scribe

Chapter 23 - A Letter From Prison

Near Thanksgiving, Liam received a letter from Andrew.

He carried it in his backpack for two days before opening it.

Andrew wrote that he loved him. He apologized for making Liam feel

responsible for the investigation. He said he had convinced himself

protecting the family justified choices that became worse each time.

Liam showed the letter to Julia.

“Do I have to forgive him?”

“No.”

“Do I have to visit?”

“No.”

“Can I still love him?”

Julia’s face broke.

“Yes.”

At school, Liam told Evie only that the letter had come.

“My mom says I can decide what I want.”

Evie understood more than he knew. Claire had never harmed her, but Evie

had still carried anger about the guilty plea.

“Deciding takes a while.”

“Are you still mad at your mom?”

“Sometimes.”

Liam looked surprised.

“She was innocent.”

“That doesn’t mean every choice she made was right.”

That evening Evie asked Claire something she had avoided.

“Did you ever think I’d hate you if I found out you pleaded guilty

because of me?”

Claire sat beside her on the sofa.

“Yes.”

“Did you think I’d blame myself?”

“Yes.”

“I did for a little while.”

Claire’s face tightened.

Evie continued, “Then Dr. Chen said adults are responsible for their own

decisions.”

“She’s right.”

“So you chose it.”

“I did.”

“Because you loved me.”

“Yes.”

“And it was still the wrong choice.”

Claire took a breath.

“Yes.”

Evie leaned against her.

The answer hurt less now because nobody was hiding from it.

On Thanksgiving morning, Claire braided Evie’s hair. One braid came out

shorter.

Evie looked in the mirror.

“You still can’t do it.”

“I’ve been out of practice.”

“You were bad before prison.”

Claire gasped theatrically.

Nora laughed from the doorway.

For a few minutes, prison, court, fountains, and foundations disappeared

beneath the ordinary argument over ribbons.

Then the doorbell rang.

Claire stiffened.

Evie felt it.

Nora opened the door.

A delivery driver handed over a pie from Thomas Reed and his family.

Claire exhaled.

Fear still had habits.

But so did home.

Later, Evie placed Andrew’s story beside Claire’s in her mind. Both

parents had said they acted for their children. One eventually admitted

the truth when it cost her. The other buried truth until it cost

everyone.

May you like

Love, Evie was learning, did not excuse choices.

But truth could change what happened after them.

Related Stories

Other posts