scribe

Chapter 6 - There Were Five

The report from Elodie’s school reached Child Protective Services before dismissal.

Mrs. Pritchard made the call from a private office. As a school counselor, she was a mandated reporter; she did not need to decide whether Elodie’s account was ultimately true before reporting a reasonable concern. Her job was not to investigate the family herself.

She gave the intake worker Elodie’s exact words, distinguishing what Elodie had said from what Ms. Cole had observed. She mentioned the drawing, but she did not claim the drawing proved abuse. She described the faint marks Ms. Cole had noticed when Elodie reached for a marker tray, but she did not guess what had caused them.

That precision later mattered.

The school also created a simple dismissal plan. Elodie would not be sent home with anyone other than an authorized adult already on file until CPS made contact. No one told Elodie there was an emergency. No police car arrived at school. No teacher whispered in the hallway.

For the rest of the afternoon, Elodie completed a spelling quiz while adults quietly began doing the work she had been unable to do alone.

By four-thirty, a caseworker named Dana Price was sitting in her car outside the Harrow house reading the intake summary twice.

Nine-year-old female. Stepmother. Deliberate painful punishment using household clothespins. Forced posture in corner. Threatening language suggesting pattern of unnoticed maltreatment. Father reportedly unaware.

Dana had learned not to treat small objects as small problems.

Inside, Vespera was peeling potatoes.

When the doorbell rang, she wiped her hands and opened the door with the pleasant expression she used for delivery drivers.

“Mrs. Harrow?” Dana asked.

“Yes?”

“My name is Dana Price. I’m with county child protective services. I need to speak with you and Adrian Harrow about Elodie.”

For one fraction of a second, Vespera’s face emptied.

Then the smile returned.

“Of course. Is something wrong at school?”

Elodie was in the living room doing homework. She recognized the counselor’s office language immediately: county, speak, Elodie.

Her pencil slipped from her hand.

Adrian arrived eighteen minutes later after Dana called him directly. He came through the front door pale and breathless.

“What happened?”

Dana asked everyone to sit separately.

Vespera folded her arms. “This is absurd.”

“We’ll speak one at a time.”

Adrian looked at Elodie. “Honey?”

She could not look back.

Dana interviewed Adrian in the dining room first. He said Vespera was strict but caring. He said Elodie was sensitive. He said there had been no physical discipline in the home that he knew of.

“Any reason Elodie might be afraid to tell you something?” Dana asked.

Adrian looked offended, then uncertain.

“No.”

“Do you routinely ask her privately how things are going?”

“I ask her every day.”

“What does she usually say?”

He hesitated.

“Fine.”

Dana wrote something down.

Vespera’s interview lasted longer.

She denied putting clothespins on Elodie. She suggested Elodie might have clipped them on herself while playing. Then she shifted and said perhaps the child had misunderstood an ordinary laundry chore. Then she said Elodie had been emotionally unstable since her mother’s death.

“How long ago did her mother die?” Dana asked.

“Four years.”

“And you believe this behavior began recently?”

Vespera paused.

“Elodie has always been imaginative.”

Dana wrote again.

When it was Elodie’s turn, Dana asked Adrian and Vespera to leave the room.

Vespera objected.

Dana did not debate her. “I need to speak with Elodie privately.”

Adrian touched Vespera’s elbow. “Come on.”

The moment the door closed, Elodie stared at Dana’s notebook.

“Did I get everyone in trouble?”

“No,” Dana said. “You told someone what happened. Adults are responsible for what adults do.”

Elodie swallowed.

Dana asked no leading questions. She invited Elodie to tell the story in her own words.

“There were five,” Elodie said again.

“Tell me about the five.”

Elodie did.

When Dana later asked to see her upper arms, only faint pressure traces remained. Dana documented them without dramatizing what she saw.

Before leaving, she established a temporary safety plan: until the assessment was complete, Vespera was not to be alone with Elodie. Adrian or another approved adult had to be present.

Vespera’s face tightened.

“You’re treating me like a criminal because a child drew a picture.”

Dana replied, “I’m treating a child’s disclosure as something that requires follow-up.”

After Dana left, Adrian stood in the kitchen staring at the table.

“Elodie,” he said. “Why didn’t you tell me?”

The question was not angry, but Elodie recoiled anyway.

Adrian saw it.

He stopped moving.

Vespera answered for her. “Because none of this happened.”

Elodie looked at her father.

“She said you wouldn’t notice.”

Adrian’s face changed.

“What?”

Vespera stood. “Enough.”

Elodie’s voice shook. “She said, ‘Let’s see if your father notices anything this time.’”

May you like

Adrian turned slowly toward his wife.

For the first time since Dana arrived, Vespera had no immediate answer.

Related Stories

Other posts