Chapter 9 - The First Honest Rule

Dr. Malcolm Hall arrived on Tuesday at three.
Orson saw his car and hid beneath the library table.
Seraphine found him there with the silver lion tucked against his chest.
“You’re not supposed to carry that without an adult,” she said.
“I’m with you.”
“That is technically clever and still not what your father meant.”
Orson frowned.
Seraphine sat on the rug several feet away. Her ribs were improving, but lowering herself still required care.
“Why don’t you want to see Dr. Hall?”
“He asks feelings.”
“That sounds inconvenient.”
Orson studied her, unsure whether she was joking.
“He asks if I’m angry.”
“Are you?”
“Yes.”
“Then at least that question is efficient.”
A reluctant smile appeared and vanished.
“He tells Father things.”
That mattered.
“What things?”
“Everything.”
Seraphine did not know whether that was true.
“Let’s ask him.”
“No.”
“We can ask together.”
Orson hugged the lion tighter.
“What if he leaves too?”
“Doctors leave at the end of appointments.”
“That’s not what I mean.”
“I know.”
Seraphine looked toward the rainy window.
“Orson, I need to change something I told you.”
His face tightened immediately.
“What?”
“I said I wasn’t walking away.”
His breathing changed.
She kept her voice steady.
“That was true in the gallery. It is not a promise that I will never leave a room, never take a day off, never change jobs, or never have a life outside this house.”
His lower lip trembled.
“You said—”
“I said what I could promise in that moment. I should have been clearer.”
He backed farther beneath the table.
Seraphine wanted to soften the truth until it stopped hurting him.
She did not.
“I will not disappear without telling you if I have a choice. I will not lie and say forever when I mean today. And if I have to leave because I’m hurt or unsafe, I will tell you why.”
Orson’s eyes filled.
“So you might go.”
“Yes.”
He looked devastated.
Seraphine’s own eyes burned, but she continued.
“People can love you and still go to another room. People can care about you and go home at night. People can leave a job without it meaning you caused it.”
“Celia left because I was bad.”
“No.”
“How do you know?”
“Because I spoke to her.”
Orson crawled forward so quickly he struck his head lightly on the table.
“You saw her?”
“Yes.”
“Where is she?”
“At her own home. She has another job.”
“Did she ask about me?”
Seraphine smiled. “The first thing she asked was whether you were safe.”
Orson began to cry silently.
“Why didn’t she come back?”
“Because adults made decisions you could not control.”
“Father?”
Seraphine did not rescue Leander from the answer.
“Yes. Your father made one of those decisions.”
Orson looked toward the library door.
Leander was standing there.
He had heard.
The boy’s face hardened.
“You made her go.”
“Yes,” Leander said.
“Why?”
“I thought she stole something. I did not listen when she said she hadn’t.”
“You didn’t listen to me either.”
“No.”
Leander came no closer.
“I’m sorry.”
Orson threw the silver lion down.
Not at anyone.
Onto the rug.
The sound was dull.
Seraphine felt Leander tense, but he did not speak.
“I hate you!” Orson screamed.
Leander’s face flinched.
“I know.”
“I want Celia!”
“I know.”
“I want Mama!”
That broke something in the room.
Leander looked away.
Seraphine let the silence remain.
Then Dr. Hall appeared in the doorway behind Leander and quietly removed his coat.
He was in his sixties, with a worn leather case and no visible alarm at the scene.
“May I sit on the floor?” he asked Orson.
“No.”
“All right.”
He sat in a chair instead.
“May your father stay?”
Orson shook his head violently.
Leander went pale.
Dr. Hall nodded. “Then he leaves.”
Leander did.
No argument.
At the threshold, Orson shouted, “And don’t listen outside!”
Leander closed the door behind him.
For the next forty minutes, Dr. Hall explained privacy in words a five-year-old could understand. He told Orson there were some things he had to share if someone was in danger, but feelings were not reports to be delivered to his father.
At the end, Orson looked at Seraphine.
“Can we make a rule?”
“What rule?”
“No more forever promises.”
Seraphine’s throat tightened.
May you like
“Yes.”
It was the first rule in Vale House that made Orson calmer instead of more afraid.