Chapter 2 - The Daughter-in-Law Who Never Was

The next morning, Guinevere did not cook breakfast.
She sat in a small café three miles from Hawthorne House with a mug of peppermint tea going cold between her hands and searched for a woman who, according to Wilhelmina, had made soup through morning sickness, scrubbed baseboards at eight months pregnant, hosted twenty-four people two days after a prenatal glucose test, and once polished silver while in early labor because “a family dinner is still a family dinner.”
For nearly two years, this mythical daughter-in-law had been Guinevere’s invisible rival.
Wilhelmina always called her “Mrs. Prescott’s daughter-in-law.” Never by a first name. Never with a photograph. Never with a story that could be checked.
Guinevere searched the names of every Prescott in Wilhelmina’s social circle. She checked charity boards, country-club event photos, funeral notices, wedding announcements and public social-media pages.
There were Prescotts.
But none matched the woman Wilhelmina described.
At ten-thirty, Guinevere called Lydia Haines, a retired florist who had known Wilhelmina for thirty years and who possessed both a good memory and no fear of gossip.
“Mrs. Prescott?” Lydia repeated. “June Prescott?”
“Maybe. Does she have a son?”
“June? Two daughters. Both married. Why?”
“Did either daughter marry someone whose family—”
“No sons,” Lydia said. “So no daughter-in-law. Unless June acquired one by sorcery.”
Guinevere almost smiled.
“Is there another Mrs. Prescott Wilhelmina could mean?”
Lydia thought for a moment. “Not that I know. Why do you ask?”
Guinevere looked out the window at passing cars.
“No reason.”
But there was a reason.
By noon, the reason had become a certainty.
The perfect daughter-in-law did not exist.
Wilhelmina had invented her.
Guinevere drove back to Hawthorne House with a strange calm settling over her. For months, every comparison had made her feel inadequate. Now the comparisons felt different. Not cruel observations. Tools.
And tools were used for a purpose.
She entered through the side door and found Wilhelmina arranging white roses in the breakfast room.
“Where were you?” Wilhelmina asked.
“Out.”
“You missed lunch preparation.”
“I know.”
Wilhelmina clipped a stem with silver shears. “Mrs. Prescott’s daughter-in-law plans meals for the week every Sunday. It prevents this sort of chaos.”
Guinevere put her purse on the chair.
“What is her name?”
The shears stopped.
Wilhelmina did not look up. “Whose?”
“Mrs. Prescott’s daughter-in-law.”
A tiny pause.
“Clarissa.”
Guinevere waited.
“Clarissa what?”
“Prescott, obviously.”
“That would be Mrs. Prescott’s daughter, unless she married her own brother.”
Wilhelmina’s head lifted.
For the first time, Guinevere saw uncertainty cross her face.
It disappeared quickly.
“Do not be insolent.”
“I called Lydia Haines.”
Wilhelmina’s jaw tightened.
“She says June Prescott has two daughters and no sons.”
“I am not referring to June.”
“Then which Mrs. Prescott?”
“You are being absurd.”
“No. I’m asking for a name.”
Wilhelmina set the shears down very carefully.
“Your obsession with proving me wrong is unbecoming.”
Guinevere felt the baby move again, a firm pressure under her ribs.
“I think you made her up.”
Wilhelmina’s eyes hardened.
“I think,” Guinevere continued, “you needed someone impossible to compare me to. Someone who never gets tired, never says no, never feels sick, never needs money, never needs help and never disagrees. Because a real woman might contradict you.”
“Be careful.”
“Yesterday you hit me.”
“You are determined to dramatize that.”
“And last night I heard you talking about papers you want me to sign before the baby is born.”
That landed.
Wilhelmina’s expression went still.
The room seemed suddenly colder.
“What were you doing outside my study?”
“Getting water.”
“Eavesdropping.”
“Listening after I heard my own name.”
Wilhelmina stepped closer.
“You live in this house because I allow it.”
“Barnaby told me his father left the house in a family trust.”
Another silence.
Then Wilhelmina smiled.
It was a small smile without warmth.
“You know very little about this family’s affairs.”
“I’m beginning to notice.”
Wilhelmina turned back to the flowers.
“The papers are routine. Estate continuity. Protection for the child.”
“Then I’ll have my own attorney review them.”
The shears struck the table with a sharp metallic sound.
“There is no need to involve strangers.”
“A lawyer isn’t a stranger when she represents me.”
“You have no idea what legal fees cost.”
“I’ll manage.”
Wilhelmina faced her.
“You think independence is a performance. You have never had to preserve anything worth protecting.”
Guinevere felt anger rise but forced it down.
“What exactly are you protecting?”
Wilhelmina’s face closed.
At that moment, Barnaby entered through the back hall carrying a leather briefcase. He glanced between them.
“What happened?”
“Your wife has decided I am a liar,” Wilhelmina said.
Guinevere looked at him. “Did you know the Prescott daughter-in-law was imaginary?”
Barnaby blinked. “What?”
“Your mother’s perfect pregnant daughter-in-law. Did you ever meet her?”
He looked at Wilhelmina.
That was enough.
“You never questioned it,” Guinevere said.
“Guin, I don’t keep track of Mom’s friends.”
“No. You don’t keep track of anything she says as long as I’m the one absorbing it.”
Wilhelmina sighed. “There. More melodrama.”
Guinevere picked up her purse.
“I’m going upstairs.”
Barnaby followed her with his eyes. “We need to talk tonight.”
“Yes,” she said. “We do.”
In the guest room, she opened the closet to hang up her coat.
A blue leather folder sat on the top shelf.
She had never seen it before.
Across the front, embossed in small gold letters, were the words:
ASHCOMBE FAMILY CONTINUITY — G. A.
Guinevere took it down.
Inside was a stack of tabbed documents and a yellow note in Wilhelmina’s handwriting.
NOTARY — THURSDAY, 3:00 P.M.
BARNABY PRESENT.
NO OUTSIDE COUNSEL.
May you like
Guinevere’s pulse quickened.
The last line was underlined twice.