scribe

Chapter 10 - The Second Child

The external investigator, Caroline Webb, called Rosamund on Friday.

Her voice was direct and unsentimental.

“I’m not representing you,” she said. “I’m retained by the school, but my assignment from the board is to conduct an independent factual review.”

“I understand.”

“I’d like to interview Mellie, but only with your consent, and preferably with a child specialist present.”

Rosamund agreed.

Before the interview, Webb asked Rosamund not to question Mellie further about specific incidents unless Mellie volunteered them.

“Children can become eager to please the adult asking,” Webb explained. “I want her account in her own sequence.”

Rosamund appreciated the restraint.

The interview took place in a neutral room at a local child advocacy center, not because criminal conduct was alleged, but because the setting was designed for child-sensitive conversations. Rosamund watched through one-way glass with permission while Webb and a specialist named Dana sat across from Mellie.

Mellie began quietly.

She described the panini.

The smell.

The green-gray corner.

Ms. Fenwick tearing that piece away.

The sentence.

Maybe you’re the problem, not the food.

Then Dana asked, “When Ms. Fenwick said things like that, what did you think she wanted you to believe?”

Mellie stared at her hands.

“That I couldn’t tell when something was wrong.”

Rosamund covered her mouth.

Mellie continued.

“She said my face makes people think things are worse than they are.”

“When did she say that?”

“When I cried about the soup.”

“What soup?”

“The silver-tasting soup.”

Dana did not react. “Was anyone else there?”

Mellie nodded. “Sophie.”

“Sophie who?”

“Sophie Lang.”

Rosamund knew the name. Sophie sat two seats behind Mellie in class.

“What did Sophie do?”

“She said it tasted funny too.”

“And then?”

“Ms. Fenwick told her not to copy me.”

Rosamund’s pulse jumped.

A second child had noticed something.

After the interview, Webb came into the observation room.

“I’m going to contact the Lang family,” she said.

“Do you believe Mellie?” Rosamund asked.

Webb did not give the comforting answer.

“I believe her account is detailed, internally consistent, and contains verifiable points. My job is to verify them.”

“That’s fair.”

Webb nodded. “One thing matters already. Mellie’s description of the sandwich predates her access to the refrigerator log. The torn corner is a new detail, and if another witness confirms it, that’s significant.”

Rosamund drove Mellie home.

They stopped for hot chocolate at a small café because Mellie asked. Halfway through, Mellie lifted the cup, sniffed it, then immediately looked embarrassed.

“Sorry.”

Rosamund felt a sting in her chest.

“For what?”

“For checking.”

Rosamund reached across the table.

“You never have to apologize for checking whether something you’re about to eat or drink seems okay.”

Mellie nodded.

Then she pushed the cup toward Rosamund.

“Can you smell it too?”

Rosamund did.

“Cinnamon,” she said. “Chocolate. Milk.”

Mellie took a sip.

For the first time in days, she smiled.

Rosamund wanted to believe that was the beginning of repair.

Her phone buzzed.

A message from Caroline Webb.

Sophie Lang remembers the soup incident. She also remembers Thursday’s sandwich.

Rosamund stared at the screen.

May you like

Then another message appeared.

She says Ms. Fenwick smelled it before giving it to Mellie.

Related Stories

Other posts