scribe

Chapter 12 - Rules for Fighting

The counselor's office had two identical gray chairs positioned at an angle so neither spouse could avoid the other completely.

Calista hated the chairs immediately.

Oswin hated the small fountain in the corner.

Dr. Camille Rowan, a Black woman in her fifties with silver-framed glasses and a voice that made silence feel deliberate, asked why they had come.

Calista looked at Oswin.

Oswin looked at Calista.

Dr. Rowan waited.

Finally Calista said, “We had an argument.”

Oswin gave a quiet breath that might have been a laugh.

Calista glared at him. “What?”

“Nothing.”

Dr. Rowan looked between them. “Was it one argument?”

Oswin answered. “No.”

That irritated Calista even though she agreed.

They told the story.

Not every detail. Enough.

Calista admitted the line about richer men. Oswin admitted that he had slept in the guest room and later hidden news about possible job loss for a day because he felt ashamed.

Dr. Rowan did not decide who was worse.

That disappointed them both.

“What happens when conflict begins?” she asked.

Calista said, “He gets quiet.”

Oswin said, “She gets sharper.”

“What do you each believe will happen if you don't do that?”

Calista frowned.

Oswin crossed one ankle over the other.

Dr. Rowan looked at Calista first.

She sighed. “If I don't push, nothing changes.”

“Push how?”

“Make the point impossible to ignore.”

“Even if you injure the relationship while making it?”

Calista looked away.

Dr. Rowan turned to Oswin.

“And you?”

“If I stay calm, things don't get out of control.”

“Do they get resolved?”

Oswin hesitated.

“No.”

“So both strategies work for the immediate goal,” Dr. Rowan said. “Calista gets attention. Oswin gets control. And both strategies fail the marriage.”

The sentence sat between them.

Dr. Rowan gave them an assignment that felt insultingly simple.

Three rules for the next argument.

No comparisons to outsiders.

No threatening the relationship unless the speaker genuinely intends to end it.

No leaving the conversation without saying when it will resume.

Calista stared at the notepad Dr. Rowan handed them.

“That's it?”

“For this week.”

“I thought therapy would be deeper.”

Dr. Rowan smiled. “Depth is often what people request when they don't want to practice basics.”

Oswin looked down to hide his amusement.

Calista noticed.

Outside the office, she nudged him with her elbow.

“You enjoyed that.”

“A little.”

They walked toward the parking lot.

Then Calista stopped.

“Do you think we're in serious trouble?”

Oswin turned.

The question contained no performance.

He answered the same way.

“Yes.”

Calista swallowed.

“But I don't think serious means doomed,” he added.

She nodded.

They stood beside their car in the afternoon sun.

“I don't want to be like my parents,” she said.

Oswin knew enough about Yvette and Calista's father to understand what she meant.

“You aren't,” he said.

“How do you know?”

“Because you're here.”

Calista's eyes moved toward the therapist's office building.

“My mother stayed too.”

“Staying isn't the same as working.”

She looked back at him.

The sentence felt important.

They drove home separately because they had arrived from different jobs.

At the first red light, Calista placed the therapy rules on the passenger seat.

No comparisons.

No empty threats.

No disappearing without return.

She thought about how little of marriage was made of grand promises and how much was made of ordinary rules repeated on tired Tuesdays.

For years, she had believed passion proved love.

She was beginning to suspect discipline did too.

The assignment sounded simple until they tried it.

On Monday evening, Oswin came home to find the cabinet beneath the kitchen sink open and Calista sitting cross-legged on the floor with a screwdriver.

He stopped in the doorway.

“What are you doing?”

“Not proving.”

He stared at the screwdriver.

“The hinge is loose.”

“I noticed.”

“And you are repairing it.”

“I am a woman of contradictions.”

Oswin set down his work bag. “I can fix that in five minutes.”

Calista looked up. “That sentence is exactly why Dr. Rowan gave you homework.”

He frowned.

She pointed the screwdriver at him. “You see a loose hinge and immediately need to become useful. Sit down.”

Oswin almost objected. Then he recognized the reflex she was naming.

He sat at the kitchen table.

Calista returned to the cabinet. It took her twelve minutes, two wrong screws, and one muttered insult to the manufacturer. Oswin fought the urge to help.

When the door finally closed evenly, she looked at him with exaggerated triumph.

“See?”

“You made that much harder than necessary.”

“Maybe. But now you know I can survive hardware.”

He smiled.

The next night, the exercise reversed.

Calista had a client dinner at a rooftop restaurant. She changed clothes three times. Each outfit was appropriate. None satisfied her.

Oswin watched from the bedroom chair.

“What is wrong with the black dress?”

“Nothing.”

“Then why is it on the floor?”

Calista studied herself in the mirror wearing a fitted cream suit. “The room is going to be full of people who spend more on shoes than I used to make in a week.”

Oswin waited.

She looked at him through the mirror. “I know what you're thinking.”

“What am I thinking?”

“That I am trying to prove something.”

“I was thinking the black dress looked nice.”

Calista laughed, but the laugh faded quickly.

She sat on the edge of the bed.

“I do this,” she said. “I dress for rooms like I am entering court.”

Oswin leaned forward. “What is the charge?”

“That I don't belong.”

He said nothing.

Calista looked at the clothes spread across the bed. “Sometimes I think if I look expensive enough, nobody can tell how hard I had to work to get invited.”

Oswin considered the admission. “Do you want me to tell you that you belong?”

She almost said yes.

Then she remembered the assignment.

“No. I want to decide what I want to wear.”

She put the black dress back on.

Not because Oswin liked it.

Because she did.

Before leaving, she kissed him and said, “I may still enjoy compliments.”

“You are allowed.”

“Even from rich men?”

Oswin gave her a look.

Calista smiled. “Too soon. I know.”

That week, no proving did not make them passive. It made their motives louder.

Oswin noticed how often he volunteered for household tasks before anyone asked. Calista noticed how often she checked whether strangers seemed impressed. Neither behavior was automatically bad. The problem appeared when the behavior became an argument they were making without words.

May you like

By Sunday, they had failed the assignment at least six times.

They also understood themselves better than they had on Monday.

Related Stories

Other posts