scribe

Chapter 3 - An Anniversary Full of Secrets

Saturday began with Ruth's birthday brunch and a chocolate cake that leaned dangerously to the left. The dining room filled with cousins, neighbors, and people Joyce had known since childhood. Gabriel wore the pecan sweater without complaint. Ruth declared him an excellent sport and asked whether he had brothers.

“None who are available for matchmaking,” he answered.

Joyce laughed into her coffee. For one morning, the deception was almost pleasant.

Then Margaret asked whether Daniel would join them for Christmas.

The question crossed the table and stopped in front of Joyce like a small, heavy object. Gabriel waited for her answer. Joyce said they had not discussed December. Margaret opened her mouth, but Ruth interrupted with a story about the year a frozen turkey had broken her kitchen sink.

Afterward, Joyce hugged her grandmother beside the birthday candles.

“You don't have to manage everyone's expectations,” Ruth murmured.

Joyce wondered whether the older woman knew more than she had said.

Gabriel drove them to the anniversary party just before sunset. They had changed into evening clothes at the Whitmore house. Joyce wore a midnight-blue dress; Gabriel wore a dark suit without a tie. The house belonged to Claire Hayes and her husband, Thomas Reed, a serious-looking man whose reputation in Charleston was built on wealth and perfect manners.

“Tell me about Claire,” Joyce said.

“She used to teach me how to draw birds. Then she spent years learning that people don't have to be productive to deserve help.”

“And Thomas?”

Gabriel tightened his grip on the steering wheel. “I don't know him as well as I should.”

At the entrance, a smiling attendant took Gabriel's keys. Music drifted through the windows. A woman in a silver dress came running down the steps before they reached the door.

“Gabriel!” Claire threw her arms around her brother. Then she regarded Joyce with delight. “You must be the woman he wouldn't tell us about.”

“Joyce,” Joyce said, relieved to use her real name.

Claire hugged her too. “Welcome to the circus.”

Inside, Gabriel's mother, Helen Hayes, greeted Joyce with a warmth that felt uncomfortably familiar. She asked thoughtful questions about publishing, offered to introduce Joyce to a retired editor, and never once asked when they intended to marry. Joyce began to understand why Gabriel felt pressure even without direct demands. His mother imagined futures for people so vividly that everyone else could see them too.

Thomas approached with two glasses of sparkling water. He congratulated Gabriel on finally bringing a guest, then looked at Joyce with an expression she could not interpret.

“Whitmore,” he repeated. “Any connection to the Charleston Whitmores?”

“My grandmother is Ruth Whitmore.”

Thomas's smile paused. “Of course. A respected family.”

He excused himself almost immediately.

Claire watched him go. “He has been distracted all week. Anniversary planning, I suppose.”

Gabriel glanced toward his sister. “You doing okay?”

“Of course,” she said too quickly.

The party unfolded beneath strings of warm lights. Joyce spoke with artists supported by Claire's foundation and learned about a neighborhood arts center threatened by redevelopment. Claire had spent two years gathering funds to buy its building. Thomas had promised help finding investors. Recently, that support had become less certain.

“It's complicated,” Claire said, twisting her bracelet. “But tonight we're supposed to celebrate.”

Joyce thought of the way Ruth's face had changed when she described the old bookstore. Buildings were never only buildings to people who had loved what happened inside them.

Near the terrace, Gabriel quietly asked Joyce to dance. She hesitated.

“This is your family's party,” she said. “We don't have to perform.”

“I'm not asking for them.”

She took his hand.

They moved carefully at first. Gabriel did not pull her close. He matched the distance she chose and watched her face when the music changed. Joyce had spent so much time assessing whether others approved of her that she found the absence of judgment disorienting.

“You're quiet,” he observed.

“I'm thinking.”

“Dangerous.”

“Your sister seems unhappy.”

Gabriel looked past her shoulder. “She says everything's fine.”

“That isn't the same thing.”

Before he could answer, Thomas appeared at the edge of the dance floor and asked Gabriel for a private word. Gabriel stepped away. Joyce moved toward the terrace, where she heard raised voices behind a partly closed study door.

“You promised the transfer would wait,” Gabriel said.

Thomas answered softly. Joyce caught only one phrase: the Whitmore property.

She turned as the door opened. Thomas saw her standing there, and a flash of alarm crossed his face.

“Looking for the powder room?” he asked.

Joyce said yes. It was a weak lie, but it gave her an exit.

In the hallway she nearly collided with Claire, who carried a small framed sketch of two birds. Claire looked toward the study, then back at Joyce.

“My husband and Gabriel have different ideas about the arts center,” she explained.

“Do you know why your husband mentioned my family?” Joyce asked.

Claire's smile disappeared. “No. Why would he?”

In the powder room, Joyce stood before the mirror and adjusted an earring that needed no adjustment. She could hear the distant clink of glasses and the steady warmth of conversation through the door. A successful party, she realized, could conceal any number of private disasters. Everyone knew how to applaud an anniversary. Few people knew what questions to ask the morning afterward. She remembered Claire describing a building full of children and wondered what it felt like to champion a project while someone closest to you treated it as a nuisance. Joyce had spent years editing other people's stories for clarity. In this house, however, she could not tell which scenes belonged together.

May you like

There was room enough.

Joyce had no answer. At the bottom of the stairs, her phone lit with a message from Emily: Is Daniel having fun? Joyce looked up toward Gabriel emerging from the study, pale and furious. The two names she had been juggling suddenly seemed like the smallest secret in the room.

Related Stories

Other posts