Chapter 8 - THE BOARD MEMBER

Dr. Imani Whitfield arrived at the academy in a navy raincoat and carried no visible folder.
That made her more intimidating than the adults who carried stacks of paper.
Seren, Lyra, Cassian, Maelis, Principal Rowan, and Ms. Harper sat around a conference table in the library. The room smelled of old books and radiator heat.
Dr. Whitfield introduced herself as chair of the Kingsley Education Foundation's scholarship review committee.
"I'm here to establish authorship and process," she said. "Not to decide which member of a family deserves more sympathy."
Maelis's chin lifted slightly.
Dr. Whitfield looked first at Seren.
"Did you write the essay originally submitted on October third?"
"Yes."
"Did you give anyone permission to submit it under Lyra's name?"
"No."
"Did you withdraw your application?"
"No."
Then she looked at Lyra.
"Did you write the essay submitted in your name?"
Lyra looked at Maelis.
Dr. Whitfield noticed.
"You may look at anyone you need to look at," she said gently. "But your answer should be yours."
Lyra's gaze returned to the table.
"No."
Maelis inhaled.
Lyra continued. "I wrote other things, but not that one."
Dr. Whitfield nodded once.
"Thank you."
She turned to Maelis.
"Did you create the duplicate application?"
"I helped my daughter apply."
"Did you upload Seren's essay?"
"I used a family draft as a model and revised it."
"Did Lyra perform those revisions?"
"I assisted her."
"Did she perform them?"
Maelis's jaw tightened.
"Not all of them."
Dr. Whitfield turned to Cassian.
"Did you withdraw Seren's original application?"
Cassian adjusted his cuff.
"I believed we had agreed as a family that Lyra needed the opportunity more."
Seren felt Lyra flinch beside her.
Dr. Whitfield's voice remained neutral.
"My question was whether you withdrew it."
"Yes."
"Without Seren's knowledge?"
"Yes."
"Did you tell the foundation Seren intended the essay to represent Lyra?"
"Yes."
"Was that true?"
Cassian paused.
"No."
Rain tapped against the library windows.
Dr. Whitfield looked down for the first time.
"That is helpful."
Maelis leaned forward. "Helpful to what? To destroying Lyra's confidence?"
Dr. Whitfield met her gaze.
"Mrs. Vale, Lyra has been placed in a position where adults prepared her to answer questions about another child's dead mother as though those memories were her own. My concern for her confidence is one reason this review is necessary."
Maelis's face changed.
Not guilt.
Anger.
Seren had rarely seen anyone challenge her so directly without giving her room to redirect the conversation.
Dr. Whitfield continued.
"The award will remain frozen. Seren's original application will be restored to the blind-review record under her own identity. Because the scoring has already occurred, the foundation will appoint two reviewers who have not seen either child's name to verify the score independently."
Cassian said, "And Lyra?"
"Her application cannot stand as submitted."
Lyra stared at her hands.
Dr. Whitfield turned toward her.
"That is not a statement about your intelligence or worth. It is a statement about the application."
Lyra whispered, "Okay."
Maelis reached for her shoulder.
Lyra moved slightly away.
Then Dr. Whitfield opened her bag and removed one sheet of paper.
"There is a separate issue."
Cassian's expression tightened.
"The foundation's financial-aid office received a request from the Vale household asking whether the scholarship could be paid as a tuition reimbursement rather than a future credit."
Seren looked at her father.
"Reimbursement for what?"
Dr. Whitfield answered carefully.
"For tuition the household claimed had already been paid on Lyra's behalf."
Principal Rowan frowned.
"Our records show Lyra's spring tuition balance is still open."
Silence.
Dr. Whitfield looked at Cassian and Maelis.
"So now I have a new question."
She slid the page across the table.
"What payment were you asking us to reimburse?"
During the recess, Seren watched Maelis pace near the vending machines while Cassian spoke to his attorney in a low voice.
Lyra sat on the carpet with her back against the wall.
"I thought scholarships were just good news," she said.
Seren sat beside her.
"Me too."
"If they give it to you, are you going to hate me every time they pay tuition?"
Seren looked at her sister.
"No."
"Promise?"
"I can't promise what I'll feel every day."
Lyra frowned.
Seren continued. "But if I get it, I know you didn't take it from me by yourself."
"Mom says you talk like a lawyer."
"Mom was a lawyer."
The word came out naturally: Mom.
For months, adults had spoken about Camille as though mentioning her too often created tension. Seren suddenly resented every time she had replaced Mom with my biological mother just to keep other people comfortable.
Lyra leaned her head back against the wall.
"I barely remember her."
"You were little."
"Was she nice to me?"
Seren searched her memories.
A summer picnic. Camille tying Lyra's shoelace. A birthday card with a purple sticker.
"Yes."
Lyra looked relieved.
"Good. Because my fake essay made it sound like I remembered her."
Seren's chest tightened.
"It wasn't your fake essay."
Lyra turned toward her.
Seren corrected herself.
"It was a fake application with your name on it. That's different."
May you like
Lyra nodded slowly.
The distinction felt important enough to keep.