scribe

Chapter 9 - The Scores

The altered scores gave Ms. Price a motive, but not yet a complete one.

Julia hired an independent education data consultant to examine the spreadsheet. The pattern was subtle. Ms. Price had not simply boosted favorites and punished children she disliked. The changes clustered around students applying for the academy’s elite regional mathematics showcase, an event tied to teacher recognition and donor attention.

Students whose parents were major school contributors had small upward adjustments. Several scholarship students had small downward adjustments.

Lily’s score had been lowered by four points.

Evie’s had not been changed.

“That’s why Lily became dangerous,” Sarah said.

Julia nodded. “She was a witness to something that could cost Price her job. Possibly more, depending on whether records were used for external applications.”

Marianne looked sick. “And Reed?”

“We don’t know whether he knew about the score manipulation before November. But the hallway video shows he knew Price had Lily’s bracelet. The deletion log suggests he tried to remove later evidence. We separate what we can prove from what we suspect.”

At school, Ms. Price announced she would be taking several days of “professional leave.”

The class cheered because they expected a substitute.

Lily did not react.

Evie leaned toward her. “She’s leaving.”

“No,” Lily whispered. “She’s coming back.”

The substitute teacher, Mr. Hale, was gentle and disorganized. For the first time in weeks, the classroom felt ordinary. Students whispered during independent work. Someone dropped a box of crayons. Lily actually laughed once.

Then the classroom phone rang.

Mr. Hale answered.

“Yes, she’s here.” He looked toward Lily. “Lillian, the office needs you.”

Lily’s face went blank.

Evie immediately raised her hand. “Can I go with her?”

Mr. Hale smiled uncertainly. “I don’t think so.”

Lily stood.

At the door, she looked back at Evie.

The same look as before.

But this time Evie remembered her mother’s rule.

No following.

She stayed in her seat.

Her hands clenched under the desk.

Lily returned fifteen minutes later.

She sat down.

“What happened?” Evie whispered.

“Dr. Reed asked if Ms. Price ever hurt me.”

“What did you say?”

Lily stared at the page.

“I said no.”

Evie’s heart sank.

“Why?”

“Because Ms. Price was sitting in the room.”

That afternoon Sarah called Julia immediately.

Julia was furious. Interviewing a child witness about alleged misconduct in the presence of the accused teacher was indefensible from a basic safeguarding perspective.

Marianne drove to the academy and demanded to know why she had not been notified.

Dr. Reed denied that it had been a formal interview.

“It was a check-in,” he said.

“With Ms. Price present?”

“She happened to be there.”

Marianne stepped closer to his desk.

“My niece is nine years old. You will not question her about this again without me or her attorney present.”

Dr. Reed’s jaw tightened.

“You are damaging Lily’s relationship with this school.”

Marianne looked at him for a long moment.

“No,” she said. “You already did that.”

When she returned home, Lily was waiting at the kitchen table.

“I lied today,” Lily whispered.

Marianne sat beside her.

“I know.”

Lily began to cry.

“I don’t want to lie anymore.”

May you like

Marianne took her hand.

“Then we build a place where you don’t have to.”

Related Stories

Other posts