scribe

Chapter 15 - The Brother in the Shadow

Anthony Caruso had spent eighteen years in the NYPD before retiring under circumstances no one in the Vitale family had ever questioned closely.

Marco questioned them now.

With help from a private investigator unconnected to either family, he obtained old disciplinary records through public filings and former colleagues.

Anthony had been investigated twice for unauthorized access to evidence rooms.

Neither case resulted in charges.

A retired sergeant agreed to speak with Marco off the record. “Anthony was useful,” he said. “He knew informants, property clerks, tow operators, private security. The kind of cop who could make a problem move sideways instead of forward.”

“Corrupt?” Marco asked.

The sergeant took his time. “I never caught him taking an envelope. But I saw people owe him favors they could not explain.”

“Did Vincent ever come around?”

“His brother? Sure. Lawyer visits. Evidence questions. Anthony used to joke that Vincent cleaned paper and he cleaned messes.”

Marco wrote the sentence down. It sounded like a joke men would repeat until nobody noticed it was a job description.

Neither case had produced enough for charges, but together they showed a man who understood exactly where institutional systems were weakest.

In 2007, one internal-affairs complaint alleged that he removed property from a homicide evidence locker, returned it three days later, and falsified the sign-out record.

The homicide was not Emilio Corleone’s.

But the method mattered.

Marco visited Tommaso at the rehabilitation floor with a folder under his arm.

On the way, he stopped outside the therapy room and watched through the glass. Tommaso’s face tightened each time he tried to raise his arm. The bullet had been intended for Adriano, but the cost now appeared in inches measured by a physical therapist. Marco felt anger return, then forced himself to name it precisely. Anthony. Vincent. Gabriel. Nico’s choice. Rafael’s shot. Precision mattered. Tommaso had taught him that much.

He entered only after the therapist stepped aside.

Tommaso was standing between parallel bars, trying to lift his right arm while a therapist watched.

He managed six inches.

Pain stopped him.

“Again,” Tommaso said.

The therapist shook her head. “Tomorrow.”

After she left, Marco showed him photographs of Anthony.

“That’s the man from the church courtyard,” Tommaso said.

“Certain?”

“Certain enough to bet your money.”

Marco sat.

“Nico says the same.”

Tommaso studied him. “You believe Nico?”

“I believe the recording.”

“Good.”

“You sound disappointed I didn’t shoot him.”

“I’m disappointed you had to think about it.”

Marco looked away.

Tommaso’s voice softened.

“We grew up in a world where punishment is fast because questions are dangerous. Maybe that is why men like Caruso survive. They know we’ll kill the first person who looks guilty and save them the trouble of explaining the second.”

Marco looked back at him.

“Since when did getting shot make you philosophical?”

“Strong medication.”

They laughed.

Then Marco’s phone rang.

Nico’s attorney.

Before answering, Marco looked again through the therapy-room glass. Tommaso was attempting the same movement he had failed ten minutes earlier. This time his arm rose another inch. The therapist nodded as if the inch mattered. Marco realized investigations were like that too: no single clue had solved anything. A ring, an access log, a payment, a camera frame, a frightened man’s memory. Inches.

Then he answered.

Anthony Caruso had contacted Nico’s wife through an unknown number and offered them passports, cash, and safe travel if Nico surrendered the recorder.

Marco’s expression hardened.

“Can they trace the call?”

“Not yet.”

“But he knows Nico recorded Vincent.”

That meant someone from the motel operation had leaked—or Anthony had been watching the family all along.

Marco stood.

Tommaso stopped him.

“Do not go alone.”

“I’m not you.”

“That is exactly why I said it.”

Marco left the hospital and drove to a secure office where Nico and his family had been placed under protection arranged through counsel and law enforcement. Nico agreed to cooperate fully.

He also remembered one detail from his meetings with Vincent.

A phrase.

“Vincent kept saying ‘the closing has to happen before October fourteenth.’”

Luca, listening by speakerphone, understood immediately.

October 14 was the twentieth anniversary of Emilio’s murder.

It was three weeks away.

Maya Chen checked the unsigned Northstar sale agreement.

The proposed closing date was October 13.

One day before the anniversary.

“Why that date?” Marco asked.

Luca looked at the Harbor Covenant.

A clause they had barely noticed provided that unresolved management rights would automatically become subject to arbitration after twenty years of continuous dispute.

October 14, 2026.

If Northstar could close before then, Caruso could claim the transfer predated any renewed arbitration demand.

The legal argument might fail.

But the money could move through offshore accounts long before a court sorted it out.

Adriano joined the call.

“So we know the deadline.”

Luca nodded.

“And Caruso knows we know.”

At that moment, Maya sent a new message.

She had traced a $750,000 payment from a Northstar affiliate made six days before the baptism.

Recipient: A.C. Protective Consulting.

Anthony Caruso’s firm.

Memo line: SPECIAL EVENT CONTINGENCY.

May you like

The church attack had a price tag.

And one of the men who helped arrange it had spent half his career wearing a badge.

Related Stories

Other posts