scribe

Chapter 16 - Lucia’s Missing Copy

The original evidence Lucia gathered had been stored in a safe-deposit box under an assumed name. She went to retrieve it with Vincent.

The box was empty.

There was no sign of forced access.

The bank record showed it had been opened four years earlier using valid credentials.

Lucia stared at the log.

“I was in Montreal that day.”

“Who knew the alias?” Vincent asked.

“Only one person.”

She closed her eyes.

Her younger brother, Gabriel Rossi.

Dante remembered Gabriel as charming, restless, and permanently short of money. He had vanished from family circles years earlier.

Lucia admitted she had trusted him during the first year of hiding.

“He helped me move documents,” she said.

“Where is he now?”

“I don’t know.”

Dante’s stare was merciless. “Another person you trusted instead of me.”

Lucia snapped, “At that time, you trusted Salvatore more than me.”

The truth ended the argument.

Marco located Gabriel in Atlantic City, living under his own name and working as a casino host.

They met in a private restaurant room.

Gabriel looked at Lucia and immediately said, “I’m sorry.”

Dante nearly crossed the table.

Vincent stopped him with a glance.

Gabriel confessed Julian had paid him $400,000 to retrieve the safe-deposit documents. He had told himself Lucia’s obsession was destroying her life and that the papers were old family business.

“What happened to them?” Lucia asked.

“I gave them to Julian.”

“All of them?”

Gabriel hesitated.

“No.”

From inside his jacket, he removed a tiny key.

“I kept one thing because I thought someday I’d need insurance.”

The key opened a storage locker at Penn Station.

Inside was a sealed evidence envelope containing Salvatore Moretti’s original handwritten ledger.

And beside it, a cassette tape labeled:

DANTE — IF LUCIA FAILS.

Gabriel Rossi’s betrayal reopened a different wound. Lucia had spent years blaming the Moretti family for manipulation, only to discover her own brother had sold access to the evidence she trusted him to protect.

At the Atlantic City meeting, Gabriel could barely meet her eyes.

“You told me you believed me,” Lucia said.

“I did.”

“You took four hundred thousand dollars from the man I was trying to expose.”

“I was drowning.”

“You were gambling.”

Gabriel flinched.

Dante remained silent, which made him more frightening than shouting would have.

Gabriel explained that Julian approached him after learning about debts owed to casinos and private lenders. He promised enough money to start over in exchange for one simple thing: retrieve documents from Lucia’s safe-deposit box. Gabriel convinced himself the documents were copies.

“I thought Julian already knew everything in them.”

Lucia stared at him. “Then why pay you?”

Gabriel had no answer.

The small key he retained led them to the Penn Station locker. Vincent photographed the locker before opening it, documented the chain of custody, and had a neutral investigator present.

Inside, Salvatore’s ledger was wrapped in oilcloth. The cassette sat beneath it.

There was also a small envelope bearing Lucia’s name.

She opened it.

Inside was a note from Gabriel written four years earlier but never sent.

I did something terrible. I don’t know how to undo it. I kept the ledger because if I gave Julian everything, you would have nothing left to prove you weren’t crazy.

Lucia read it twice.

“You wrote this?”

Gabriel nodded.

“Why keep it instead of sending it?”

“Because apologizing would mean admitting what I did.”

Lucia laughed bitterly.

“Apparently cowardice is hereditary in my family too.”

The line hurt both of them.

On the train back north, Sera sat beside Lucia.

“Do you forgive Uncle Gabriel?”

“Not yet.”

“Do you love him?”

“Yes.”

Sera frowned. “That sounds annoying.”

Lucia smiled through tears. “Extremely.”

Gabriel’s gambling debts also created a legal vulnerability. Julian’s attorneys could portray him as an unreliable witness who changed sides for financial help. Vincent therefore structured Dante’s assistance carefully: no debt forgiveness in exchange for testimony, no cash payment, and full disclosure to counsel.

Gabriel hated the arrangement.

“So I get nothing?”

“You get lawyers helping you negotiate debts you created,” Lucia said. “That is not nothing.”

Gabriel looked at Dante. “You could make some calls.”

“I could,” Dante replied. “That is exactly why I won’t.”

Lucia studied him, surprised again.

Dante continued, “If your testimony is worth anything, it cannot be purchased by me after Julian purchased you first.”

Gabriel winced.

Sera later asked why adults made everything about money.

Lucia answered, “Because money can turn choices into excuses.”

Dante added, “And because people confuse having more options with having no responsibility.”

May you like

Sera thought about that while placing the Rossi key beside the music box.

The family’s wealth had protected them from many ordinary problems. It had also given their worst decisions larger consequences.

Related Stories

Other posts