Chapter 22 - Beatrice Was Not a Saint

The full accounting took months, not days.
By June, Wrenford Manor smelled of cut grass and open windows instead of rain. Aurelia’s bruises had faded. The staircase no longer stopped her every time she saw it, though she still preferred to keep one hand firmly on the rail.
Gideon’s financial case grew stronger.
So did the truth about Beatrice.
The accountants uncovered several letters proving that, before she recognized Gideon’s manipulation, Beatrice had willingly authorized two speculative loans he recommended.
One had financed a glassworks expansion that failed. Another backed a land speculation near Troy. Beatrice’s own notes showed she had approved both after Gideon assured her the risks were minimal. When the investments soured, she blamed Edmund for not intervening even though she had deliberately excluded him from the decisions.
Cassian reacted with anger that bordered on panic.
“She wasn’t stupid.”
“No one said she was,” Edmund replied.
“She wouldn’t waste money.”
“Intelligent people make bad investments.”
“She knew things.”
“Yes.”
Cassian struck the table with his palm. “Stop saying yes like it doesn’t matter!”
Edmund flinched but did not raise his voice. “It matters because she was a person, not a monument.”
The word monument followed Cassian for the rest of the day. A monument could not contradict itself, apologize, choose badly, or learn. Beatrice had been easier to worship when she had no flaws. Gideon’s forged letter had succeeded partly because perfection made imitation simple: any severe warning could be accepted as sacred if it arrived under her name.
By evening, Cassian understood why the truth felt almost like a second death. He was not losing his mother again. He was losing the version of her that had never truly lived. She had also written bitterly to her sister about Edmund and had once threatened to amend Cassian’s trust to exclude Edmund from any management role.
Cassian read one of those letters and looked betrayed.
“She did not trust Father.”
“Not then,” Aurelia said.
“But the blue letter said she was sorry.”
“People can change their minds when they learn more.”
Cassian stared at his mother’s portrait.
For years, Beatrice had existed in his memory as perfection: beautiful, dead, therefore unchangeable. Gideon had exploited that perfection by making every forged sentence sound sacred.
Now the real woman reappeared in fragments.
She had been proud.
She had been frightened of poverty despite having money.
She had mistrusted Edmund.
She had made poor decisions.
She had corrected some of them too late.
Cassian hated this version at first.
“Why are you showing me bad things about her?” he demanded.
Edmund answered before Aurelia could.
“Because hiding them would turn her into another lie.”
Cassian left the room.
He did not speak to his father for the rest of the day.
That evening, Aurelia found him sitting on the back steps watching fireflies rise over the lawn.
“She can’t defend herself,” he said.
“No.”
“So people can say whatever they want.”
“That is why evidence matters.”
He picked at a loose thread on his sleeve.
“Did you dislike her?”
“I never met her.”
“You live in her house.”
Aurelia looked toward the manor.
“I live in a house she once lived in.”
Cassian considered the distinction.
“Father loved her.”
“Yes.”
“Then he loved you.”
“Yes.”
“Can both be real?”
Aurelia smiled faintly. “Most hearts are less tidy than legal documents.”
Cassian leaned against the stone pillar.
After a while he said, “I think I wanted her to be perfect because if she was perfect, then loving her was easy.”
Aurelia felt something inside her soften.
“And if she was not?”
“Then I have to decide what parts I keep.”
That was exactly what grief required, though Aurelia did not tell him so.
The next major development came from the criminal investigation.
Peter Sloan’s records, the bank clerk’s testimony, the forged instruments, the attempted archive burglary, and Joseph Crane’s account formed a connected body of evidence. Gideon’s lawyers negotiated.
He would not confess to ordering Cassian to harm Aurelia because no evidence established that he had done so.
He would, however, plead guilty to multiple financial and document offenses rather than face a broader trial carrying greater exposure. Harker entered his own agreement on lesser charges after admitting his role in bypassing signature controls and facilitating transfers.
Joseph Crane pleaded to arson and related offenses. Martin Keene pleaded to burglary and agreed to testify about Gideon’s retrieval order.
When Price explained the likely outcomes, Cassian looked dissatisfied.
“Mr. Vale should say what he did to me.”
“He may never say it the way you want,” Aurelia said.
“But the memorandum proves it.”
“It proves he intended to use your resentment and guide it without overt instruction.”
“That is what he did.”
“Yes.”
“Then why won’t he say sorry?”
Aurelia looked toward the open window.
“Because remorse cannot be subpoenaed.”
Cassian hated that answer too.
May you like
But later, when he passed Beatrice’s portrait, he no longer stopped beneath it as though awaiting orders.
He simply said, “Good night, Mother,” and kept walking.