Chapter 16 - The Family Tree

The assignment came home on a Thursday in a bright yellow folder.
BUILD YOUR FAMILY TREE.
Orien stared at the paper for so long that Evander assumed he was reading the instructions.
"Need help?"
"It's stupid."
Evander looked over his shoulder.
The worksheet showed a trunk with blank branches labeled Mother, Father, Grandparents, Siblings.
"Ah."
"It says siblings."
"You can put Caelan and Lucan."
"But they aren't."
"They're your stepbrothers."
"Not anymore if you're getting divorced."
Evander sat beside him.
"A court paper doesn't decide whether you care about someone."
"Then what do I write?"
That was harder.
Elise was his mother. Evander was his father. Nathan, Elise's boyfriend, mattered but was not family yet in the way Orien understood it. Seraphine had been his stepmother and would soon become his father's ex-wife. Caelan and Lucan were legally becoming former stepbrothers, a phrase so cold Evander refused to say aloud.
"Write what feels true," he said.
Orien frowned. "Teachers hate that answer."
"Then blame me."
The next evening, Caelan and Lucan were at the townhouse for dinner. Orien put the family-tree sheet in the center of the table.
"Do you guys count?"
Lucan looked offended. "Of course I count."
"I mean as brothers."
Caelan stopped chewing.
"Do you want us to?"
Orien shrugged. "Yeah."
"Then yes."
Lucan took a marker and wrote his own name on a branch before anyone could stop him.
"Your handwriting is terrible," Caelan said.
"Still counts."
Evander photographed the page before it disappeared into Orien's backpack.
At school the next day, Ms. Bell called him.
"I wanted you to know Orien changed the assignment."
Evander braced himself. "How?"
"He drew extra branches."
"Is that a problem?"
"No. I think it improved the worksheet."
That afternoon, Orien brought home the page with a note in red ink: Families are built in many ways. Thank you for showing us yours.
He taped it to the refrigerator beside Evander's weekly list.
Seraphine saw it Sunday when she came inside to pick up the boys.
She stood in front of the refrigerator for a long time.
Her own name was written in smaller letters at the side of the trunk, connected by a dotted line.
Former stepmom / still Seraphine.
She laughed softly through sudden tears.
"That's accurate."
Orien appeared behind her.
"I didn't know what to call you."
"You don't have to call me anything you don't want to."
"Can I still call you Seraphine?"
"I'd like that."
He nodded.
She looked at him.
"Orien, I have wanted to say something to you in person. Your dad said it should be when you were ready. Are you ready?"
He glanced at Evander, who was standing near the stairs.
Evander did not nod or prompt him.
Orien made the choice himself.
"Okay."
Seraphine sat at the table so they were closer to eye level.
"I am sorry for leaving your lunchbox empty. I'm sorry for telling Caelan not to share. I'm sorry for the times I made you feel like a guest in your own home. I was angry at your dad about things that were not your fault, and I convinced myself I was protecting my boys. I hurt you instead."
Orien picked at a scratch on the tabletop.
"Do I have to forgive you?"
Seraphine's eyes filled.
"No."
He looked up, surprised.
"Not now. Not later. Forgiveness isn't something you owe me because I apologized."
"Dr. Park said that too."
"She's smarter than I was."
Orien considered her for a long moment.
"I don't hate you."
Seraphine wiped one tear quickly.
"Thank you for telling me."
"But I don't want you to make my lunch."
The sentence could have sounded petty. It did not.
Seraphine nodded.
"Okay."
"Dad makes it weird now anyway. He puts notes in it."
Evander protested from the stairs. "One note."
"It said, 'Eat the apple.'"
"You keep bringing the apple home."
Lucan yelled from the living room, "Can I have his apple?"
The tension broke.
For the first time, the five of them laughed in the same room without pretending anything was fixed.
The family-tree assignment traveled farther than Orien expected.
Elise saw it when she picked him up on Friday. Nathan was with her, waiting by the door with two coffees.
Orien pointed to the dotted line beside Seraphine's name.
"She's still family but not married family."
Nathan studied the page carefully.
"Makes sense."
"What are you?"
Nathan nearly dropped his coffee.
Elise hid a smile.
"I'm Nathan," he said.
"That's not a family thing."
"Maybe that's enough for now."
Orien considered this and wrote Nathan? in pencil near his mother's branch.
Nathan laughed. "Question mark is fair."
That evening, Elise called Evander.
"I need you not to make a thing out of this."
"Excellent opening."
"Orien put Nathan on the family tree."
Evander's stomach tightened automatically.
He hated that reaction.
"Okay."
"He used a question mark."
"That's somehow worse."
Elise laughed.
"Are you okay?"
Evander looked at the refrigerator where Orien's weekly schedule hung.
"My first feeling is stupid."
"Feelings are allowed to be stupid."
"I want to be the unquestioned father."
"You are his father. Nathan existing doesn't put you on probation."
Evander knew that intellectually. Emotionally, the same scarcity Seraphine had struggled with lived in him too.
"I told Caelan he doesn't have to choose between me and Warren. I suppose life enjoys consistency."
"Rude of it."
When Orien came home Sunday, Evander did not ask about Nathan. He waited.
At dinner, Orien volunteered, "Nathan burned pancakes."
"Badly?"
"Smoke alarm badly."
"Tragic."
"Mom says you make better pancakes."
The compliment warmed him before he could stop it.
Then Orien added, "But Nathan makes better eggs."
Evander put a hand over his heart. "Betrayal."
Orien laughed.
The joke did something useful. It allowed the truth into the room without requiring anyone to shrink.
Later, Evander added a small note to the family-tree assignment before returning it to the refrigerator:
No branch has to disappear for another one to grow.
Orien read it and rolled his eyes.
"That's cheesy."
May you like
"I know."
He left it there anyway.