Chapter 18 - What Bella Believed

Mrs. Patel asked Bella to make two lists.
The first was titled THINGS I KNOW.
The second: THINGS I WAS TAUGHT TO BELIEVE.
Bella stared at the page.
Under THINGS I KNOW, she wrote:
I like drawing.
I am good at reading.
My mom loves me.
Hannah is my friend.
Then she stopped.
Under THINGS I WAS TAUGHT TO BELIEVE, the words came faster.
I am weak.
I make excuses.
People don’t like me because I deserve it.
If I ask for help, I am manipulating people.
If someone hurts me, I should ask what I did to cause it.
If I fail, it says something about who I am.
Bella began crying.
Mrs. Patel waited.
“Which list feels more true?”
“The second one.”
“Which list has more evidence?”
Bella looked at the first.
“I don’t know.”
So they examined evidence.
Bella was good at reading: her standardized scores showed it.
Hannah was her friend: Hannah had risked social consequences to tell the
truth.
Rachel loved her: that did not require proof, but Bella had thousands of
examples anyway.
Then they examined “I am weak.”
“What evidence supports that?” Mrs. Patel asked.
“Ms. Cross said it.”
“That is evidence she said it. Is it evidence it is true?”
Bella stared at her.
The distinction was difficult.
But it was a door.
At home, Rachel was learning her own version of the same lesson.
She had blamed herself for not noticing sooner.
Laura Chen challenged her.
“What evidence did you have before Bella told you?”
“Her grades fell.”
“That can happen for many reasons.”
“She was quieter.”
“Also many reasons.”
“I should have known.”
“You’re doing what Eleanor did.”
Rachel recoiled.
Laura continued gently. “You’re taking an outcome and turning it into a
moral judgment about yourself.”
Rachel sat back.
The irony was painful.
Ms. Cross’s logic had infected the mother trying to defeat it.
That night, Rachel told Bella, “I’ve been thinking something unfair.”
Bella looked worried.
“About me?”
“About myself. I kept saying I should have known sooner.”
Bella considered this.
“Did you?”
“No.”
“Then why are you blaming yourself?”
Rachel smiled sadly.
“Good question.”
Bella smiled back.
For the first time, recovery became something they were doing together
rather than something Rachel was doing to Bella.
Then the phone rang.
May you like
It was Dr. Whitaker.
The board had reached a decision regarding Eleanor Cross.