Chapter 14 - The Price of Being Believed

The revised financial forecast arrived on a rain-heavy Monday in November. Gabriel had found alternative donors for part of the restoration project, but the public exhibition wing would remain on hold. Three contractors had accepted temporary assignments elsewhere. Eight others faced delayed starts, though the company could preserve several smaller maintenance projects to give them work. Cassander read the figures with a sense of responsibility that had nothing to do with punishing the Marlowes.
“Can we offer training hours to the workers whose roles are delayed?” he asked.
“We can for some, not all,” Gabriel said. “And we shouldn't promise what we can't fund.”
They agreed on a transparent letter explaining the revised schedule without disclosing private family events. Workers could accept other jobs without penalty and would receive any compensation already owed under their contracts. Cassander would not use his daughter's experience as a justification for breaking promises to people who depended on him.
At the same time, a society columnist published a piece suggesting that Cassander had been manipulated by an overly attached child and a controlling mother. The article did not name Eirabelle but described her age and the old family home closely enough that acquaintances could recognize her. Cassander's first impulse was to issue the recording and prove the columnist wrong.
Mara Ellison stopped him. “Once you release that audio, it belongs to the internet. You cannot take it back from people who will replay it for entertainment.”
“Then how do I protect her?”
“By refusing the terms of this argument. You don't have to provide strangers with a child's pain to earn their approval.”
They requested a correction of the misleading claim that the wedding had been canceled at a child's demand. The columnist's editor agreed to remove speculative references to family members who had not spoken publicly. It was a narrow victory, but it did not require Eirabelle's voice to become evidence for a crowd.
When Cassander told Imogen, she asked whether he was angry. “Of course I am.”
“Good,” she said. “Anger isn't the difficulty. What you do with it is.”
Eirabelle had begun asking for stories about Marielle that did not end with a hospital. Cassander found one about a disastrous boat trip on the Hudson River and another about the time Marielle had tried to teach him to bake a cake while he kept treating the recipe like an architectural drawing. He told both at dinner. Eirabelle laughed until she hiccuped, then asked whether Vesperine had known Mama.
“No,” Cassander said. “They never met.”
“Then why didn't she like Mama's stories?”
He searched for a truthful answer that did not force a child to manage adult envy. “I think she found it difficult that we remembered someone important to us. That's a grown-up feeling she should have handled differently.”
“Could she have learned the purple boat story?”
“Yes. If she had wanted to listen.”
“Maybe she doesn't like purple.”
“Maybe,” he said. He would not argue with his daughter for making the explanation simpler. She was five. She deserved a world that did not demand she understand every failure of the adults in it.
That week Nell Avery replied to Cassander's request. She was willing to speak in person but asked whether the discussion would affect Eirabelle's current care. He assured her it would not and offered to meet at a café near her new workplace. Nell arrived wearing a navy sweater and carrying a notebook. She told him she had resigned after Vesperine repeatedly instructed her to put away Marielle's books and told her not to comfort Eirabelle when the child cried at bedtime.
“I tried to speak to you,” Nell said. “I left a message with your office. I was told you wanted the household to work through Vesperine.”
Cassander looked down. “I didn't make that instruction directly, but I let it become the rule.”
Nell said she had refused to tell Eirabelle that her mother was best forgotten. When she insisted the child needed reassurance, Vesperine accused her of undermining the future marriage. Nell had no wish to enter a public fight with an influential family and had chosen to leave. She now regretted not contacting Imogen.
“Please don't make that regret yours alone,” Cassander said. “I was the parent.”
They spoke for another hour. Nell's recollections were not presented as perfect evidence. She distinguished what she had witnessed from what she had inferred, and Cassander appreciated her care. At the end he asked if she would like to see Eirabelle again, not as a witness but as someone the child missed. Nell smiled and said she would welcome a visit if Eirabelle wanted one.
That night Cassander explained the invitation to his daughter. She looked startled, then delighted. “Can Nell come for pancakes?”
“If she wants to.”
“Can we make the burnt ones too?”
He laughed. “I can probably manage that.”
Nell also offered a practical suggestion during their conversation. She remembered that Eirabelle had always settled more easily when she knew what would happen before bedtime. In the weeks before her resignation, changes were announced without warning: different routines, missing objects, photographs removed from walls. Nell had tried to preserve a few familiar rituals but had been told they were outdated.
May you like
Cassander asked whether she would be comfortable writing down the old bedtime sequence, not as a strict rule but as something he could offer Eirabelle. Nell took a page from her notebook and listed the steps: wash hands, choose pajamas, place the owl on the pillow, select a story, leave the lamp on low, and say goodnight twice if necessary. Cassander recognized each detail once he saw it. He had lived in the same house and somehow needed another person to remind him what his daughter did every evening. Instead of defending himself, he thanked her and began using the list only when Eirabelle wanted it.
As he helped her choose pajamas, he thought of how little the public article mattered beside this private possibility: a child might see a trusted adult return without any bargain attached. He could not erase the weeks in which Eirabelle had feared losing her place. He could help her learn that relationships did not have to vanish simply because another grown-up disliked them.