scribe

Chapter 1 - The Light Switch

The paper trembled in Ella Foster’s hands before Victor even raised his voice.

Seventy-two percent.

The red number seemed brighter than anything else in her small bedroom. Her teacher had written, “You understand the ideas, but you rushed. Please slow down next time.” Ella had read that sentence three times on the bus ride home. It had embarrassed her, but it had not frightened her.

Victor frightened her.

“You knew this test was coming,” he said, standing beside her desk in his dark knit sweater. “We talked about it all week.”

Ella stared at the wooden floor. “I studied.”

“Then why is this what you brought home?”

She clutched her schoolbook against her chest. “It was hard.”

Victor gave a short, humorless laugh. “Life is hard. That is not an excuse.”

From the hallway came the soft clink of a mug. Ella knew her mother was there. Sandra had been moving between the kitchen and bedroom for several minutes, never quite entering, never quite leaving.

Victor tapped the test paper with one finger. “You waste time. You daydream. You make excuses. And then everybody else has to deal with the result.”

Something inside Ella tightened. She was tired. Tired of his rules about shoes, voices, doors, homework, pencils, the order of books on her desk. Tired of watching her mother look down whenever Victor looked up.

“I said I studied,” Ella whispered.

“What?”

“I said I studied.” She looked at him this time. “You don’t have to keep saying it.”

The room changed.

Victor’s face did not twist into anger. That would almost have been easier. Instead, it became still.

“You think talking back makes you clever?”

He snatched the book from her hands.

Ella recoiled. Her heel caught the leg of the chair. She stepped backward to keep from falling and struck her forehead against the edge of the study table.

The sound was small. A dull wooden knock.

Pain flashed across her brow.

Ella gasped and pressed her palm to the spot. Tears came instantly, more from shock than injury.

“It hurts, Dad…”

Victor looked at her hand covering her forehead.

For one second, Ella believed he might come closer.

Instead, he crossed the room.

The light switch clicked.

Darkness swallowed the desk, the narrow bed, the gray skirt folded over Ella’s knees, the schoolbooks, the pencil cup, and Victor’s face.

“Sit there in the dark and think about your attitude.”

He walked into the hallway.

Sandra stood in the doorway.

Warm light outlined her beige cardigan and medium-brown hair. Ella could see her mother’s hand wrapped around the door handle.

“Mom?”

Sandra’s eyes moved to Ella’s forehead, then to the abandoned test paper on the floor.

Ella waited.

Sandra’s fingers tightened around the handle.

Then she slowly pulled the door closed.

The warm strip of hallway light narrowed across Ella’s face until it disappeared.

She sat beside the desk with one hand pressed to her forehead and the other curled against her stomach. From the hall came footsteps moving away.

She did not know how long she remained there.

Long enough for the ache to dull.

Long enough for the house to become quiet.

Long enough to understand that being alone was not the same thing as being unseen.

The next morning, the bruise was faint but visible.

Ella sat at her desk in homeroom, her dark-brown hair tied loosely back, trying to keep her face turned toward the window.

Ms. Harper noticed anyway.

The teacher crouched beside her desk. Her voice was gentle. “Ella, what happened there?”

Ella’s fingers tightened around her pencil.

For an instant she saw Victor’s hand taking the book, the desk edge, the light going out, her mother’s face framed in the doorway.

Then she lowered her eyes.

“I bumped into the cabinet myself.”

Ms. Harper did not answer right away.

Ella looked at the worksheet in front of her.

She thought the lie was finished.

For the rest of the morning, Ella kept touching the tender spot through her hair. Every time Ms. Harper passed her desk, she lowered her hand quickly, as though even checking the bruise might reveal too much. During math, she made two mistakes she normally would have caught. During reading, she stared at the same paragraph until the words lost meaning.

What bothered her most was not the pain. It was the fact that the classroom lights stayed on without anyone earning them. Children whispered, chairs scraped, pencils rolled onto the floor, and nobody had to wonder whether a wrong answer might make the room disappear. Ordinary things suddenly felt like privileges she had never known were privileges.

When the bell rang, Ms. Harper did not stop Ella. She only said, “Have a good afternoon.” The kindness almost hurt more than suspicion would have.

May you like

Ella walked into the hallway telling herself that the safest version of a story was the smallest one. A cabinet. An accident. Nothing else.

She did not know Ms. Harper had already begun remembering every detail.

Related Stories

Other posts