scribe

Chapter 12 - The Draft

Seraphine wrote seventeen versions of an apology.

Renee rejected sixteen.

The first said: I regret my actions.

“Too vague.”

The second said: I allowed an upsetting interaction to become physical.

Renee crossed out the entire sentence.

“That is exactly the language your staff called out.”

The third blamed stress.

The fourth mentioned humiliation.

The fifth described Imogen’s restraint before Seraphine’s attack.

The sixth included the phrase “both of us.”

Renee deleted it.

“There is no both-sides version of who initiated physical contact.”

By the tenth draft, Seraphine was furious.

“Nothing is good enough for you.”

“Correct.”

Seraphine looked at her.

Renee folded her arms.

“You are trying to write a statement people will forgive. Write one that is true even if they don’t.”

That changed the exercise.

Seraphine opened a blank page.

She wrote:

At the Meridian Foundation gala, a server told me she could not change a seating arrangement I wanted changed. I responded with insults, then tried to kick her twice and strike her. She defended herself and did not retaliate. My earlier statement minimized my responsibility and wrongly suggested the video lacked important context. It did not. I was the person who made the situation unsafe.

She stopped.

Renee read over her shoulder.

“Keep going.”

Seraphine’s hands hovered over the keyboard.

I have spent my career advising people to protect trust with honest communication. I did the opposite when honesty embarrassed me.

She stopped again.

“What do I say about why?”

“The truth.”

“I don’t fully know the truth.”

“Then don’t invent one.”

Seraphine thought about Camille.

About banquet kitchens.

About how she would never have kicked Gideon.

She typed:

I am beginning to confront the fact that I treated a woman differently because I saw her as service staff and assumed my status gave me the right to demand compliance. That is not an explanation that excuses what I did. It is a failure I need to understand and change.

Renee sat beside her.

“Now the hard part.”

“What’s harder than that?”

“Do not ask Imogen to accept this.”

Seraphine frowned.

“I have to apologize to her.”

“Yes. You do not get to turn receiving your apology into another job for her.”

Before it was published, Seraphine called three clients herself.

Renee told her she did not need to.

“Then why am I doing it?” Seraphine asked.

“Because you finally understand a statement cannot carry every consequence for you.”

The first client, a regional bank, listened to Seraphine explain what the new statement would say.

Its chief marketing officer thanked her and said the bank would continue the relationship after a ninety-day review.

Seraphine exhaled when the call ended.

The second client was less forgiving.

A university vice president told her they were ending the contract.

“Our student workers have spent the last week asking why we would keep paying a firm led by someone who treated service staff that way,” he said.

Seraphine gripped a pen.

“I understand.”

“I don’t think you do.”

The old impulse rose immediately.

Defend.

Explain.

Remind him how much value her team had created.

She said nothing.

He continued.

“You know what made the decision final?”

“The video?”

“No. Your first statement.”

Seraphine closed her eyes.

“We work with students on ethics and leadership. We could explain a person losing control and taking responsibility. We could not explain paying that person to advise us on credibility while she was publicly avoiding plain language.”

The criticism was precise.

That made it harder to dismiss.

“I’m sorry,” Seraphine said.

“I hope you mean the new statement.”

“So do I.”

The contract ended that afternoon.

Vale Strategy lost nearly eight percent of projected annual revenue.

The third client, a nonprofit hospital network, did not terminate immediately. Its CEO asked Seraphine to step away from the account while her team continued.

For the first time, Seraphine had to accept an arrangement where the firm was valued and she personally was considered a liability.

That distinction bruised her ego more than losing the university.

After the calls, she sat with Renee.

“I thought accountability was supposed to stop the bleeding.”

Renee looked at her.

“That is crisis strategy talking.”

“What is accountability supposed to do?”

“Tell the truth about who caused the wound.”

“That does not sound commercially useful.”

“It isn’t always.”

Seraphine looked at the revenue sheet.

“So we could lose more.”

“Yes.”

“People could decide the apology is not enough.”

“Yes.”

“I could change and still not get some things back.”

“Yes.”

Seraphine leaned back and stared at the ceiling.

“That is terrible messaging.”

Renee laughed.

“It is reality.”

The difference between those two things had once been Seraphine’s profession.

Now it was becoming her education.

The final public statement named no demand for forgiveness.

It promised no dramatic transformation.

It announced that Seraphine was stepping away from client-facing leadership for an unspecified period and that an external adviser would review workplace culture at Vale Strategy Group.

Renee posted it at 4:00 p.m.

The internet reacted exactly as the internet did.

Some called it sincere.

Some called it calculated.

Some said it was too late.

Some said she had been “canceled enough.”

Some wanted Imogen to respond.

Imogen did not.

Dana, her attorney, sent her the statement with one message:

You owe nobody a public reaction.

Imogen replied:

Good, because I don’t have one.

That was not completely true.

She felt relief that Seraphine had stopped implying the video was misleading.

She felt anger that strangers were already praising the apology as if acknowledging obvious facts were heroic.

She felt curiosity about the line concerning status.

Most of all, she felt tired of being linked to a woman she had never chosen to know.

At work that evening, a coworker asked, “You gonna forgive her?”

Imogen was stacking clean glasses.

“I don’t know her.”

“You know what she did.”

“That doesn’t mean I owe her a relationship.”

The coworker considered that.

“So no?”

May you like

Imogen placed another glass on the rack.

“It means her becoming better is her business. Me becoming okay is mine.”

Related Stories

Other posts