Chapter 20 - The Deposition

Verena’s deposition lasted six hours.
Isolde did not have to attend, but she chose to sit in for the portions concerning her loan and the HELOC.
Verena wore gray and answered every question with the controlled impatience of a person offended by chronology.
Caleb began with the 2023 loan.
“Mrs. Mercer, did you understand the four-hundred-twenty-thousand-dollar transfer from Isolde Mercer to be a gift?”
“No.”
“A capital contribution?”
“No.”
“A loan?”
“Yes.”
“Secured?”
“Yes.”
“Did you sign a written consent authorizing Edmund Mercer to pledge a twelve-percent membership interest?”
“Yes.”
“Did you later describe that interest to Hart Capital as unencumbered upon routine family consents?”
“I described the expected post-closing condition.”
“Which required Isolde to subordinate?”
“Yes.”
“Had she agreed to subordinate?”
“Not yet.”
“Did you instruct your son not to upset her before she signed?”
Verena’s eyes moved toward Isolde.
“I told him to avoid unnecessary conflict.”
Caleb displayed the group chat screenshot.
Keep her soft. No more fights until she signs.
“Those are your words?”
“Yes.”
“What did ‘soft’ mean?”
“Receptive.”
“Did you believe Isolde’s emotional state affected whether she would sign financial documents?”
Verena paused.
“Yes.”
The room seemed to become smaller.
Caleb continued.
“Did you know Alaric had caused Daniel Reeve to notarize Isolde’s HELOC signature while she was out of state?”
“No.”
“Did you know the HELOC was opened?”
“Yes.”
“Did you know a portion of the proceeds would be contributed to Mercer House Development?”
“Yes.”
“Did you ask Isolde whether she had agreed?”
“No.”
“Why not?”
“I assumed my son handled his marriage.”
The phrase hung in the air.
Handled his marriage.
Caleb moved to the $165,000 repayment to Verena’s trust.
“Did you disclose to Isolde that company cash would be used to repay your insider advance shortly after her loan funded?”
“No.”
“Why not?”
“It was not her decision.”
“She was the lender.”
“She was a lender. She was not management.”
“Did you tell her the company needed the funds to protect payroll?”
“Yes.”
“Was that true?”
“Yes.”
“Was it the whole truth?”
Arthur objected.
Verena answered after a long pause.
“No.”
Isolde felt something inside her loosen.
Not because Verena admitted wrongdoing in legal terms. She did not.
Because the pattern finally had language.
Not the whole truth.
Caleb finished with Edmund’s letter.
“Why did you retain a letter addressed to Isolde after your husband’s death?”
Verena looked at the paper.
“I resented it.”
“What did you resent?”
“That Edmund trusted her with leverage against the company.”
“More than you resented the company owing her money?”
“I resented both.”
“Did you consider Isolde family?”
Arthur objected to relevance.
Verena spoke before he finished.
“I considered her Alaric’s wife.”
Caleb let the silence sit.
“And what rights did that status give her in your mind?”
Verena’s eyes narrowed. “Rights?”
“Yes. Not duties. Rights.”
The question seemed to irritate her precisely because she had never framed the relationship that way.
“She had a home. Financial security. Inclusion in holidays. Access to the family.”
“Did she have a right to accurate information about debt placed against her home?”
Arthur objected.
Verena answered anyway. “Yes.”
“Did she have a right to decide whether her separate money would remain tied up in your company after maturity?”
Another pause. “Yes.”
Each answer sounded less like a concession than a language lesson she resented needing.
Caleb waited.
Verena looked directly at Isolde.
“And I treated those as different things.”
For the first time, there was no contempt in her voice.
Only recognition.
Near the end of the deposition, Caleb asked one final series of questions about the rainy night. Not the affair—the timing.
“Did you expect Isolde to review financing papers that week?”
“Yes,” Verena said.
“Did you believe she was upset about Sabine?”
“Yes.”
“Did you think being upset would make her more likely or less likely to sign?”
Verena looked at the table. “At the time, I thought she would want to restore peace.”
“By signing?”
“Yes.”
Isolde felt chilled. The insult in the living room had not been a secret mind-control scheme. It was something more ordinary and believable: a family accustomed to conflict ending when Isolde absorbed it. They had counted on habit.
The deposition ended shortly before dusk.
In the hallway, Verena approached Isolde without Arthur.
“I suppose you wanted to hear me say that.”
“No.”
“No?”
“I wanted you not to believe it in the first place.”
Verena looked tired.
“Edmund thought you would make Alaric better.”
“I wasn’t supposed to be his improvement project.”
“No.”
The word surprised Isolde.
Verena continued. “I thought you made him comfortable. I did not understand comfort can become a kind of permission if the person receiving it has no discipline.”
“Do you understand it now?”
Verena’s mouth twisted.
“I understand we trained him badly.”
“We?”
“Edmund by avoiding conflict. Me by treating control as competence. You by saving him too often.”
The old Isolde might have accepted her assigned share.
The new one did not.
“No,” she said. “I am responsible for staying too long. I am not responsible for training a grown man not to forge my consent.”
Verena looked at her.
Then, slowly, she nodded.
That night, mediation was scheduled for the following week.
May you like
Miriam sent Isolde a message with three words.
Time to finish this.