Chapter 8 - The Invitation to a Lie

The invitation arrived on June second, addressed to Ms. Brooke Fenwick Hollis in embossed silver lettering.
Inside, creamy paper announced the marriage of Cassidy Fenwick and Derek Hollis at Cedar Hollow Estate on June twenty-first. The wording described the occasion as the joining of two families. Mine was already involved. That was the problem.
I called Mara and asked whether Derek could legally marry Cassidy while still married to me. She confirmed he could not. Our divorce was pending; no final decree existed. A ceremony could not turn an unlawful marriage into a lawful one simply because a florist delivered flowers.
“What should I do about the invitation?” I asked.
“Whatever preserves your peace. You have no obligation to manage their event.”
I left the invitation on the counter for two days. Then I photographed it for my records and placed it in the folder. Even paper could be useful when people insisted they were telling the truth.
Mother called from an unfamiliar number on Thursday.
“Don't hang up,” she said. “I need five minutes.”
“You have one.”
“The venue has become difficult. They're asking for a clarification about the ceremony. Derek says your attorney refuses to cooperate.”
“Derek is still married. That is a fact, not a scheduling problem.”
Mother exhaled. “You can be divorced before the wedding if you stop making demands.”
“The property questions are not settled.”
“Then settle them.”
“We are working through the proper process.”
“Brooke, the invitations are out. People have booked flights.”
“You sent invitations for an event you weren't free to hold.”
There was a pause. Then my mother made the request beneath all her other requests.
“Could you at least tell people you approve of the ceremony? The venue needs to know there won't be trouble.”
“No.”
“Think of Cassidy.”
“I have thought of Cassidy every day since the florist called.”
I ended the call. My hands stayed steady.
That afternoon I received a message from Cassidy. She wanted to know whether we could meet at a coffee shop without Derek or Mother. I agreed because she had respected my boundaries since the park, and because I wanted to learn what she had discovered.
She arrived holding the invitation with two fingers, as if it were dirty.
“I didn't know we couldn't get a license,” she said.
“Did Derek tell you the divorce was final?”
“He said the paperwork would be done.”
“But you knew it hadn't been.”
She nodded. “I kept avoiding the question.”
Cassidy showed me a message from the venue. Nadine had asked whether the couple intended a symbolic ceremony rather than a legal wedding, since they could not confirm the necessary documentation. Mother had replied that the distinction should not be explained to guests.
“Derek says we can have the ceremony now and make it legal later,” Cassidy said. “Mom says nobody needs the details.”
“What do you say?”
She did not answer immediately.
“I've spent months trying to make this feel like a love story,” she admitted. “But every version starts with you being tricked into stepping aside.”
I watched her absorb her own words. I wanted to tell her what decision to make. I had done that for years, issuing practical instructions whenever she called in trouble. If I resumed that role now, she could blame me for the outcome.
“You have to choose,” I said. “Not for me, not for Mom. For yourself and your son.”
She put her hand over her stomach. “I don't know how to do this without somebody telling me what to do.”
“Then start small. Ask a question and insist on an honest answer.”
Before leaving she asked whether I would attend if they changed the occasion into a commitment ceremony.
“No,” I said. “I won't celebrate a relationship built on my exclusion.”
She blinked, then nodded.
Afterward I met Eva at the house to sort through kitchenware. We packed skillets, dishes, and an enormous appliance Derek had bought and used twice. Eva pointed at the invitation on the table.
“Are you going to send a response?”
“I did.”
“What did you write?”
“Nothing. I won't be there.”
She smiled. “That's a complete answer.”
As we packed, Eva uncovered a battered old recipe tin that had belonged to my grandmother. Its lid bore a faded drawing of strawberries. Inside were cards in several kinds of handwriting: my grandmother's careful script, my father's block letters, and my own childish attempts to spell cinnamon. I found one for peach cobbler with a note on the back: Brooke is the only one who waits until the oven is ready. I smiled at the memory of being praised for patience. Then I felt the familiar ache of wondering whether patience had become the excuse everyone used to delay doing right by me. I slid the tin into the box marked KEEP. A good quality could be used against you without becoming a bad quality. I could remain patient with difficult work and refuse to wait indefinitely for somebody else's honesty. Before Eva left, we baked the cobbler from the old recipe, using peaches we'd picked up at the market.
On June tenth, Dad called. He and Mother had been arguing. He said he would not attend a ceremony presented as a legal wedding while Derek was still married.
“I'm not asking you to take my side,” I told him.
“I'm taking the side of telling guests the truth.”
I remembered the porch conversation, the way his hands had twisted his cap. Change did not make him brave all at once. It made him choose differently each time.
May you like
Before bed, I opened a property listing Fallon had sent. It showed a small bungalow with yellow kitchen cabinets and a back garden shaded by a crepe myrtle. It needed work, which I knew how to assess. I saved the listing.
For the first time, June twenty-first felt less like a deadline hanging over me than a day I might spend looking at a different future.