Chapter 25 - WHO CHOSE THE WATER

After the interview, Aldric remained alone in the consultation room for several minutes. He had expected Melusine's admission to settle something inside him. Instead it created a sharper boundary between explanation and forgiveness. Fear explained why she had obeyed Pell. It did not move Eirlys's hands back onto the stone coping. Love, if it had existed once, did not erase later cruelty. Aldric found unexpected relief in allowing those facts to coexist. He did not need one final label for Melusine. The court could judge her acts. Eirlys could someday judge the relationship. He could simply maintain the boundary required now.
Ormond's final sentence followed Aldric home.
Ask Melusine who chose the pool.
He told himself it was manipulation.
Then he told himself manipulation could still contain facts.
The next morning he requested a recorded interview with Melusine. Sabine attended. So did Harrow. Melusine's solicitor sat beside her with a yellow legal pad.
Aldric remained standing until Sabine said, "Sit. This is not a confrontation room."
He sat.
Melusine looked at him.
"Felix said something to you."
"He said to ask who chose the pool."
Her eyes closed.
That was answer enough.
Aldric's voice hardened. "You chose it."
"Yes."
Sabine did not interrupt.
Melusine folded her hands tightly.
"Pell said I needed to create a visible child-endangerment event that could be blamed on household negligence. He suggested stairs, a loose gate near the road, medication confusion, several things."
Aldric stared at her.
"And you selected the pool."
"Yes."
"Why?"
"Because I thought I could control it."
The words filled the room with terrible familiarity.
Control.
Aldric's own favorite illusion.
Melusine continued. "The shallow end was less than four feet. I knew you were on the south lawn. I knew Bram was nearby. I thought the drainage lip would stop the chair. I thought I could make it look frightening without letting her fall."
"Then why the second push?"
Melusine's breathing became uneven.
"Pell called. He said Julian would pay if I failed. He said Eirlys had to enter the water or the footage was useless."
Aldric's hands clenched.
"So you removed her fingers."
"Yes."
"One by one."
"Yes."
"While she begged you."
Melusine looked at him.
"Yes."
The solicitor touched her arm.
"You don't have to-"
"I do," Melusine said.
She looked back at Aldric.
"I need to say it without Pell in the sentence. I removed her hands. I pushed the chair again. I did that."
Aldric expected satisfaction.
Instead he felt only exhaustion.
"Did you love her?"
The question surprised everyone.
Melusine's face broke.
"Yes."
Aldric almost stood.
"Do not insult her."
"I am not asking that to excuse me."
"You terrorized her. You told her Lenore left because she was difficult."
"I know."
"You made her afraid to speak to me."
"I know."
"That is not love."
Melusine wiped her face.
"No. It was not love by the time I was doing those things. It was fear wearing love's name because I was too cowardly to admit what I had become."
The room fell silent.
Aldric looked at Sabine.
She gave him nothing. No instruction. No moral answer.
This part belonged to him.
He turned back to Melusine.
"You will never be alone with Eirlys again."
Melusine nodded.
"I know."
"You will not ask her to forgive you."
Another nod.
"If, when she is older, she chooses to know anything about you, that choice will be hers."
Melusine swallowed.
"Yes."
Aldric rose.
At the door, she said his name.
He stopped but did not turn.
"There is one more thing."
He waited.
"The day before the pool, Eirlys hid something from me. A folded paper from Lenore's old desk. I tried to take it. She put it inside her cardigan. Later it was gone."
Aldric turned now.
"What paper?"
"I don't know. It had a drawing of a door on it."
Sabine stood.
"What kind of door?"
Melusine closed her eyes, remembering.
"Blue. With a silver number five."
Aldric and Sabine looked at each other.
May you like
Eirlys's fifth birthday was five weeks away.
And somewhere, Lenore had left one final message marked with the number five.