Dr. Brooks looked at him.

“Intent matters. Effect also matters.”

He nodded reluctantly.

Then Dr. Brooks asked a question neither expected.

“Cassian, what would it mean about you if Althea did not need you?”

He frowned.

“She does need me.”

“That was not my question.”

He sat back.

The room became very quiet.

After several seconds, he said, “I don’t know.”

“Guess.”

Cassian stared at the carpet.

“Maybe that I’m replaceable.”

Althea turned toward him fully.

Dr. Brooks did not rush.

“And what did losing your job tell you about being replaceable?”

Cassian’s throat tightened.

“That I was.”

The answer arrived almost in a whisper.

Althea’s eyes softened.

Dr. Brooks leaned forward slightly.

“So when your employer demonstrated that a role you believed was secure could disappear, you came home carrying a fear that security itself had disappeared. Then your wife continued functioning. Paying bills. Making plans. Going out.”

Cassian’s jaw worked.

“It felt like she didn’t need me.”

Althea spoke quietly.

“I wanted you. That’s different.”

Cassian looked at her.

The sentence visibly unsettled him.

Dr. Brooks let the silence remain.

Then she said, “A relationship based on being needed can become vulnerable when circumstances change. A relationship based on being chosen has a different problem: you cannot force the choice.”

Cassian looked down again.

For the first time, he understood why Althea’s independence had felt like rejection.

He had built too much of his identity around indispensability.

Her competence had begun to feel like evidence against his worth.

Near the end of the session, Dr. Brooks gave them one assignment.

“For the next week, neither of you will use the words always or never about the other person. Speak only about specific actions. And Cassian, when you feel the urge to question a decision Althea has made, ask yourself one thing first: Is this information I need, or reassurance I want?”

Cassian gave a weary half-smile.

“You make that sound simple.”

“I said one question. I didn’t say the answer would be simple.”

Outside the office, Althea and Cassian stood beside their separate cars.

For a moment, they were awkward teenagers again, unsure how to end a date.

Cassian finally said, “I’m sorry you learned how to manage my reactions.”

Althea looked at him.

It was the first apology he had made that did not contain the word but.

“Thank you,” she said.

He nodded.

May you like

She got into her car.

Neither asked the other to come home.

Related Stories

Other posts