scribe

Chapter 10 - The Letter That Was Too Convenient

The letter Cedric left behind was damning.

Father Anselm taught her another useful rule that morning: a document could be persuasive precisely because it confirmed what someone already hoped to believe. Cedric's false letter gave Ysabel everything she wanted—Alaric's guilt in clean language, his intention reduced to a few incriminating lines, the ambiguity gone. That perfection made it dangerous. Real conspiracies were usually messier. People used euphemisms, private references, unfinished instructions. Alaric especially prized deniability. A letter making him sound like a stage villain was less plausible than an account entry that hid theft behind the word 'transfer.' Ysabel felt embarrassed that she had wanted the letter to be real. Then she decided embarrassment was useful if it made her harder to deceive twice.

Master Rellan's written record became a small fortress. Once her lucid refusal existed under a neutral seal, Alaric could no longer claim every later objection was invented after the fact. A single properly witnessed moment anchored the chronology.

Too damning.

It appeared to be written in Alaric’s hand and instructed Cedric to “prepare Lady Ysabel’s authorization whether she recalls giving it or not.” It referred directly to Wrenford, the missing seal, and Lord Mowbray’s loan.

Mara read it once and said, “This could hang a man.”

Father Anselm read it twice and said, “This could also be bait.”

Ysabel agreed.

Alaric’s actual letters were elegant and restrained. Even when angry, he rarely wrote anything explicit. A man who preferred deniable cruelty did not ordinarily put crimes into plain sentences.

She compared the letter with an old note Alaric had written her during their courtship.

The handwriting was close.

But the ink was wrong.

Alaric used brown-black iron gall from the manor scriptorium. Cedric’s letter shone blue at the edges when held near flame.

Father Anselm touched the page.

“Westbridge ink.”

Cedric kept a bottle of it in the counting room.

“Why give me a false letter?” Mara asked.

“Because if I present it,” Ysabel said, “Alaric can prove it is false and make everything else I say look false too.”

Father Anselm nodded.

“Or Cedric hopes to make you accuse Alaric before you have evidence strong enough to survive denial.”

Ysabel folded the letter again.

“Then we do not accuse anyone.”

“What do we do?” Mara asked.

“We let Cedric believe I trusted him.”

The next morning, Ysabel thanked Cedric in the gallery.

He visibly relaxed.

“I knew you would understand.”

“I understand that I need protection.”

“Yes.”

“And you will help me find the rest of Lord Osric’s records?”

Cedric hesitated only slightly.

“If they still exist.”

“They do.”

His eyes sharpened.

“How can you know?”

“The key.”

She watched him carefully.

“What key?” he asked.

Too quickly.

Ysabel smiled.

“Exactly.”

Cedric said nothing.

She walked away.

That afternoon, Alaric summoned a notary named Master Rellan to the manor.

The new authorization was laid out in the solar with three witnesses: Cedric, Lord Mowbray, and Alaric’s aunt, Lady Heloise.

Ysabel read every line.

It granted Alaric emergency authority over Wrenford and over the portion of Fenwick lands assigned to her dower, citing her “temporary incapacity arising from advanced pregnancy.”

She looked up.

“I will not sign this.”

Alaric’s expression remained controlled.

“Why?”

“Because I am not incapacitated.”

“You forgot signing the Mowbray authorization.”

“I did not sign it.”

“You misplaced your seal.”

“It was taken.”

“You believed the windless cellar door was deliberately shut.”

“I still believe that.”

Lady Heloise shifted uneasily.

Ysabel turned to the notary.

“Master Rellan, do you consider a woman incapable because she disputes a forged document?”

Rellan cleared his throat. “That is not for me to determine.”

“Good. Then record that I am lucid, present, and refusing voluntarily.”

Alaric’s face changed.

Only slightly.

But Rellan dipped his pen.

“I can record that.”

“Record also that I request examination of the Mowbray note against the sealed marriage settlement held by my trustee, Lady Corinne Marroway.”

At Corinne’s name, Cedric looked at Alaric.

Alaric’s calm finally cracked.

“There is no need to involve your aunt.”

Ysabel met his eyes.

“There is every need.”

Master Rellan wrote.

The scratch of his pen sounded louder than the fire.

May you like

For the first time, Ysabel was not merely resisting Alaric’s story.

She was creating a record of her own.

Related Stories

Other posts