Chapter 20 - What We Were Actually Fighting About

Rowe Commercial Systems hired Monroe Brand Studio.
The contract was professional, specific, and intentionally modest.
Tasha worked primarily with Priya. Andre attended only the meetings where operations mattered. Nobody at the company cared about their history after Marcus learned enough to make one joke and receive a warning look from both of them.
The project went well.
Too well, perhaps.
Professional collaboration gave Andre and Tasha legitimate reasons to speak. Those reasons slowly expanded at the edges.
A question about truck signage became a conversation about neighborhood businesses.
A review of recruiting language became an argument about whether people really left managers or companies.
An invoice question somehow ended with both of them remembering a terrible restaurant where they had once waited ninety minutes for dinner.
The familiarity returned in pieces.
Neither named it.
Then, one evening, Tasha came to Cedar Lane to photograph a Rowe service van Andre had brought home for a mockup.
The work took twenty minutes.
Afterward, she stood on the patio looking at the refinished back door.
"You finally painted it."
Andre looked over. "You remember the old color?"
"Andre, it was a blue so sad it looked unemployed."
He laughed.
Tasha smiled, then noticed the grill.
"Is this the famous appliance?"
"Grill isn't an appliance."
"That sounds like something a homeowner says after buying one expensive water heater."
Andre opened the lid.
"You hungry?"
Tasha hesitated.
It was a small question carrying more weight than food deserved.
"A little."
Andre took two burger patties from the refrigerator inside.
They sat at the patio table as dusk gathered.
For several minutes, they talked about work.
Then Tasha put down her drink.
"Can we talk about us without making it a decision?"
Andre looked at her.
"What does that mean?"
"I don't want a conversation where the point is deciding whether we're getting back together. I want to understand what happened. Better than I did."
Andre leaned back.
His first instinct was caution.
His second was relief.
"Okay."
Tasha folded her hands on the table.
"I used to say you had no ambition. That wasn't true."
Andre waited.
"What I meant was I couldn't see your ambition, and that scared me."
"Why?"
She told him about her father.
Andre knew pieces of the story but not the shape of it.
He knew Mr. Monroe had left when Tasha was young. He did not know about the promised weekends, the bills Lorraine covered without complaint, the way nine-year-old Tasha began judging love by whether it arrived on time.
"When you said, 'Trust me, I'm working on it,' I heard something different than what you meant," she said. "I heard, 'Don't ask questions.'"
Andre looked down at the table.
"Sometimes I did mean that."
Tasha's eyebrows lifted.
"Not because I was hiding anything bad," he continued. "I hated talking about things I might fail at. If I told you I wanted the license and then didn't pass, I thought you'd see me differently. If I said I wanted property and couldn't qualify, I thought I'd look foolish."
"So you waited until things were done."
"Or almost done."
"And I felt shut out."
"I know that now."
Tasha looked toward the yard.
"I responded badly."
"Yes."
She gave him a dry look. "Thank you for the cushioning."
"You asked for honesty."
"I did."
Andre continued. "You started comparing me to people. Coworkers' husbands. Men online. Whoever had the thing you thought I should have next."
Tasha's face tightened.
"I know."
"It made me want to tell you less."
"Which made me push more."
"Which made me tell you less."
They both fell quiet.
There it was.
Not one villain.
A loop.
Tasha rubbed her thumb along the edge of the table.
"I also liked the social proof," she said. "I can't pretend I didn't. I liked dating somebody people could recognize as successful without explanation. That's ugly, but it's true."
Andre considered the words.
"I wasn't embarrassed by what I did," he said. "But I was proud of not caring what anybody thought. Too proud. Sometimes caring how your partner experiences your life isn't vanity."
Tasha met his eyes.
"Did you ever think I wasn't good enough for you?"
The question surprised him.
"No."
"Even at the end?"
Andre took his time.
"I thought you didn't respect me. That's different."
Tasha absorbed that.
"I didn't," she said quietly. "Not enough."
Andre did not rush to comfort her.
The truth deserved room.
After a moment, she asked, "Did you stop loving me before we broke up?"
Andre looked toward the house.
"No."
Tasha inhaled slowly.
"Me neither."
The air between them changed.
Not into romance.
Into honesty sharp enough to be dangerous if mishandled.
Andre stood and gathered their plates.
"This is where people in movies kiss and make a terrible decision," he said.
Tasha laughed, relieved.
"We're not doing that."
"Good."
"You sound too relieved."
"I just bought a house. I can't afford emotional property damage."
She laughed harder.
When she stood to leave, neither reached for the other.
At the gate, Tasha turned.
"I'm glad we talked."
"Me too."
"No decision."
"No decision."
She left.
Andre returned to the patio.
Two empty plates sat beside the grill.
The first time Tasha had stood there after the purchase, the house had been proof she was wrong.
May you like
Tonight, it had been only a house.
That felt healthier.