scribe

Chapter 4

The anniversary dinner at Marcella and Leonard’s house did not unfold as smoothly as Marcella had intended.

It began late because she and Cassian had needed to transfer all twenty-four meal containers into their own cars and drive them across town themselves. The kitchen there was too small for their irritation, and the guests kept arriving in shimmering dresses and tailored jackets while Marcella tried to plate food without admitting anything had gone wrong.

Leonard, who noticed more than he commented on, watched his wife direct cousins toward the dining room and ask nieces to refill iced tea. He waited until there was a brief gap in the noise, then leaned toward Cassian near the sink and asked, “Where’s Althea?”

Cassian kept stacking serving spoons. “She stayed home.”

Leonard looked at him over the rim of his glasses. “That doesn’t answer me.”

Cassian didn’t reply.

By then Selene had arrived.

She was elegant in a bronze sheath dress, carrying the same polished ease that had once made Marcella feel her son had married upward. She greeted Leonard warmly, kissed Marcella’s cheek, and accepted a glass of sparkling water from a cousin before asking the obvious question.

“Where’s Althea?”

Marcella’s smile shifted. “She wasn’t able to make it.”

Selene glanced at the loaded buffet. “But she made all this?”

Cassian, standing a few feet away, felt the question like a splinter.

Marcella answered before he could. “We decided it would be easier this way.”

Selene’s brows drew together. “Easier for whom?”

Marcella gave her a look meant to end the subject. “Tonight is Leonard’s and my night, dear.”

But the question lingered.

By the time guests were seated, enough relatives had noticed Althea’s absence to start their own versions of concern. Some assumed she was ill. One aunt quietly asked if there had been a disagreement. Marcella smiled too brightly and said, “Just a small change of plans.”

Leonard stood to give a toast before dinner and let his gaze rest one beat longer than usual on the empty place setting beside Cassian.

“To marriage,” he said, his voice carrying gently over the room, “and to the people who make a family stronger by the daily work nobody applauds enough.”

Marcella smiled at him from her chair.

Cassian felt every word.

The meal should have tasted familiar. It didn’t. Althea’s food was excellent, but in her absence each tray seemed to accuse him of something he had not yet named properly.

Selene sat halfway down the table listening to distant cousins discuss schools and church renovations. At one point she caught Cassian’s eye and gave him a look that said plainly: We are speaking later.

He looked away.

After dessert, while the older guests drifted into the living room and younger ones collected purses and shawls, Selene found him alone in the den adjusting framed photos on the mantel just to keep his hands occupied.

“What happened?” she asked.

Cassian sighed. “My mother thought tonight would be awkward.”

“Because I was coming?”

He said nothing.

Selene stared at him. “You let them exclude your wife because I was on a guest list?”

“It wasn’t like that.”

Her expression hardened with disappointment rather than anger. “Then explain how it was.”

Cassian opened his mouth and heard how weak his own reasons sounded before they formed.

Selene folded her arms. “I would not have come if I knew I was being used as an excuse to push your wife out of the room.”

“No one used you.”

“Cassian.” She lowered her voice. “Do not insult both of us by being cowardly and technical.”

That stung because it was true.

He leaned against the desk behind him. “Mom said she wanted to avoid tension.”

“And you agreed because?”

He looked toward the doorway, where the murmur of family floated in waves.

“Because I thought it would keep the peace.”

Selene shook her head slowly. “No. You thought it would keep your mother comfortable.”

She let that sit.

Then she said, “For what it’s worth, this is exactly why we didn’t work. You always knew what was unfair. You just waited too long to challenge it.”

She walked out before he could defend himself.

Leonard entered the den a minute later and found his son standing very still.

“Your former wife just left through the front door without dessert,” he said mildly. “That’s usually not a sign of a successful evening.”

Cassian rubbed his forehead. “Dad, please.”

Leonard closed the door behind him. “Did your mother tell Althea not to come?”

Cassian hesitated.

That was enough.

Leonard’s mouth flattened. “And you stood there while she did it.”

Cassian looked down.

May you like

“Yes,” he said.

Leonard nodded once, disappointment quiet but unmistakable. “Then I suppose the anniversary toast was for someone else tonight.”

Related Stories

Other posts