Chapter 2 - What Jennifer Saw

Jennifer arrived at Hawthorne Academy in seventeen minutes.
She entered the main building without removing her raincoat, her
honey-brown hair damp around her shoulders. Hawthorne’s reception area
was designed to reassure wealthy parents: dark wood, framed university
pennants, fresh white flowers, photographs of smiling children beside
donors whose names appeared on buildings. Jennifer barely looked at any
of it.
Ellie was seated outside Headmaster Arthur Bell’s office.
Her schoolbag was on her lap now.
Jennifer crouched and pulled her close. “Are you okay?”
Ellie nodded against her shoulder, then whispered, “Ms. Caldwell told me
to keep it about the watch.”
Jennifer leaned back. “What does that mean?”
“I don’t know.”
The office door opened.
Ms. Caldwell stood beside Headmaster Bell, a polished man in his late
fifties whose silver tie matched his hair. Tori sat inside with her
mother, Caroline Hayes.
Caroline rose when Jennifer entered.
“I’m sorry this has become dramatic,” she said.
Jennifer looked at Ellie. “It became dramatic when a child was publicly
accused without evidence.”
Bell raised a placating hand. “No one has reached a formal conclusion.”
Ellie looked up. “She sent me into the hallway because I wouldn’t say I
took it.”
Bell glanced at Ms. Caldwell.
The teacher answered carefully. “Eleanor was becoming argumentative.”
“I said you didn’t ask what happened,” Ellie replied.
Jennifer saw the faint flush rise in Caldwell’s neck.
Caroline sighed. “Victoria is certain the watch disappeared during
lunch.”
“Certain Ellie took it?” Jennifer asked.
Tori stared at the carpet.
“I saw her near my desk.”
Ellie turned sharply. “I was putting my library book away.”
Jennifer asked, “Has anyone searched the room?”
Bell smiled without warmth. “We don’t conduct searches of children’s
belongings over minor property disputes.”
“Yet you punished mine.”
Silence.
Jennifer’s gaze moved across the office. On Bell’s credenza sat a framed
photograph from Hawthorne’s Founders Gala. She recognized several
trustees.
Then she recognized one man in the back row.
Her husband, Charles Whitmore.
The photograph was dated eighteen months earlier.
Charles had told her he had never attended a Hawthorne trustee event.
Jennifer walked closer.
Bell noticed.
“That was before your daughter enrolled,” he said.
“I know.”
Charles was standing beside Caroline Hayes.
Between them was a man Jennifer had spent the last six months hearing
about on television: Martin Voss, former chief financial officer of
Whitmore Development, who had accused Charles of diverting money from a
municipal redevelopment project.
The scandal had not produced criminal charges, but it had nearly
destroyed Charles’s company.
Jennifer looked at Caroline.
“You knew my husband before our daughters were classmates.”
Caroline’s expression remained smooth. “Westchester is a small world.”
“Not that small.”
Bell interrupted. “Mrs. Whitmore, I think we should focus on today.”
Jennifer looked at the photograph again.
Then she noticed something reflected in its glass.
A red light above Bell’s office door.
A security camera.
“Good,” she said. “Then let’s focus on today. Show me the classroom
footage.”
Bell’s smile disappeared.
“There is no classroom footage.”
Ellie spoke from beside her.
“Yes, there is.”
Everyone turned.
Ellie pointed through the glass wall toward the corridor.
“There’s a camera outside our classroom. And yesterday Ms. Caldwell told
us it could see the whole doorway.”
Bell’s eyes moved to Caldwell.
Jennifer saw it again: that tiny tremor in the teacher’s hand.
Then Bell said, too quickly, “Unfortunately, that camera has been
offline since Monday.”
May you like
Ellie frowned.
“No, it hasn’t.”