scribe

Chapter 5 - One Piece

Elowen agreed to meet him that evening at a quiet café halfway between their house and Malcolm’s apartment.

Cassiel chose a public place because he did not trust either of them to have the same argument in the rooms where they had built a marriage.

Elowen arrived early. She had changed into jeans and a loose sweater. Without the maternity dress, she looked less like the woman from the ultrasound suite and more like the person Cassiel had known since graduate school.

That resemblance made him angry in a different way.

She stood when he approached.

“Thank you for coming.”

He sat without answering.

A server brought water. Neither ordered food.

Cassiel placed his phone face down on the table.

“I spoke to Marcus.”

Elowen’s eyes closed briefly.

“He called you?”

“Yes.”

“What did he say?”

Cassiel leaned back.

“This is the part where you stop asking what other people told me and start telling me what happened.”

She nodded.

He had prepared questions in Malcolm’s guest room, writing them on hotel stationery because he needed structure more than he needed dignity.

“When did it start?”

“March fourth.”

“First time you slept together?”

“March eighteenth.”

“Last time?”

“April eleventh.”

That matched Marcus.

“How many times?”

“Five.”

“Did you use protection?”

“Not every time.”

Cassiel looked away toward the café window.

“When did you know you were pregnant?”

“May twenty-sixth.”

“First scan?”

“June seventh.”

“What did they date the pregnancy?”

Elowen’s fingers tightened around the paper sleeve on her water glass.

“About ten weeks.”

Cassiel did the math. Conception would have fallen somewhere around late March, give or take normal biological uncertainty.

Squarely inside the affair.

“You told me on June seventeenth that you were six weeks pregnant.”

“Yes.”

“You had already seen an ultrasound placing you at about ten.”

“Yes.”

“Why six?”

“Because six weeks made it possible.”

There it was.

The sentence he had been waiting for.

“Possible for me.”

“Yes.”

“Not medically possible. Emotionally possible.”

Elowen nodded.

“I was terrified you’d leave before we knew whose baby it was.”

“So you made sure I bonded first.”

“That wasn’t—”

Cassiel lifted one hand.

“Finish that sentence only if you can say it without lying.”

Elowen’s eyes filled.

She looked down.

“I wanted you to love the baby.”

“I already would have cared about an innocent baby.”

“I wanted you to love the baby as yours.”

Cassiel stared at her.

The honesty finally arrived, and it hurt more than the evasions.

“You were trying to create a fact with attachment.”

“I thought if it was yours, none of this would matter.”

“And if it wasn’t?”

Elowen whispered, “I didn’t let myself think that far.”

Cassiel reached into his jacket and unfolded the paper of questions.

Elowen looked at it.

“You wrote them down?”

“I’m trying not to scream at you.”

She nodded.

He continued.

“Did Marcus know I thought you were five months?”

“No.”

“Did anyone else know the real timeline?”

“My sister knew I was further along.”

“Did she know about Marcus?”

“Yes.”

Cassiel sat very still.

Elowen’s younger sister, Nerissa, had congratulated him at a family barbecue. She had hugged him and said, You’re going to be such a good dad.

He added another name to the list of people who had been standing inside the truth while he performed happiness outside it.

“Why did you keep talking to Marcus?”

“Because he had a right to know there might be a baby.”

Cassiel’s expression hardened.

“He had a right to know, but I didn’t?”

“That sounds terrible.”

“It is terrible.”

“I know.”

Cassiel folded the paper again.

“Dr. Sloane mentioned earlier records would matter more than yesterday’s measurements. I want copies of the dating scans if you’re willing to share them.”

Elowen nodded quickly. “I will.”

“And I want a paternity test.”

Her face changed.

“Now?”

“If there’s a medically appropriate noninvasive option your doctor considers reasonable, yes. Otherwise after birth. But I’m not spending the next three months pretending uncertainty is intimacy.”

Elowen wiped one tear from her cheek.

“If it’s yours, can we fix this?”

Cassiel looked at her for a long time.

“That question is exactly the problem.”

She stared back.

“You still think paternity decides whether you betrayed me.”

“I don’t.”

“You asked the question.”

She lowered her eyes.

Cassiel stood.

“I’m staying at Malcolm’s for now. We can talk about bills and appointments tomorrow. I’m not making permanent decisions tonight.”

Elowen nodded.

As he turned to leave, she said, “Cassiel.”

He stopped.

“I am sorry.”

He did not tell her it was too late.

He did not tell her it was enough.

May you like

He simply said, “Be specific next time.”

Then he walked out into the evening, carrying the first piece of the truth he had asked for.

Related Stories

Other posts