Chapter 9 - Before the Portico

Honoria claimed she had been in her bedroom at nine forty-five.
Her maid contradicted her.
Edith Sloan had served Honoria for twenty-two years and looked physically ill when Sheriff Mercer questioned her.
"Madam dismissed me at nine thirty," Edith said. "She said she wanted no one in the east corridor until morning."
"Was that unusual?"
"Very."
"Did she say why?"
"She said Mrs. Theodora needed quiet with the infants."
Theodora stared at the statement when Mercer showed it to her.
"I never asked for quiet."
"I know. Agnes says you rang for hot water at nine thirty-five and no one answered because staff had been sent to the detached kitchen."
"By whom?"
"Mr. Cray. He said there was a gas leak in the servants' hall."
"There is no gas in the servants' hall. We use oil lamps."
"Exactly."
The pattern tightened.
Servants diverted.
The front door modified.
A key in Honoria's private case.
The trust nearing transfer.
Missing company funds.
But Mercer still did not have direct proof that Honoria started the fire.
The insurance examiner's preliminary report placed the origin in Percival's old records room beside the drawing room. The ignition appeared low, near a rug and cabinet. Lamp oil residue was present in the floorboards.
"Could a lamp have fallen?" Theodora asked.
"There was no lamp stand there," Bell said. "And the oil was spread in more than one direction."
"So it was set."
Bell looked at Mercer.
"In my professional opinion, yes."
Arson.
The word now had evidence behind it.
The district attorney authorized a formal criminal inquiry.
Gideon Vale responded by becoming helpful.
Too helpful, in Theodora's view.
He arrived with copies of trust papers, bank authorizations, and letters suggesting that Honoria had personally directed North River payments.
"You kept these?" Theodora asked.
"I keep everything."
"Except the truth from me."
Vale's lips thinned.
"I am an attorney. Confidentiality is not deceit."
"Sometimes it is paid deceit."
He ignored that.
"Your mother-in-law acted beyond my advice on many occasions. I repeatedly cautioned her against aggressive estate measures."
Theodora opened one of his letters.
It contained his signature below a transfer order.
"You signed this."
"At her direction."
"So did Alistair."
"And he will have to explain that."
Theodora looked at him.
"You seem eager for everyone else to explain."
Vale's eyes cooled.
"Be careful whom you accuse."
"That is the second time someone in this family has told me to be careful since I survived the fire. I am beginning to hear it as encouragement."
After he left, Theodora asked Finch to examine Vale's fees over the past five years.
"Why?" Finch asked.
"Because a man who bills for secrets often leaves arithmetic behind."
That evening, while Agnes bathed Clara, Theodora went to the twins' nursery in the damaged house to retrieve a carved cradle panel Percival had commissioned before his death.
The room was cold and smelled faintly of smoke.
She found the panel under a sheet.
As she lifted it, something metallic clinked against the floor.
A small silver button.
Not from her clothing. Not from Agnes's.
It bore a tiny engraved V.
Theodora had seen buttons like it before.
Gideon Vale's evening waistcoat had a row of them.
She carried it directly to Mercer.
"Do not decide what it means yet," he cautioned.
"It means he was in the nursery."
"It may mean he visited the room on another day."
"He told me he had not entered the family wing in months."
Mercer stopped.
"That," he said, "is more useful."
The next morning, Vale was asked to account for his movements on the night of the fire.
He said he had been at his hotel in Albany.
The hotel register showed he had checked in after midnight.
May you like
His carriage driver remembered collecting him from a road less than a mile from Wrenford Hall at ten thirty.
And suddenly Honoria was no longer the only person whose whereabouts before the portico mattered.