scribe

Chapter 8

Letters That Never Arrived

The box had belonged to Thomas Voss.

Sabrina found it in the back of a locked cabinet in his study, beneath tax returns and insurance policies. Thomas had labeled it simply C.V. RECORDS.

Inside were adoption documents, court filings, notes from attorneys, and twenty-three letters from Maristella.

Every envelope was unopened.

Every one had been returned.

RETURN TO SENDER.

NO SUCH RESIDENT.

ADDRESS UNKNOWN.

Caelan spread them across Sabrina's dining table in chronological order.

The first had been written when he was two.

The last when he was nineteen.

"Why did Thomas keep these?" he asked.

Sabrina sat opposite him, visibly shaken.

"I didn't know he had them."

"They were returned to Maristella. How did he get them?"

Sabrina picked up one envelope carefully.

"Maybe she sent copies during the court case."

Caelan opened the legal folder.

One document contained a letter from Maristella's attorney accusing August Romano's office of interfering with correspondence. Another response denied it.

A third, handwritten note from Thomas read: Sabrina does not want to discuss. Keep in case Caelan asks someday.

Caelan pushed back from the table.

"He knew."

Sabrina covered her mouth.

Thomas Voss had been the gentlest man Caelan knew. He coached youth baseball, repaired neighbors' porches without accepting money, and cried every year during the same Christmas movie. Caelan had built morality partly from Thomas's example.

Now even that foundation cracked.

"Maybe he was planning to tell you," Sabrina whispered.

"Someday. Everyone loves someday."

He picked up the first letter.

The envelope was addressed to Master Caelan Voss, care of Sabrina Voss.

His hands trembled.

"Can I read it?"

Sabrina nodded.

The letter itself had been copied into the court record.

My beautiful boy,

You may never receive this. If you do, I hope someone reads it aloud until you are old enough to read it yourself. I want you to know that I did not leave because I stopped loving you. I am trying to bring you home. If I fail, it will not mean I wanted a life without you. It will mean adults with more power than me decided they knew what was best.

Caelan stopped.

He could not continue.

Sabrina cried silently across from him.

"I am sorry."

He folded the copy carefully.

"Did you ever intercept her mail?"

"No."

"Did Thomas?"

"I don't know."

"Did August?"

"I suspected his lawyers redirected things. I never proved it."

Caelan looked at the returned envelopes.

"Why didn't you tell me once I turned eighteen?"

Sabrina answered with painful honesty.

"Because by then I had spent eighteen years being your mother. I was afraid the truth would turn me into the woman who stole you."

"Did you?"

She flinched.

"I don't know anymore."

Caelan softened despite himself.

"You raised me."

Sabrina looked up.

"That doesn't erase what I should have done."

"No."

"But does it erase being your mother?"

Caelan stared at the woman who had sat beside him through fevers, science fairs, heartbreak, and funerals. Biology had rearranged his family, but it could not delete history.

"No," he said. "It doesn't."

Sabrina began to sob.

Caelan did not cross the table to hold her.

Not yet.

But he stayed.

They spent four hours scanning every document.

Near the bottom of the box, Caelan found something unexpected: a letter addressed to him in Thomas's handwriting, dated eight months before Thomas died.

Caelan,

There is a truth about your adoption I have lacked the courage to tell you. Sabrina loves you beyond measure. So do I. That love became an excuse for silence, and silence became habit. If I do not tell you myself, I hope these records do what I failed to do.

The letter ended abruptly.

Perhaps Thomas had intended to continue.

Perhaps illness had intervened.

Caelan held the page for a long time.

"He tried," Sabrina said.

"He started."

"Is that different?"

"Yes."

But not entirely.

Caelan scanned the letter and sent the entire archive to Maristella.

He did not send it to Evadne.

He kept his promise.

That evening Maristella called him for the first time since the DNA result.

Caelan almost did not answer.

"Hello?"

Her voice shook.

"I received the files."

"Okay."

"Those letters... I thought they were destroyed."

"Thomas kept copies from the court record."

Silence.

Then Maristella said, "Thank you for sending them."

Caelan stared at Julian's photograph on his own kitchen counter.

"I don't know what to call you."

Maristella inhaled sharply.

"You don't have to call me anything."

"You're my biological mother."

"Yes."

"Sabrina is my mother too."

"Yes."

There was no competition in Maristella's answer.

That mattered.

Caelan looked at the unfinished letter from Thomas.

"I think everyone in this family confused love with ownership."

Maristella was quiet.

May you like

"Including me," she said.

For the first time, Caelan believed they might eventually speak without the past shouting over them.

Related Stories

Other posts