Chapter 28 - THE MAN AT THE GATE

The car stopped outside the locked gate.
A man stepped out.
Not Benedict.
Not police.
He held up identification to the intercom camera.
Dr. Simon Vale.
Caelan stared at the name.
Helena went rigid.
“Vale?”
The visitor was in his early sixties.
Old enough to be the son of the doctor who signed Helena’s original confinement order.
He was.
He claimed he had found records among his late father’s possessions and wished to turn them over privately.
Shaw advised them not to let him inside until police arrived.
So they met at the gate.
Simon Vale handed Caelan a metal document case.
“My father kept copies.”
“Why?”
“Insurance.”
“Against whom?”
“Alaric Veyne. Lucien Harrow. Possibly himself.”
Helena would not get out of the car.
Simon saw her through the windshield and looked ashamed.
“I was a child when most of this happened.”
“But not when your father retired,” Seraphine said.
“No.”
“You never looked at his files?”
“I did last month.”
“After this became public?”
“Yes.”
Convenient again.
Inside the case were psychiatric notes, payment records and one photograph.
The photograph showed Blackthorn’s upstairs corridor in 1964.
At the far end stood a blurred female figure.
Long hair.
Pale dress.
Almost no facial detail.
Caelan stared.
“Who took this?”
“My father.”
“Why?”
“He was asked to evaluate Maeve Vale for hallucinations.”
Helena whispered from behind the car window, “My mother.”
Simon nodded.
“She insisted someone stood outside her child’s room. My father believed it was stress.”
“What changed?”
“He found evidence someone was using the service passages.”
Caelan exhaled.
Human explanation.
Again.
“Who?”
Simon looked at the photograph.
“A dismissed servant named Corinne Ash.”
Seraphine frowned.
“Why was she there?”
“She believed the Vale family had caused her sister’s death. She watched the children. Left notes. Moved objects. She was arrested.”
“And the photograph?”
“Probably her.”
“Probably?”
Simon looked uncomfortable.
“The photograph was taken three weeks after Corinne Ash was arrested.”
Silence.
A police car appeared down the road.
Simon handed over the final file.
Inside was a statement from Maeve.
I accept that Miss Ash entered the house. I do not accept that she was the woman I saw. Miss Ash walked with a limp. The woman outside the nursery did not move at all.
Eirwen stood behind the gate, holding Seraphine’s hand.
She looked at the old photograph.
“That’s her.”
Caelan felt every rational explanation in the last month shift under him.
“Who?”
May you like
Eirwen pointed.
“The waiting lady.”