scribe

Chapter 15

The Bride Who Came Without Flowers

Ava came to Daniel's office carrying an ordinary paper bag. Her wedding dress was gone, replaced by dark jeans and a wool coat. She looked tired in a way that expensive makeup could not correct. Daniel met her in a conference room, not the private office where she'd sometimes sprawled on his couch and talked about business ideas while he worked.

"I brought back Lucy's gift," she said, placing the bag on the table. "The coordinator found it in the car. I wasn't sure if you wanted it."

Daniel looked inside. The silver picture frame lay in its ribboned box. Evan's card had been tucked beneath the lid, its message written in Emily's handwriting from his dictation. Something tightened in Daniel's chest.

"They bought that for you," he said. "If they ever want you to have it, they'll decide."

Ava sat without being invited. "I know I did something awful."

"Which part?"

She looked up quickly. "All of it. Asking Mom to keep them away. Not checking how it would be done. Making it sound as if they were the problem."

"Why did you want them excluded?"

"I wanted one day when I didn't feel second." Ava's voice cracked, but she kept speaking. "When I was little, people introduced me as Carol's daughter. You were Richard's son, the real heir. I thought if the pictures showed just the four of us, people would finally see me as belonging to the family."

"You thought you had to take their place to find yours?"

"It sounds horrible when you say it."

"It's what happened."

She traced the edge of the table. "Your kids never did anything. Lucy was always trying to sit beside me. I told myself she would interrupt or ask questions at the wrong time. That wasn't true. I knew it wasn't true."

Daniel remembered Ava at six, small and solemn, standing at the threshold of his bedroom with a toy dinosaur she'd found at a school fair. He had been grieving his mother and resentful of Carol's arrival. Ava had held out the dinosaur without speaking. He had taken it and said thank you. It was a good memory. He refused to use it to excuse the present one.

"Who sent Carol the photographs?" he asked.

Ava swallowed. "I did. She asked for clear pictures for security, and I pulled them from our family message thread. I thought the guard would keep them privately."

"Did you know the guard was told not to admit them?"

"Yes."

She didn't look away. Daniel was grateful for the honesty and angry that it had taken so much to obtain.

"Mark won't speak to me except about practical things," Ava added. "He thinks I should tell you about the studio payments."

"Then tell me."

"Mom gave the studio thirteen thousand nine hundred dollars to settle a supplier dispute. She said the money came from her planning business and would be repaid after the wedding. I signed a document acknowledging the transfer. I didn't know it was included in what you paid Harrow. Not for certain."

Daniel heard the qualification. "Not for certain."

"I suspected. I should have looked."

"Yes."

He asked which supplier had received the settlement. Ava named a fabrics importer that had delivered materials for a hotel project canceled midway through construction. She had owed the amount long before she was engaged. Daniel had not known the business was struggling that badly because she sent photographs of showroom openings and spoke about an exciting pipeline of clients. He realized they had both treated success as a language they were expected to speak at family dinners, even when it left important facts hidden.

"You could have told me the studio was in trouble," he said.

"I know. I was afraid you'd say I'd failed."

"I might have asked difficult questions. That's not the same as deciding you weren't worth helping."

Ava lowered her eyes. The irony was unmistakable: she'd concealed a failure to preserve his approval, while he had spent his savings seeking hers. Their mutual fear had not made them more honest with one another. It had simply given Carol room to manage the distance between them.

Ava rubbed her eyes. "I can pay some back. I still have equipment to sell. But there are vendor balances and a deposit the venue won't return. If I could borrow a little time, perhaps I could make this right before it becomes public."

Daniel sat back. The old bargain had appeared in a new voice: help me solve this before anyone knows, and I'll become the person you need me to be. He recognized his own desire to accept it. Ava had been his little sister once, and he still wanted to spare her unnecessary pain.

"I'll cooperate in a fair repayment agreement," he said. "I'm not giving you new money, and I'm not keeping records hidden to protect appearances."

Ava looked toward the bag. "Will Lucy ever forgive me?"

"I don't know. She might. She might not. You can apologize without knowing the result."

"Could I write her a letter?"

"You can write one and give it to us. Emily and I will decide when to offer it to her. No requests for a reply. No telling her you're sad or that your wedding was ruined. She doesn't carry your feelings."

Ava nodded, tears gathering but not yet falling. "I used to think you forgave everything because you were stronger than the rest of us."

"I forgave things because I was afraid of losing everyone," Daniel said. "That's not the same thing."

He walked her to the door. She left the bag and the frame on the table, but when she reached the hallway she turned back.

"I did want you at the wedding," she said. "I thought if you were there and the kids weren't, I could have both worlds."

May you like

"You couldn't," he replied. "I'm their father. I don't come in without them when they've been singled out for being mine."

After she left, Daniel stood by the conference-room window and watched city traffic move below. He realized an apology could be sincere and still incomplete, and that refusing the request attached to it did not make the apology worthless. Somewhere inside that distinction might be a way for his family to grow without asking the children to make themselves smaller.

Related Stories

Other posts