Chương 9 - NO RULE

Dr. Miriam Vale called it conditioned expectation.
Corisande called it unbearable.
For weeks, ordinary kindness confused Ismerie.
A new coloring book made her ask what she had to promise. Extra strawberries at breakfast made her glance toward the doorway. When Maura told her she was proud of a drawing, Ismerie immediately wanted to know what she had done right.
Praise had become transactional.
Comfort had become suspicious.
Gentleness had acquired a hidden price.
Corisande began answering every question the same way.
“No rule.”
Why can I have cocoa?
No rule.
Why can I pick the bedtime story?
No rule.
Why did you hug me?
No rule.
The words slowly became a ritual.
Not a perfect one.
One morning, Corisande reached suddenly to straighten Ismerie’s cardigan collar.
Ismerie flinched so hard she dropped her spoon.
Corisande froze.
“I’m sorry.”
Ismerie stared at her.
Adults in her recent world did not apologize easily.
“Why?”
“I touched you without asking.”
The little girl considered this.
“You can ask?”
“Yes.”
“Even you?”
“Especially me.”
That became another ritual.
Can I brush your hair?
Can I carry you?
Can I look at your knee?
Sometimes Ismerie said no.
Corisande learned to survive the no without letting her face fall.
Meanwhile, the investigation widened.
Gideon Pryce retained a criminal-defense attorney.
Thaddeus remained missing.
His bank accounts showed a series of cash withdrawals totaling forty thousand dollars made during the week before Corisande returned early from her trip.
Police believed he had planned to disappear briefly, not permanently—possibly until the guardianship process advanced.
Then Corisande’s early return interrupted the schedule.
The most disturbing evidence came from the recovered flash drives.
There were twelve recordings in total.
In some, Ismerie repeated statements about Corisande being angry, absent, or frightening.
In others, Thaddeus rehearsed answers to questions no one had yet asked her.
Who helps you when Mommy cries?
Who makes dinner when Mommy forgets?
Who do you want to live with if Mommy goes away?
The final recording was dated the morning Corisande came home.
It began normally.
Then, halfway through, Ismerie stopped repeating the sentence she had been given.
Thaddeus said, “Again.”
She shook her head.
“Again.”
“No.”
His voice hardened.
“Ismerie.”
The child looked down at her hands.
Then she said something Corisande replayed three times.
“Daddy said pretending is only a game if everybody knows.”
Silence followed.
A long silence.
Then Thaddeus walked into frame.
He did not strike her on camera.
He simply leaned down until his face was close to hers.
“Your father isn’t here.”
Ismerie’s fingers crossed beneath the table.
“No,” she whispered. “But he told me.”
The recording ended.
Corisande watched the black screen.
Julian had been gone fourteen months.
Yet some small lesson he had taught their daughter while playing pretend had survived long enough to interfere with a grown man’s scheme.
The weeks between interviews developed their own rhythm. Tuesday therapy. Thursday calls with the prosecutor. Saturday mornings at the park if Ismerie slept well. Corisande returned to part-time work from Maura's guest room and learned to end meetings without apologizing when school or counseling required her attention.
Not every day contained a revelation.
Some days contained cereal.
Some contained tantrums about socks.
Some contained no mention of Thaddeus at all.
Dr. Vale warned Corisande not to mistake silence for either recovery or suppression.
“Children move in and out of hard material,” she said. “She may play for three hours and then ask one devastating question while brushing her teeth.”
That proved true.
One night Ismerie asked, “If I told you sooner, would Uncle stop sooner?”
Corisande sat on the closed toilet lid while the child held a toothbrush covered in too much foam.
“That was not your job.”
“But would he?”
“I don't know.”
Ismerie stared at her.
Corisande resisted the urge to replace uncertainty with comfort.
“What I know is that grown-ups were responsible for keeping you safe. You were not responsible for making the right report at the right time.”
“What if I said it wrong?”
“You couldn't say it wrong.”
“Uncle said I said things wrong.”
“I know.”
“Was he lying?”
“Yes.”
The answer came without hesitation.
That distinction—between uncertainty and certainty—became another part of recovery. Corisande did not need to answer every question with maybe. Some facts were clear. Thaddeus had lied. The bruises were not Ismerie's fault. Telling was not betrayal.
By the time police released the candy from evidence, Corisande understood why throwing it away needed to be Ismerie's choice rather than a dramatic gesture performed for her.
That evening, Corisande took Ismerie’s strawberry candy from the evidence-return envelope police had released after photographing it.
“Can we throw it away?” she asked.
Ismerie looked at the wrapper.
“Do we have to?”
“No.”
“Can we?”
“Yes.”
Together they walked to the bin.
Ismerie dropped it in.
Then she looked up.
“No rule?”
May you like
Corisande swallowed.
“No rule.”