Chapter 4 - The Heir’s Alibi

Antonio arrived at the repair shop the next morning alone.
Vincent had not invited him.
He came through the open garage bay wearing a charcoal overcoat and expensive shoes that collected dust with every step.
Vincent was under a lifted pickup truck tightening a bracket.
“You have a problem with phones?” Antonio called.
Vincent rolled out from beneath the truck. “You have a problem with doors?”
Antonio held up his own phone.
On the screen was the photograph sent to Vincent the previous night.
Vincent’s expression changed.
“How did you get that?”
“Father.”
“That was fast.”
“He thinks someone is threatening his grandchild.”
“They are.”
Antonio looked toward the office where Sofia sat with Emilia and Vincent’s office manager.
His voice lowered. “Then stop dragging them into your detective fantasy.”
Vincent stood. “Your CFO paid cash to tow your car to a fake company that received foundation money.”
Antonio’s face tightened. “My car was stolen for six hours that night.”
Vincent laughed once. “Convenient.”
“I reported it to private security.”
“Not the police?”
“My father hates headlines.”
“That habit is working out well.”
Antonio stepped closer.
“Do you think I stole eleven million dollars from my own family?”
“I think you insulted me in front of a room full of people because you believed my daughter threatened your inheritance.”
“That makes me an ass, not a thief.”
Vincent studied him.
Antonio took a breath.
“I was in Milan when that transfer was approved.”
“You know about Claire’s note.”
“Father told me this morning.”
“Can you prove Milan?”
Antonio reached into his coat and tossed a folder onto a workbench.
Inside were hotel invoices, meeting agendas, passport scans, photographs, and flight records.
Vincent did not touch them.
Antonio said, “You look disappointed.”
“No. I look like a man wondering why somebody forged your name.”
“Maybe because they knew Father would suspect me.”
“Would he?”
Antonio’s jaw flexed.
“That is the part you enjoy, isn’t it? Watching him doubt me.”
Vincent shook his head. “You think I want your place. I don’t.”
“Then why are you here?”
“This is my shop.”
Antonio stared at him, then almost smiled despite himself.
For a moment, the hostility eased.
Then Sofia entered from the office.
“Enough,” she said. “Both of you.”
Antonio looked at his sister.
She handed him the copy of the trust amendment.
“You should have seen this from me before the party,” she said. “I’m sorry you didn’t.”
Antonio did not take it.
“Did you know Father was giving Emilia voting rights?”
“No.”
“Would you have accepted?”
Sofia hesitated.
Antonio noticed.
“There.”
“What?”
“That pause.”
She hardened. “Because I don’t know what accepting means anymore.”
“It means you believe you should have part of the company.”
“I already own part of the company.”
“Nonvoting shares.”
“Exactly. The kind Father gave daughters because sons were supposed to lead.”
Antonio went quiet.
Vincent looked at Sofia. They had never discussed that piece so plainly.
She continued. “You’re angry that Emilia changes the balance. I’m angry that there was a balance designed against me in the first place.”
Antonio looked away.
For the first time, Vincent saw something beneath the arrogance: fear.
Not fear of poverty. Fear of becoming unnecessary.
Rebecca Shaw called before the silence could settle.
She had confirmed Antonio’s Milan trip.
More importantly, she had found Claire Donnelly.
She was not in Arizona.
She was living under her maiden name in a rented house outside Pittsburgh.
“Is she willing to talk?” Sofia asked.
“Not by phone,” Rebecca said. “She hung up when I mentioned Bianchi.”
Matteo wanted a private investigator to approach her.
Vincent said no.
Everyone looked at him.
“If she ran because she’s afraid of Bianchi people, sending Bianchi people is stupid.”
Antonio gave a humorless laugh. “And your plan is what? Show up with a wrench?”
Vincent met his eyes.
“My name isn’t Bianchi.”
That afternoon, while Sofia stayed with Emilia at the mansion under strengthened security, Vincent drove west with Antonio in the passenger seat.
Matteo had insisted Antonio come.
“Why him?” Vincent had asked.
“Because if Claire believes his signature was forged,” Matteo said, “he deserves to hear why.”
The drive was miserable.
Two hours from Pittsburgh, Antonio finally spoke.
“You hit hard.”
Vincent looked ahead. “You tackle badly.”
Antonio almost laughed.
Then his phone vibrated.
He read the message and went pale.
“What?” Vincent asked.
Antonio turned the screen.
It was a photograph of Claire Donnelly’s rented house.
Taken that morning.
May you like
Below it was one sentence:
SHE SHOULD HAVE STAYED GONE.