Chapter 15 - The Question Without the Baby

Dr. Pierce began their second session by removing the pregnancy from the room.
Not literally.
Elowen was visibly pregnant, and the baby shifted hard enough beneath her sweater that she paused once to press a hand against her side.
But the counselor said, “For the next twenty minutes, I want you to imagine there were no pregnancy. The affair happened. The timeline deception did not, because there would be no timeline to manipulate. Just the affair. What would each of you want?”
Elowen looked startled.
Cassiel leaned back in his chair.
“I don’t know,” he said.
Dr. Pierce nodded. “Good. Don’t rush.”
He thought about the question.
If there were no baby, there would be no Marcus permanently connected through parenthood. No paternity test. No birth approaching like a legal and emotional deadline.
There would still be five encounters.
Weeks of emotional intimacy before them.
Months of concealment afterward.
“I might have tried to repair it,” Cassiel said finally.
Elowen looked at him sharply.
He continued. “I don’t know if I would have succeeded. But I think I might have tried.”
Her eyes filled.
Dr. Pierce turned to her. “What happens when you hear that?”
“It makes me think I ruined the chance by getting pregnant.”
Cassiel’s expression changed immediately.
“No.”
Elowen looked at him.
“That is not what I said.”
“But if there were no baby—”
“The baby is not the wrongdoing.”
Dr. Pierce watched silently.
Cassiel leaned forward.
“The baby makes the affair impossible to place entirely in the past. That’s true. Marcus will exist in your life if he parents his child. But the pregnancy is not a punishment and the child is not evidence against you.”
Elowen cried quietly now.
“What changed my view of the marriage most,” Cassiel said, “was not the test result. It was learning you knew the timeline and chose one for me. That happened after the affair.”
Elowen nodded through tears.
Dr. Pierce asked, “Cassiel, do you want to remain married to Elowen?”
The directness changed the air.
He did not answer immediately.
Elowen stared at the floor.
“I don’t know whether I can,” he said.
“That is different from whether you want to.”
Cassiel exhaled.
“Yes.”
A long silence.
“I still love her,” he said. “That’s the humiliating part.”
Elowen looked up.
Dr. Pierce said, “Why humiliating?”
“Because love feels like evidence I’m weak.”
“Is it?”
“No. But it feels like it.”
Elowen whispered, “I love you too.”
Cassiel looked at her.
“I know.”
She seemed surprised.
“That’s what makes this so confusing,” he continued. “I believe you loved me while you were lying to me. I believe you loved me when you slept with him. I believe you loved me when you changed the dates.”
Elowen covered her face.
Cassiel’s voice remained steady.
“So love by itself is not enough evidence anymore.”
Dr. Pierce asked, “What would be evidence?”
Cassiel thought.
“Truth when it costs her something. Boundaries with Marcus that are about co-parenting, not emotional escape. Letting me make decisions she hates without changing the information. Time.”
Elowen lowered her hands.
“And for you?” Dr. Pierce asked her.
Elowen breathed carefully.
“I need to stop treating abandonment like an emergency that permits manipulation.”
Cassiel looked at her.
She continued. “I need to accept that he may leave, and being honest cannot depend on whether honesty keeps him.”
Dr. Pierce nodded.
“Good.”
The session ended without a decision about divorce.
In the parking lot, Elowen and Cassiel stood near their separate cars.
“Can I ask you something?” she said.
“Yes.”
“If you eventually decide to leave, will you tell me before you file?”
Cassiel considered.
“Yes.”
“Thank you.”
He nodded.
Elowen rested one hand on her stomach.
“He’s moving.”
Cassiel’s eyes dropped instinctively.
For one painful second, he remembered every time she had guided his hand to feel a kick.
Elowen did not reach for him now.
She simply stood there.
That restraint mattered too.
Cassiel looked back at her face.
“I hope he’s healthy.”
“He is, according to Dr. Sloane.”
“Good.”
Then he walked to his car.
May you like
For the first time, Elowen understood that hoping for her child and choosing their marriage were two separate acts of compassion.
She could not use one to demand the other.