scribe

Chapter 13 - The Brother Who Chose the Wrong Side

Eric Morgan requested the meeting.

He arrived at Naomi’s office without his usual confidence and placed a thumb drive on the table.

“I copied everything before I deleted it.”

Thomas stared at him. “Deleted what?”

“My messages with Grant.”

Laura closed her eyes.

Eric continued quickly. “I know how that sounds.”

“It sounds like obstruction,” Naomi said.

“I never destroyed subpoenaed material. This was before any preservation notice.”

“That distinction may save your license. It does not make this admirable.”

Eric nodded.

He looked at Thomas.

“Grant contacted me eleven months ago. He said you were having some kind of breakdown.”

Thomas laughed bitterly.

“He showed me transfers with your credentials.”

“Forged.”

“I didn’t know that.”

“You didn’t ask.”

Eric flinched.

The pattern again.

Guilt first.

Questions later.

“I believed him,” Eric said. “At least partly. And I thought if I could get the documents back, the company would leave you alone.”

“You took his money?”

“No.”

“Then what did you get?”

Eric looked ashamed.

“A promise.”

“For what?”

“To keep my firm on Halcyon’s outside real-estate panel.”

Thomas sat back.

There it was.

Not a suitcase of cash.

Not cinematic corruption.

Something ordinary enough to be rationalized.

Future business.

Access.

Status.

A brother telling himself he was preventing disaster while protecting his own interests.

Eric pushed the thumb drive forward.

“There’s a message from Grant about Bella.”

Laura’s hand froze.

Naomi inserted the drive into an isolated laptop.

The message was dated three weeks earlier.

GRANT: Laura will not sign anything tied directly to Halcyon now. Whitmore gives us another route.

ERIC: Leave Bella out of it.

GRANT: No one is touching the child. We need Laura in a room with counsel.

ERIC: And Thomas?

GRANT: He’ll overreact. That helps us.

Thomas’s face emptied.

Eric whispered, “I told him no.”

“You kept working with him.”

“I was trying to contain it.”

“You helped him understand exactly how I would react.”

Eric looked down.

Naomi scrolled.

Another exchange.

GRANT: Does Thomas still use the old locker?

ERIC: I don’t know.

GRANT: Find out.

Laura stood.

“You knew.”

“I knew he wanted documents. I didn’t know Keene had used your identity.”

“But you took the key.”

“Yes.”

“And put it in Bella’s bag.”

“Yes.”

Thomas walked to the far wall.

For years he had trusted his brother more than anyone.

Even when he stopped trusting Laura.

That realization seemed to hit him physically.

Eric stood too.

“I’m going to cooperate with the investigators.”

Thomas did not turn.

“You should.”

“I’m sorry.”

Thomas said nothing.

Eric left.

For several minutes, the room remained silent.

Then Naomi opened another file from the drive.

A PDF invoice.

Northline Civic Consulting billed Halcyon $75,000 for “campus risk management services.”

The payment beneficiary was not Julian Vale personally.

It was a limited liability company registered to his wife.

Laura stared.

“So Vale was paid too.”

Naomi nodded.

“And look at the date.”

The invoice had been approved eight months earlier.

Two days after Thomas first requested Whitmore’s scholarship-grant records from Halcyon.

Thomas turned from the wall.

“Whitmore received scholarship money through Halcyon.”

“Yes,” Laura said.

He came closer.

“What if the two million didn’t leave education?”

Naomi frowned.

“What do you mean?”

“What if it was moved between education entities to hide who actually benefited?”

He took the laptop.

Northline had billed Halcyon.

Whitmore had received grants.

Vale had received consulting money.

Price had received consulting money.

The school and the company were not separate stories.

They were one system.

And Bella’s classroom had simply been the smallest room inside it.

Eric’s thumb drive contained more than messages with Grant.

There were invoices his firm had received for Halcyon property work, internal notes, and one draft email Eric had written to Thomas but never sent.

Thomas opened it.

Tom,

I think you may be right about Grant, but if you keep pushing this the way you are, they will bury you before you prove it. Take the settlement. Keep copies somewhere safe. Walk away and be a father.

The draft was dated nine months earlier.

Thomas stared at it.

“He thought I was right.”

Eric had not merely been fooled.

At some point he had suspected the truth and chosen self-preservation anyway.

That hurt more.

Laura read the draft.

“People are rarely one thing,” she said.

“He believed me enough to warn me privately and doubted me enough to help them publicly.”

“Or he believed you and was more afraid of the consequences than the lie.”

Thomas laughed without humor.

“You make that sound better?”

“No.”

She closed the file.

“It makes it clearer.”

Thomas thought of Eric on the porch at childhood homes, college graduations, their mother’s funeral.

Betrayal did not erase love that had existed before it.

That was part of why betrayal hurt.

Naomi marked several messages for investigators but cautioned them against reading motive into every line.

“We can prove actions more easily than hearts.”

Bella, coloring nearby, looked up.

“That should be on a sign.”

Naomi smiled.

“It should be in every courtroom.”

Thomas watched his daughter return to the page.

He had spent months wanting someone to prove his brother had become a bad person.

Now he wanted something harder.

An accurate account of what Eric had done.

May you like

Not more.

Not less.

Related Stories

Other posts