Chapter 3 - The Camera That Wasn’t Broken

By six o’clock, the school had changed its explanation twice.
First, Principal Bell said the classroom camera had been offline all
week. Then the technology coordinator, summoned by Natalie’s insistence,
confirmed the device had transmitted data that afternoon. Finally Bell
claimed the recording might have been automatically deleted during a
software update.
Natalie sat at the conference table with Sera beside her and wrote down
every version.
Caroline Foster stopped pretending to be patient.
“My daughter’s property is missing. Why are we discussing cameras?”
“Because the camera can tell us what happened,” Natalie said.
“It can tell us whether Sera took the watch,” Sera corrected quietly.
Natalie squeezed her hand under the table.
The technology coordinator, Omar Patel, stared at his laptop. “The file
existed at 3:14 p.m.”
“And now?” Natalie asked.
“Now it doesn’t.”
“Who can delete it?”
Omar hesitated. “Administrators with elevated access.”
Bell leaned forward. “That doesn’t mean anyone deleted it
intentionally.”
“Can you see who accessed it?” Natalie asked.
Omar looked at Bell before answering. “There should be logs.”
“Should be?”
“The logs for this afternoon are also missing.”
Caroline stood. “This is turning into theater.”
Maddie remained seated. She had been unusually quiet since the backpack
search.
Sera studied her. “Maddie?”
Maddie’s eyes lifted.
“Why did you say that about my dad?”
Caroline’s hand closed around her daughter’s shoulder.
“Maddie was upset,” she said.
“But where did she hear it?”
“Maddie,” Natalie said, “who told you Sera’s father stole something?”
Maddie’s lower lip moved.
Caroline interrupted. “This has nothing to do with Daniel Collins.”
Natalie went still.
She had never told Caroline her late husband’s first name.
Caroline realized the mistake immediately.
Sera felt Natalie’s hand tighten around hers.
“How do you know my husband’s name?” Natalie asked.
Caroline recovered quickly. “Everyone knows everyone here.”
“No,” Natalie said. “They don’t.”
Bell stood. “I think we should continue tomorrow.”
Natalie closed her notebook. “We will. And I want written preservation
of every camera file, access log, email, incident report, and message
relating to my daughter or the missing watch.”
Caroline gave her a cold look. “You sound like a lawyer.”
“I’m a forensic accountant.”
For the first time, Caroline looked genuinely unsettled.
Outside, Natalie and Sera walked toward the parking lot under falling
snow.
“Mom?”
“Yes?”
“Was Dad a thief?”
Natalie stopped.
“No.”
“Then why did Mrs. Foster know his name?”
Natalie looked back at the school’s glowing windows.
“Because,” she said slowly, “I think today was about more than a watch.”
Her phone buzzed.
An email had arrived from an address with no name.
Subject: DANIEL COLLINS WAS RIGHT.
May you like
The message contained only one sentence:
ASK THE SCHOOL WHO PAID TO ERASE THE VIDEO.