Chapter 23 - THE BIRTHDAY CALL

Eira had stopped trusting memory completely, which worried Amaris almost as much as the lies had. If a birthday felt lonely, Eira wanted a call log. If she remembered her mother being late, she wanted an email. If Cassian said an event happened one way, she wanted to know whether a timestamp existed.
Her therapist gently named the pattern.
"You are checking because checking makes you feel safer."
"Because people can remember wrong."
"Yes."
"And people can lie."
"Yes."
"Then why shouldn't I check?"
The therapist smiled. "Sometimes checking is useful. But you also deserve a life where every feeling doesn't need a document before you're allowed to have it."
Eira frowned.
"If you felt hurt on your birthday, that feeling was real even before you knew whether your mother called."
Eira thought about that for days. She had become so focused on proving the history that she had nearly forgotten the child inside the history. The eight-year-old who waited for a call had been hurt whether Cassian lied deliberately, forgot, misunderstood or destroyed the phone.
Still, the birthday mattered because it was one of the memories Cassian had narrated for her. When Rosalie admitted Amaris had called, Eira wanted the actual record. Not to prove she was allowed to be hurt. To put the memory back in the correct shape.
So she asked Amaris. And this time, Amaris answered without turning the answer into a weapon.
The birthday call became the first memory Eira wanted corrected completely.
Not interpreted.
Not softened.
Corrected.
She asked Amaris what had happened.
Amaris opened her old phone records.
“I called at 6:41,” she said. “Then 6:49. Then 7:18.”
“Did Dad answer?”
“The first time.”
“What did he say?”
“That you were opening gifts and he would have you call me after cake.”
“Did I?”
“No.”
“Did you call again?”
“Yes.”
“Why didn’t you tell me later?”
“I did.”
Eira frowned.
“When?”
“The next morning, I sent you a voice message.”
Eira reached for her tablet.
The message thread only went back four months because of the block.
“Where is it?”
“I still have my copy.”
Amaris played it.
Happy birthday, bug. I’m sorry we missed each other tonight. I love you bigger than eight candles and every candle after that. Call me when you can.
Eira covered her mouth.
She remembered waking the next morning and asking Cassian if Mom had called.
He had said, She sent a late text. We’ll deal with it later.
Later had never come.
Eira cried quietly.
Amaris did not tell her not to.
After a few minutes, Eira said, “Can I send it to Dad?”
Amaris hesitated.
“It’s your birthday message.”
“I want him to hear it.”
“Okay.”
Eira forwarded the audio through the family communication thread.
Then she typed:
You said she did not call. This is what she sent me that I never got.
Cassian replied eleven minutes later.
I remember. I was angry because she had challenged the birthday schedule that week. I decided she did not get to interrupt the party after being difficult about timing. I told myself I would let you call later. I didn’t. Then when you asked, I minimized it instead of admitting what I had done. I am sorry.
Eira read it twice.
Then she typed:
Why didn’t you just say you were mad at her?
His reply came slowly.
Because then I would have had to admit I was using your call to punish her.
Eira stared at the screen.
Amaris did not read over her shoulder.
Eira showed her voluntarily.
Amaris read the message and sat back.
“That’s the truth,” she said.
“You knew?”
“I suspected.”
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
“Because suspicion is not proof. And because I was afraid if I told you what I suspected, I would be doing another version of what he did—giving you my story about the other parent.”
Eira rested her chin on her knees.
“So what do I do with all the true things?”
Amaris thought for a moment.
“You don’t have to do anything with them today.”
Eira looked at the old voice message again.
Eight candles.
Every candle after that.
She saved the audio to a folder called MOM.
May you like
Not EVIDENCE.
That distinction mattered too.