Chapter 15 - The Hearing Begins

The hearing took place in a paneled chamber attached to the provincial intendant’s administrative offices in Tours.
It was not a grand court. There was no jury, no theatrical bench, no crowd. A royal subdelegate named Monsieur de Charny presided with two clerks and a legal assessor. The narrowness of the room made the stakes feel more severe.
Bastien arrived in black velvet.
He looked exactly as he had beneath the chandelier: controlled, polished, untouched.
Armand Arcourt sat to his left with counsel.
Eulalie entered with Geneviève and Vaudreuil. Celestine followed separately.
For one second, Bastien’s composure cracked.
He had not expected Celestine to appear beside his opponents.
De Charny began with the narrow question: whether Bastien should receive temporary administrative authority over Eulalie’s separate property while her alleged incapacity was assessed.
Bastien’s counsel spoke first.
He described a household deteriorating under a pregnant wife’s suspicion. Eulalie, he said, had become fixated on harmless friendship between her husband and a guest. She had secretly entered private archives, taken documents, fled with servants, and now accused respected men of conspiracy.
The account was skillful because parts were true.
Eulalie had entered the archive.
She had fled.
She was pregnant and frightened.
Truth, arranged carefully, could resemble a lie.
Then Vaudreuil presented Dr. Pelletier.
The physician denied the certificate attached to Bastien’s petition.
De Charny compared the signatures.
“Lord Varenne,” he said, “who supplied this document?”
Bastien did not hesitate. “It was delivered to my steward’s office. I believed it genuine.”
Claude Lavigne, seated at the back, spoke before anyone asked him.
“It did not pass through my office.”
Bastien turned.
The stare he gave Lavigne held years of command.
Lavigne did not look away.
Next came Eulalie.
She described the pillar without embellishment.
Her wrists tied above her head.
The single strike.
The demand that she sign away administration the next morning.
Bastien’s counsel asked, “Had you accused your husband of an improper relationship with Mademoiselle Arcourt?”
“Yes.”
“Were you jealous?”
“Yes.”
The lawyer paused, perhaps surprised by the admission.
Eulalie continued, “I was also correct.”
A faint stir moved through the room.
Bastien’s jaw tightened.
Then Celestine was called.
She stood pale but steady.
“Did you have an intimate relationship with Lord Varenne?” de Charny asked.
“Yes.”
Bastien closed his eyes once.
“Did you deliberately encourage Lady Eulalie’s jealousy?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because Lord Varenne and my father believed her jealousy could later be cited as evidence that she was emotionally unfit to manage her property.”
Arcourt’s counsel rose immediately. “That is false.”
De Charny silenced him.
Celestine produced the letters.
Her own worst words were among them.
The room heard them all.
She did not ask to be excused.
Then Vaudreuil presented the copied memorandum and registry record 4721.
Arcourt was ordered to produce the original.
His counsel placed it on the table.
Eulalie saw her false signature.
Her real seal.
And Lavigne’s witness mark.
De Charny asked Eulalie, “Did you execute this instrument?”
“No.”
“Did you authorize another to execute it?”
“No.”
Lavigne admitted witnessing a sheet before the final text was added.
Then Celestine said, “I saw Lord Varenne write Lady Eulalie’s name on a financial document while using letters from their engagement as a model.”
Bastien finally lost his composure.
“You liar.”
The words echoed.
Everyone turned.
Celestine’s face went white.
Bastien stood. “You came into my house with your father’s instructions. You shared my bed. You plotted against my wife. And now, because you fear exposure, you invent forgery?”
Celestine shook but remained standing.
“I did all the first things,” she said. “That is why I know the last one is true.”
Silence.
De Charny ordered Bastien to sit.
Then Geneviève presented the copied 1768 entries and explained their connection to 4137.
Arcourt objected that copies were unreliable.
De Charny agreed the original ledger would be necessary for any broader finding.
He recessed the hearing for one hour.
In the corridor, Eulalie stood near a tall window, exhausted.
Bastien approached before Vaudreuil could stop him.
He spoke quietly.
“You think this room will save you?”
“No.”
“What, then?”
“The fact that you no longer control every room.”
For the first time, anger showed nakedly on his face.
A clerk opened the chamber door.
“The subdelegate will resume.”
They returned.
De Charny read his interim decision.
Bastien’s request for temporary authority was denied.
All transfers involving Bellune property were suspended pending review.
The disputed original 4721 was impounded in the administrative archive.
And, because evidence suggested possible forgery affecting registered financial instruments, an official inventory of relevant Varenne papers was ordered.
Eulalie felt relief so sharp it almost hurt.
Then came the final sentence.
“Lord Varenne is instructed not to remove, alter, or destroy estate records.”
Bastien’s face became still again.
Too still.
Eulalie looked at Geneviève.
They both understood at once.
May you like
The 1768 ledger was still at Château de Varenne.
And Bastien had several hours’ head start before the inventory officers could reach it.