Chapter 10 - The Deal They Thought Was Finished
Seraphina claimed she was spending the night at her sister’s house in Summit.
Vincent let her leave.
Federal investigators, already briefed through Rachel Stein, knew Caruso had returned. They advised Vincent not to follow Seraphina or interfere.
So he did something far more difficult.
He waited.
At 11:40 p.m., Seraphina returned without the suitcase.
Vincent was in the library.
“You’re back early,” he said.
“My sister had a migraine.”
“Convenient.”
“What?”
“Nothing.”
She looked exhausted. “I’m going to bed.”
Vincent watched her leave.
The next morning federal agents detained Anthony Caruso at a hotel near Newark Airport on an unrelated sealed financial warrant tied to charity fraud records Elaine had helped uncover. Vincent learned only after Rachel called.
“He’s asking for a lawyer,” she said. “And apparently he wants to negotiate.”
“With what?”
“Information.”
Two days later prosecutors requested Vincent’s cooperation interview.
Caruso had begun talking.
According to Rachel, he admitted siphoning charity money and falsifying trust records. He claimed Seraphina knowingly assisted and later pressured him to forge Vincent’s authorization for Bellweather loans.
But on Lucia’s death, Caruso gave a different account.
“He says Lucia’s aneurysm was real,” Rachel told Vincent.
Vincent gripped the edge of the conference table.
“So nobody killed her.”
“That is his claim. Medical records may support it.”
“Then why the lies about Trenton?”
“Because she collapsed after confronting him.”
Vincent stared.
“Where?”
“At a property office near Princeton. She had followed him there to photograph documents connected to the land scheme.”
Vincent’s face went rigid.
“Was Seraphina there?”
“Yes.”
Rachel continued carefully. “Caruso says Lucia became extremely upset, complained of a sudden severe headache, and collapsed. He called an ambulance.”
“And Seraphina?”
“She left before first responders arrived.”
Vincent closed his eyes.
That was monstrous enough. Seraphina had watched Lucia collapse and later entered Vincent’s life without telling him.
But Rachel was not finished.
“Caruso says Seraphina wanted him to destroy Lucia’s bag because it contained evidence. He refused. He removed the documents, but kept the bag.”
“Where?”
“Storage facility in Edison. Agents recovered it this morning.”
Inside Lucia’s bag was a notebook.
Vincent read photocopies later that day.
The final entries described Caruso’s fraud, Seraphina’s role, and a planned land acquisition company. One page listed parcels around the future logistics corridor.
Another contained a sentence underlined twice:
S. says Vincent will marry someone like her eventually because he confuses admiration with loyalty.
Vincent read it three times.
Lucia had understood him more clearly than he understood himself.
That evening he found Bella in the library doing homework.
“Can I tell you something about your mother?”
Bella looked up.
“Yes.”
“She was trying to protect you.”
“From Seraphina?”
“From several people. Including people I trusted.”
“Did Seraphina hurt her?”
Vincent chose his words carefully. “She saw your mother collapse and left instead of helping. Then she hid what she knew.”
Bella’s face went pale.
“Why?”
“Money. Fear. Ambition. Maybe all three.”
Bella looked down at Mr. Buttons.
“Did Mama know Seraphina would marry you?”
Vincent swallowed.
“No. I don’t think so.”
But Lucia’s notebook suggested Seraphina had already imagined something like it.
That night Seraphina entered Vincent’s bedroom.
“You spoke to federal agents,” she said.
It was not a question.
Vincent looked up from his desk.
“How do you know?”
“Because Anthony is in custody.”
“You spoke to him?”
She laughed once, bitterly. “You think I’m stupid?”
“I think you underestimated a nine-year-old with a stuffed rabbit.”
Her face hardened.
Then she said, “You have no idea what Anthony told them about you.”
Vincent leaned back.
“Then tell me.”
May you like
Seraphina’s voice became almost gentle.
“He told them Lucia suspected you knew about the fraud.”