Chapter 19 - The Deposition

Dorian’s attorneys spent seven hours asking Rosalind questions.
The deposition took place in a downtown conference room with no jury, no judge, and no dramatic objections for television cameras.
That made it more exhausting.
Every answer mattered.
“When did you first become aware of Hart & Vale Holdings?”
“As a child, generally. As an active company in which I still held an interest, the week my daughter was born.”
“Your father discussed the company at home, did he not?”
“Occasionally.”
“So you knew he owned part of it.”
“I knew he had once owned part of it. I was told his interest had no remaining value.”
“By whom?”
“My mother, based on information she received after his death. And later by members of the Vale family.”
The attorney shifted.
“Were you under significant emotional stress during the week you claim to have discovered the forged consent?”
Naomi said, “You may answer.”
“I had given birth. My husband had assaulted me. I was under stress.”
“Could that stress affect your memory?”
“It could affect anyone’s memory.”
“Did it affect yours?”
“Not about whether I signed away a company interest worth millions of dollars.”
The attorney looked down.
Later he asked whether Rosalind sometimes forgot appointments during pregnancy.
She said yes.
Whether she relied on Cornelius to handle paperwork after her mother died.
Yes.
Whether she signed a limited power of attorney without reading every page.
Yes.
Whether she ever told Cornelius to “just handle all the estate stuff.”
“Yes. Informally.”
“Then is it possible you also authorized him to handle Hart & Vale?”
“No.”
“How can you be sure?”
“Because the power of attorney is limited. My lawyer can show you the text. And because authorizing my husband to collect documents is not the same as authorizing him to give away six million dollars.”
For the first time, Dorian’s attorney looked irritated.
Around hour five, he turned to the night of labor.
Rosalind’s body stiffened before she could stop it.
“Mrs. Vale, is your anger toward the defendants influenced by your marital dispute with Cornelius Vale?”
“It would be strange if it weren’t influenced at all.”
“So this lawsuit is personal.”
“It concerns my money, my father’s company, my forged signature, and people in my husband’s family. Of course it is personal.”
“Did Cornelius strike you after you raised your voice?”
Naomi objected to the characterization but allowed the factual answer.
“Yes.”
“Did that event cause you to reinterpret ordinary business decisions as malicious?”
Rosalind looked directly at the attorney.
“No. The documents did that.”
Naomi did not smile, but Mara later said she nearly did.
Then came the board meeting minutes.
“Isn’t it possible you joined by phone briefly from your medical appointment?”
“No.”
“Could you have forgotten?”
“No.”
“Why are you so certain?”
Naomi slid an exhibit across the table.
Rosalind’s phone records showed no call to ValeConnect or any Hart & Vale number during the meeting.
Hospital Wi-Fi logs, obtained through a narrow subpoena with Rosalind’s consent, showed her device connected to the maternity clinic network.
ValeConnect server logs showed no session under her name.
Most damagingly, the account listed as “RHV” in the meeting record had connected from an IP address assigned to Vale Property Group headquarters.
The attorney went quiet.
Rosalind understood then why evidence mattered.
Memory could be called emotional.
A woman in labor could be called confused.
A wife leaving her husband could be called vindictive.
But an IP address did not care whether anyone liked her.
At 6:12 p.m., the deposition ended.
Rosalind stepped outside into early winter darkness.
Cornelius was across the street leaving his own lawyer’s office.
Their eyes met.
Neither crossed.
The parenting order prohibited casual contact, and neither tested it.
For a second Rosalind remembered the front door opening after midnight, the keys dropping into the bowl, the relief she had felt before she understood who had walked in.
Then Cornelius looked at his watch.
He was due at the supervised center in twenty minutes.
May you like
He turned toward the parking garage and hurried.
He arrived for Clara’s visit four minutes early.