Chapter 23 - The Verdict

Silvio’s trial began eleven months after Roberto’s remains were found.
By then, the criminal case had become a public history of the Marchetti family.
Prosecutors did not ask the jury to believe a single witness without support. They built the case from overlapping evidence: the compromised device backup, the false meeting relocation, Marcus Dane’s transport testimony, the warehouse video, the North Pier vehicle data, Roberto’s recorder, the concealed remains, financial records, Thomas’s testimony, and Silvio’s own words on the audio.
Silvio’s lawyers argued that the shooting was self-defense.
The recording captured Silvio saying Roberto reached for him. They emphasized that no surviving witness had seen the exact physical movement before the shot.
Thomas complicated that defense.
On the stand, he admitted lying during his first proffer.
Then he described the final seconds.
“Roberto picked up the ledger,” Thomas said. “Silvio told him to put it down. Roberto said he was leaving. Silvio moved toward him. Roberto pushed his arm away. Silvio pulled the gun.”
“Did Roberto have a weapon?” the prosecutor asked.
“No.”
“Did you see him reach for one?”
“No.”
Silvio’s attorney attacked Thomas for cooperating to reduce his own sentence.
Thomas agreed with nearly every accusation about himself.
“Yes, I lied.”
“Yes, I forged documents.”
“Yes, I was afraid.”
“Yes, I want consideration.”
Then he looked at Silvio.
“But Roberto did not have a gun.”
Isabella testified for two days.
She admitted her own crimes before the defense could use them against her. She described Roberto’s final visit, the signed trust termination, and her failure to give police the letter.
Silvio’s attorney asked whether she was blaming Silvio to save herself.
“No,” Isabella said. “I blamed everyone else to save myself. That is why I am here admitting it.”
Daniela testified last.
She described the altered consents and Roberto’s effort to prove she had not knowingly participated.
The prosecutor showed her the final page of Roberto’s letter.
“Why is this important to you?”
Daniela looked at the jury.
“Because my brother died after spending years trying to expose a system built on people deciding what others were allowed to know.”
Silvio watched her without expression.
The jury deliberated for two and a half days.
During the wait, Daniela refused the private room prosecutors offered. She sat in a public corridor with former employees, reporters, and strangers who had followed the case. An older man introduced himself as a retired Marchetti driver. His pension had been cut during one of the years later tied to Lake Meridian.
“I used to think your family owned the company,” he told her. “Then I realized our paychecks were part of what made it valuable.”
Daniela had no polished response.
“You are right,” she said.
He nodded, apparently satisfied by the absence of a speech.
When the bailiff finally opened the courtroom doors, Daniela’s legs felt heavy. She did not want a verdict to become another family myth, one clean event that supposedly explained decades of choices. Whatever the jury decided about Silvio, Lorenzo’s lies would remain. Isabella’s fraud would remain. Thomas’s cowardice, Martin’s manipulations, Victor’s invoices, Enzo’s blank authorization, and Daniela’s own willingness not to read what benefited her would remain.
The verdict could establish responsibility for crimes. It could not distribute innocence.
Daniela sat in the courtroom between Miriam and Enzo when the jury returned.
Guilty of first-degree murder.
Guilty of conspiracy to defraud Marchetti Holdings.
Guilty of obstruction.
Guilty on multiple financial counts.
Silvio did not react until deputies approached him.
Then he turned toward Daniela.
For a moment she saw the old family patriarch again—the man who had filled holiday rooms, given graduation toasts, told everyone that the Marchetti name meant survival.
“You think this fixes it?” he asked.
Daniela stood.
“No.”
Silvio waited.
“It stops you from calling it protection.”
He was led away.
Outside the courthouse, reporters crowded the steps.
Daniela declined interviews.
Enzo walked beside her.
“You all right?”
“No.”
He nodded.
They reached the corner where Roberto used to wait after long meetings, always impatient, always checking his watch.
Daniela looked down at that same watch on her wrist.
It no longer ran.
She had decided not to repair it.
10:58 p.m.—the time it had stopped beneath North Pier—remained fixed on the face.
Not because she wanted to live in the moment he died.
Because some things were supposed to remain evidence.
Her phone rang.
Miriam.
“The independent custodian has finished the governance proposal,” she said. “There is one problem.”
“What?”
“To create Roberto’s employee trust as written, the company needs forty percent of voting interests committed voluntarily. With the corrupted trust unwound, we are short.”
“How short?”
“Eight percent.”
May you like
Daniela already knew who controlled almost exactly that amount.
Isabella.