Chapter 10 - Not Elijah Again

Charles dreamed of his older son for the first time in months.
In the dream, Elijah was seventeen and standing beside the old basketball hoop in the driveway. Charles kept trying to tell him about the baby, but every time he opened his mouth, Elijah bounced the ball once and asked, “Are you going to listen this time?”
Charles woke before he answered.
At six in the morning, he found Elodie feeding Eli in the kitchen.
Zaria had slept only two hours and finally allowed herself to rest after Elodie promised to wake her for the next feeding.
Charles poured coffee.
Elodie looked at him. “You can hold him, you know.”
“I know.”
“You keep standing near him like there’s an electric fence.”
“I’m trying to make sure I don’t make him into Elijah.”
Elodie’s expression softened.
“That’s a good instinct.”
“It doesn’t feel good.”
“No. Most useful instincts don’t.”
She finished the bottle and held Eli upright against her shoulder.
Charles watched the tiny head bob once before settling.
“Did Jama tell you why she named him Eli?”
“No.”
“Did she ever call him Elijah?”
“Never.”
Charles nodded.
Elodie looked toward the empty doorway.
“When she came down that night, I called him ‘little Elijah’ once.”
Charles waited.
“She corrected me immediately.”
“What did she say?”
“She said, ‘Please don’t make him carry a dead man before he can hold his own head up.’”
Charles closed his eyes.
“That sounds harsh.”
“It was accurate.”
He looked at his wife.
“You agree with everything she says now?”
“No. I agreed with that.”
After a moment, Elodie held the baby toward him.
Charles did not move.
“You don’t have to,” she said.
That made it possible.
He washed his hands, dried them, and sat down.
Elodie placed Eli in his arms carefully.
The baby weighed less than Charles expected and more than he was ready for.
He smelled like formula, clean cotton, and something warm that Charles had forgotten babies carried with them.
Eli opened his eyes.
Charles stared back.
There it was again—the temptation to search for Elijah.
He stopped himself.
“Hello, Eli,” he said.
The baby blinked.
“That’s it. Just Eli.”
Elodie looked away so he would not see her cry.
Later that morning, Detective Avery called with two updates.
The first was that Warren had admitted calling Jama multiple times.
The second was that he claimed the calls were meant to persuade her to resolve the trust claim quietly to avoid litigation.
“Why would there be litigation?” Charles asked.
Avery said, “According to him, because paternity was not established before Elijah died.”
“Maren said the DNA test was strong.”
“It may be. Warren says he did not trust the private laboratory and wanted court-supervised testing.”
“That still doesn’t explain the pediatrician.”
“He denies knowing which pediatrician Eli uses.”
“Do you believe him?”
“I believe records.”
“What records?”
“We’re working on that.”
Then Avery gave them the update that changed the day.
Jama’s car had been found.
It was parked at the Atlanta bus terminal.
Her phone was inside the glove compartment.
Her purse was gone.
So was she.
Holding Eli changed Charles’s understanding of scale.
The baby’s entire back fit along his forearm. His hand could cover most of the child’s chest without trying. Charles had spent two days thinking about trusts, investigators, legal memos, hidden relationships, and dead sons. Eli reduced the world to whether his neck was supported and whether the bottle was warm enough.
Charles liked that and distrusted how much he liked it.
After Elodie went upstairs, he stayed in the kitchen with the baby for ten more minutes.
“Your father hated peas,” he said quietly.
Eli stared at him.
“That is not useful information at your age.”
The baby yawned.
Charles smiled.
“He also fixed things that were not broken. Your grandmother has a lamp he rewired three times because he insisted the switch sounded wrong.”
Eli’s eyes drifted closed.
Charles stopped.
He had almost said, You’re going to be like him.
The sentence formed automatically.
He swallowed it.
“You don’t have to be like anybody,” he whispered instead.
That was harder to say than it should have been.
In Charles’s family, resemblance had always been treated as inheritance. Micah had Charles’s shoulders, so people said he would be stubborn. Elijah had Elodie’s smile, so relatives called him charming before he knew what charm was. Children were assigned futures through faces.
Charles wondered how many predictions became pressure simply because adults repeated them often enough.
When Zaria came down, she found him still holding Eli.
“You look scared,” she said.
“I am.”
“Of dropping him?”
“No.”
She waited.
Charles looked at the sleeping baby. “Of loving him for the wrong reason.”
Zaria’s expression softened.
“There probably isn’t a perfectly clean reason.”
“That does not sound reassuring.”
“It isn’t supposed to. Just keep noticing when the reason starts telling you what he owes you.”
Charles looked at her.
“You and Elodie have formed a union.”
May you like
“We meet Thursdays.”
He laughed quietly so he would not wake the baby.