Chapter 4 - WHAT LUCIEN SAW

Lucien found them in Dressing Room Three.
Vespera reached him first.
"Thank God," she said, hurrying down the corridor. "Your mother has locked herself in there with Calista."
Lucien did not answer.
He looked at Vespera's face, then at the torn strip of lilac satin still clenched in her left hand.
She noticed his gaze and tucked it behind her palm.
Too late.
"What is that?"
"Part of the dress. I was going to have wardrobe fix it."
"You said it caught on a hook."
"It did. I pulled it free."
"You said Calista was hysterical."
"She was."
Lucien knocked on the dressing-room door.
"Calista? It's Dad."
The lock clicked.
Eudora opened the door.
Lucien saw his daughter sitting under his mother's coat.
He saw the red mark on her cheek.
He saw how she looked at Vespera and then immediately looked down.
Something inside him changed shape.
He entered slowly.
"Can I sit with you?"
Calista nodded.
He crouched in front of her.
"I need to ask you something, sweetheart. You don't have to answer quickly. Did Vespera slap you?"
Calista's fingers tightened.
Vespera stepped forward. "Lucien, this is absurd."
Eudora moved between them without touching anyone.
"Let her answer."
Lucien kept his eyes on Calista.
"Did she?"
A tear slipped down Calista's cheek.
She nodded once.
Lucien stopped breathing for a second.
Behind him, Vespera exhaled sharply.
"She thinks a corrective tap is a slap because Eudora is putting words in her mouth."
Calista flinched at the word corrective.
Lucien saw it.
"Did you tear her dress?"
"I was trying to stop her from running onto the stage looking ridiculous."
"After the performance?"
Vespera's expression tightened.
He had caught the inconsistency before she could smooth it over.
Calista whispered, "She said I didn't deserve it."
The room went quiet.
Lucien sat back on his heels.
"Didn't deserve what?"
"Pretty dresses."
Vespera folded her arms. "This is becoming grotesque. She made a mistake. I corrected her. Every serious musician is disciplined. Ask Soren."
Eudora looked at Lucien.
"She is eight."
"Do not start with me," Vespera snapped. "You abandoned this family."
Eudora's face hardened.
"And who told Calista that Lucien asked me not to come?"
For the first time, Vespera had no immediate reply.
Lucien turned.
"What?"
Calista looked frightened again.
Eudora said, "Your daughter believes you barred me from seeing her. I never received such a request from you. Did you send one?"
"No."
Vespera said quickly, "You two were barely speaking. I simplified it for a child."
"You lied to her," Lucien said.
"I protected her from adult conflict."
"By telling her I rejected her grandmother?"
Vespera's voice dropped. "Do not let your mother turn one stressful evening into a trial."
Lucien looked at Calista.
One stressful evening.
He thought of the breakfast flinch.
The photographs.
The messages telling him not to call before performances.
"We're leaving," he said.
Vespera relaxed slightly, assuming he meant all three of them.
Then Lucien added, "Calista is coming with me and Mother. You can take the other car."
Her face changed.
"Lucien."
"Not tonight."
"I am your wife."
"And she is my daughter."
The words landed badly because they should never have needed saying.
Vespera looked at Calista.
Only for a second.
But Calista drew Eudora's coat closer.
Lucien saw that too.
As they left, Mara Keene stood at the far end of the corridor beside a stack of costume cases.
She waited until Vespera disappeared toward the lobby.
Then she stepped toward Eudora and whispered, "There is a camera above the stage-door corridor."
Lucien turned.
May you like
Mara swallowed.
"Mrs. Vale asked security to switch it off before the recital."