scribe

Chapter 3 - THE DINNER WITHOUT HIM

Lenora had never imagined Thanksgiving could feel hostile without anyone raising their voice.

Her parents arrived at four twenty-three.

Her mother, Diane Wynn, carried a pumpkin pie in a glass dish and stepped into the house with the careful smile she used when she had already decided not to comment on something obvious.

Charles carried a bottle of sparkling cider.

He looked toward the dining room.

“Where’s Rick?”

Lenora closed the front door.

“He went to his father’s.”

Diane removed her coat slowly.

“Today?”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

Lenora hesitated.

Because the answer sounded worse out loud.

“He found out I asked Amos not to come.”

Charles glanced at Diane.

Diane looked at the empty kitchen counter.

“And Rick took the food?”

“Yes.”

“All of it?”

“Yes, Mom.”

Charles cleared his throat.

“Well. That was dramatic.”

Lenora turned toward him.

“Please don’t.”

“I’m only saying—”

“I know what you’re saying.”

Diane put the pie down.

“Why did you ask Amos not to come?”

Lenora stared at her mother.

“For you.”

“For me?”

“You told me last year he made Dad uncomfortable.”

Diane’s mouth tightened.

“I said your father and Amos do not enjoy one another.”

“You said dinner was tense.”

“It was.”

“So I tried to avoid that.”

Charles walked into the dining room and examined the prepared table as if someone might produce a turkey from beneath it.

“What are we supposed to eat?”

Diane shot him a look.

“Charles.”

“What? I skipped lunch.”

Lenora almost laughed. The absurdity of the question felt cruel.

She had spent two days cooking.

The food was thirty-one minutes away.

She opened the refrigerator.

There were eggs, butter, celery, cranberry sauce, two bottles of wine, and half a container of yogurt.

Diane approached the island.

“Lenora.”

“What?”

“Did Rick know you were calling Amos?”

“No.”

Her mother was quiet.

“That was a mistake.”

“I was trying to make this easier.”

“For whom?”

“For everybody.”

“No,” Diane said. “You were trying to prevent discomfort.”

“What’s the difference?”

“Sometimes discomfort is the price of having a family.”

Charles sighed. “Can we not turn this into philosophy? Amos is difficult.”

Diane faced him.

“And you aren’t?”

He blinked.

Lenora leaned against the counter.

Her father frowned. “What is that supposed to mean?”

“It means,” Diane said, “that you made comments last Thanksgiving you knew would bother him.”

“I was talking generally.”

“You were being passive-aggressive.”

“I was not.”

“You absolutely were.”

Charles looked at Lenora as if requesting backup.

She did not give it.

For the first time since Rick had walked out, the shape of what she had done became clearer.

She had told herself she was protecting her parents.

But her parents were adults.

She had made a decision about Rick’s father without Rick because she assumed he would object.

That was why she had hidden it.

Not forgotten to mention it.

Hidden it.

Her phone sat on the counter.

Rick’s message remained on the screen.

I’ll come home tonight. I’m eating with Dad.

No accusation.

No insult.

Somehow that made it harder.

Diane pulled out a chair.

“Order something.”

Charles looked offended. “On Thanksgiving?”

“We are the reason there’s no Thanksgiving dinner here.”

“I didn’t ask her to uninvite anyone.”

“No,” Diane said. “But she thought she needed to choose.”

Lenora looked up.

“Mom.”

Diane softened.

“I know you were trying to make us comfortable. But I don’t want comfort that costs your husband his father.”

The sentence landed cleanly.

Charles stared at the floor.

Lenora looked toward the table.

Six place settings.

She had removed Amos’s name card that morning.

Rick never noticed because she had told him she was simplifying the table.

Now two places would be empty.

Hers felt empty too.

At five fifteen, they ate delivery pizza from paper plates because every restaurant with traditional holiday meals had stopped taking orders.

Charles complained about the crust.

Diane told him to stop.

Lenora barely ate.

At six forty, her parents left.

Diane hugged her at the door.

“Talk to your husband.”

“I will.”

“And listen before you explain.”

Lenora swallowed.

Her mother squeezed her shoulder.

“Those are not the same thing.”

After they left, the house became painfully quiet.

Lenora went to the dining room and began gathering the untouched plates.

At Amos’s former place, there was no plate to gather.

She had removed it before anyone arrived.

That bothered her more than she expected.

She stood there looking at the bare section of tablecloth and remembered the first Thanksgiving after Rick’s mother died.

Amos had arrived early.

He had carried flowers for Lenora because he said hosting after a loss was hard on everyone, not only the person grieving most visibly.

She had forgotten that.

Or perhaps she had chosen not to remember it when it became inconvenient.

At eight twelve, headlights moved across the front window.

Rick was home.

The pizza arrived twenty minutes late.

Charles opened the box and stared as if the delivery driver had personally insulted Thanksgiving.

“This is cold.”

“It’s pizza,” Diane said. “Eat it.”

“There’s no salad?”

Lenora laughed once, sharply.

Her father looked up.

“What?”

“Nothing.”

“No, say it.”

She looked at him.

“I spent two days cooking an entire holiday meal so nobody would be inconvenienced, and now you’re asking where the salad is.”

Charles stared.

Diane slowly put down her slice.

Lenora had not meant to say it. But once spoken, the sentence opened a door.

Charles leaned back.

“You’re blaming me?”

“I’m blaming me.”

“For what?”

“For thinking this was my problem to solve.”

“What problem?”

“You and Amos not liking each other.”

“I never said I disliked him.”

“You don’t have to say everything directly, Dad.”

Diane looked at her daughter, then at her husband.

Charles’s mouth tightened.

“I came here to have Thanksgiving with my family.”

“So did Amos.”

“He has Rick.”

“And you have Mom.”

“That’s not the same.”

Lenora stared.

Charles heard himself.

He looked away.

Diane spoke first.

“Why isn’t it the same?”

Charles rubbed his jaw.

“I didn’t mean—”

“No,” Lenora said quietly. “You did.”

Her father’s eyes returned to hers.

She continued.

“You think because Amos is widowed, his family is somehow optional around married people.”

“I did not say that.”

“You said he has Rick like that means Rick should peel off from his own house and create a second Thanksgiving.”

Charles said nothing.

Lenora looked toward the empty dining table.

“That’s exactly what happened.”

Diane folded her napkin.

“Your daughter is right.”

Charles exhaled.

“I am not taking responsibility for Rick walking out with dinner.”

“No,” Diane said. “That part belongs to Rick.”

“Thank you.”

“And the rest belongs to all of us in different amounts.”

Charles looked deeply dissatisfied with shared accountability.

Lenora almost smiled.

Later, after her parents left, she stood alone in the kitchen with the pizza box still open.

The house smelled wrong.

Tomato sauce instead of sage.

Cardboard instead of turkey.

Cold cheese instead of browned butter.

She closed the box.

On the counter was a stack of recipe cards written in Gloria’s handwriting. Rick had copied them after his mother died, but he kept the originals in a plastic sleeve.

Lenora pulled out the macaroni recipe.

At the bottom, Gloria had added in blue ink:

Make extra. Somebody always comes hungry.

Lenora sat down.

She imagined Gloria hearing what had happened.

Not as a saint.

Not as an all-knowing dead mother.

As the opinionated woman Lenora had known for five years.

Gloria would have been furious.

But Lenora suspected she would also have made her sit down, eat something, and answer the only useful question after a mistake:

What are you going to do differently now?

When headlights finally moved across the wall, Lenora folded the recipe card and placed it back in its sleeve.

She was ready to begin answering.

After her parents left, Lenora opened the family group chat and scrolled backward.

There were months of messages from Amos.

Happy birthday.

Drive safe.

Tell Rick I found his drill.

Your mother’s surgery go okay?

Need anything from the store?

Nothing grand.

Belonging, she realized, was often built from boring sentences.

That made her own decision feel worse. She had treated family as a guest list when Amos had practiced it as repetition.

She typed:

Amos, I’m sorry.

Then deleted it.

Too quick.

Too easy.

Too centered on her relief.

Instead she wrote his name on a sticky note and placed it beside her keys.

Not because she might forget him.

Because tomorrow’s apology needed to begin with leaving the house, sitting across from him, and accepting that he might not help her feel better.

May you like

For once, she would not solve discomfort from a distance.

Lenora slept on the sofa for an hour before Rick returned, not because she meant to but because exhaustion won. When she woke, the room was dark and the untouched table still looked staged for people who had never arrived. She turned off the dining-room light. It felt like admitting the day was over. There would be no salvaging Thanksgiving. Only learning from it. Strange, she thought, how much easier repair became once she stopped trying to rescue the original version of events.

Related Stories

Other posts