scribe

Chapter 6 - WHAT “FAIR” MEANT

Saturday morning, Laura made pancakes.

This was unusual enough that both boys came downstairs before she called them.

Beau climbed onto his chair and announced that he wanted three. Jasper poured orange juice.

Vincent sat at the table scrolling through work messages.

For a few minutes, everything felt normal.

Then Beau said, “Jasper has a school guitar now.”

Laura flipped a pancake too hard. It folded in half.

“He might,” she said.

“Mr. Tate said I can borrow one if you sign,” Jasper explained.

Vincent looked up. “Why wouldn’t we sign?”

Laura glanced at him. “Because we don’t know the replacement cost.”

Vincent shrugged. “We’ll ask.”

Jasper noticed how quickly the problem became solvable when Vincent heard it aloud.

Laura noticed too.

“I was going to ask,” she said.

“I know.”

Her tone sharpened slightly. “I’m not trying to keep you from playing, Jasper.”

“I didn’t say you were.”

“Your face says things.”

Jasper looked down at his plate.

Beau stopped swinging his feet.

Vincent put his phone face down.

“Let’s not do this at breakfast.”

Laura exhaled. “Fine.”

Jasper ate one pancake and said he was full.

As he stood, Laura said, “Sit down, please.”

He sat.

She leaned both hands on the counter.

“I think we need to clear something up.”

Jasper waited.

“Beau getting lessons doesn’t mean we love music more when he plays it.”

Jasper almost said, I know.

Laura continued. “We’re trying to be fair. You had two years of lessons. Beau has had none.”

There was that word.

Fair.

Jasper looked at Vincent. “Is that what you think too?”

Vincent hesitated long enough to answer.

“I think we’re doing the best we can with what we have.”

“That’s not what I asked.”

Beau’s eyes moved from one adult to the other.

Vincent leaned back.

“Yes,” he said. “I think it’s fair for Beau to get a chance.”

Jasper nodded.

Laura seemed relieved.

Then Jasper asked, “When I got two years, was that my whole turn?”

Neither parent spoke.

He continued before he lost courage.

“Like, if I liked it enough to keep going, did that still count as finished because Beau hadn’t started yet?”

Laura’s face tightened. “Nobody said finished.”

“But nobody said when it starts again.”

“We don’t know when.”

“That’s what finished feels like.”

The room went still.

Jasper hated the sound of his own voice when he said things like that. It made him feel dramatic, even when he spoke quietly.

Beau pushed his plate away.

“I don’t need eight lessons,” he said.

Laura turned immediately. “This isn’t about you giving anything up.”

“But Jasper wants lessons.”

“And you do too.”

Beau looked at Jasper.

Jasper shook his head. “Keep your lessons.”

“I can give you four.”

“You can’t split a package like cookies.”

Beau frowned. “Why not?”

Jasper almost laughed.

Vincent did, once, softly. The tension loosened for a second.

Then Laura sat at the table.

“Jasper, I need you to understand something.”

He braced himself.

“When your lessons stopped, your dad and I were scared. We didn’t tell you how scared because you were ten. We were two months behind on the car. The electric bill was late. I was putting groceries on a credit card.”

Jasper listened.

“We thought stopping one activity would be temporary. Then we got caught up, but there were other things. Beau needed after-school care when my hours changed. Your dad had dental work. The washing machine died.”

“Okay.”

“And when Beau asked about guitar, we thought…” She stopped.

“What?”

Laura looked uncomfortable.

“We thought maybe it was his turn to have something that was his.”

Jasper looked toward the case by the wall.

“My guitar.”

Laura closed her eyes briefly.

“I hear how that sounds.”

Vincent rubbed his jaw.

Jasper did not raise his voice.

He did not need to.

“His thing that was his was my thing.”

Beau looked stricken.

Jasper turned to him immediately. “I’m not mad at you.”

“I know.”

But Beau did not look convinced.

Vincent spoke. “We should’ve bought him a different guitar.”

Laura looked at him. “With what money?”

“A used one. Something.”

“And then we’d be having a conversation about why we bought Beau a guitar when Jasper already had one sitting untouched.”

Jasper heard the key word.

“Untouched.”

Laura looked at him.

“I stopped touching it because my string broke and nobody replaced it.”

Vincent’s face changed.

Jasper continued, quieter now. “Then when you finally bought strings, Beau was already using it.”

Nobody answered.

That detail had been small enough to disappear from family memory.

Not from his.

Vincent stood and walked to the case.

He opened the front pocket, searched for a moment, and pulled out a sealed packet of strings.

Jasper stared.

“When did you buy those?”

Vincent looked at the receipt tucked inside.

“Three months ago.”

Three months.

Before Beau’s lessons.

Vincent sat back down slowly.

“I forgot these were here.”

Jasper nodded.

That was the problem in its simplest form.

Nobody had chosen to hurt him.

They had just forgotten the thing he was waiting for, then remembered a new thing for someone else.

Laura looked at the unopened strings.

Her voice was smaller when she spoke.

“I don’t think we’ve been using the word fair correctly.”

Jasper looked at her.

May you like

For the first time, she did not immediately explain what she meant.

That made him listen.

Related Stories

Other posts