Chapter 5 - The Price of Mercy

By noon, Ethan Vale was a fugitive in the village where he had been born.
Tobias posted notices at the docks accusing Ethan of endangering Port Hollow, assaulting a company officer, concealing a dangerous creature, and interfering with maritime property.
“Maritime property?” Ethan said when Eliza read the notice aloud in the loft of an abandoned net shed.
“He means the company owns anything caught in its waters,” she replied.
“That is nonsense.”
“It only has to sound official long enough for frightened people to obey.”
They had left Marina hidden in a flooded cavern beyond the Covenant Hall. Ethan hated being away from her, but remaining in the caves risked trapping all three.
Eliza had another goal.
They needed Amos Crane.
The former county clerk was seventy now and lived six miles inland near Bracken Ford. If anyone could confirm the registry alteration, it was him.
Getting there required crossing Port Hollow unseen.
Ethan borrowed an old coat from the net shed and pulled the collar high. Eliza covered her hair with a fisherman’s scarf. They moved through alleys behind the smokehouses while company men watched the main road.
At the harbor square, a crowd had gathered around Silas.
His mother, Margaret Morrow, stood beside him with tears on her face.
Tobias held a debt ledger open before them.
“Your note comes due Monday,” he said.
Margaret whispered, “You promised us until winter.”
“I promised while your son remained useful.”
Silas’s face burned red.
Ethan understood immediately.
Tobias was punishing him for failing in the cave.
Three hundred and forty dollars was more than Silas could earn in months. Losing credit meant losing boat repairs, then the boat itself.
Tobias closed the ledger.
“Bring me the mermaid, and the debt disappears.”
Margaret gripped Silas’s sleeve.
“Don’t.”
Silas looked at the ground.
Ethan and Eliza slipped away before they heard his answer.
Bracken Ford was a muddy crossroads town of forty houses and one courthouse annex. Amos Crane lived behind the old post office in a cottage that smelled of coal smoke and medicinal herbs.
When Ethan knocked, nobody answered.
Eliza tried the door.
Unlocked.
Inside, shelves had been emptied onto the floor. Papers covered the rug. A desk drawer hung broken.
Ethan’s stomach tightened.
“We’re late.”
A weak voice came from the pantry.
“Depends what for.”
They found Amos Crane sitting on the floor with a split lip and one eye swelling shut.
Eliza knelt.
“Who did this?”
Crane laughed without humor.
“You know who.”
“Tobias?”
“His men. Asked about old deeds. Asked what Nathaniel Vale gave me.”
Ethan helped him into a chair.
“What did my father give you?”
Crane studied him.
“You look like him when you’re angry. That is not a compliment. Nathaniel nearly got himself killed asking questions.”
“He did get killed.”
Crane’s expression shifted.
“So you finally learned.”
The room seemed to tilt.
Eliza went rigid.
“What are you saying?”
Crane looked between them.
“Nathaniel did not drown in a squall.”
Eliza’s face drained.
“You told me the boat wreck was found.”
“I told you what Tobias paid me to sign.”
Ethan grabbed the back of a chair.
“Paid you?”
Crane’s shame was old but visible.
“In 1867, Gideon Grey paid me to alter the shoreline registry. I told myself it was paperwork. Then seventeen men died. Eleven years ago, Tobias came to me again. Nathaniel had found evidence of the forgery and threatened to reopen everything.”
“What happened?” Ethan asked.
Crane stared at the rain on the window.
“Tobias arranged for Nathaniel’s skiff to be found overturned beyond Widow’s Reach. There was no storm that night.”
Eliza stood so fast the chair toppled.
“You knew.”
“I knew enough.”
“You let me bury an empty coffin.”
Crane did not defend himself.
Ethan’s voice turned quiet.
“Was my father murdered?”
“I never saw a body.”
“Who took him?”
“Two company men. One is dead.”
“And the other?”
Crane swallowed.
“Silas Morrow’s father.”
Ethan stepped back.
Silas’s father, Daniel Morrow, had died six years ago in a warehouse fire.
Eliza’s grief hardened into fury.
“Why help us now?”
Crane pointed toward the overturned desk.
“Because Tobias thinks I still have the original registry page.”
“Do you?”
“No. Nathaniel took it.”
Ethan thought of the Covenant Hall.
“Where?”
Crane smiled faintly.
“He said the sea would keep better records than men.”
A horse stopped outside.
Then another.
Crane’s expression changed.
“They followed you.”
Ethan moved to the window.
Silas stood in the road with three company men.
Rain ran down his pale face.
He looked directly at the cottage.
For one long second, Ethan and Silas saw each other through the glass.
May you like
Then Silas raised his hand.
And pointed toward the back door.