Chapter 16 - The Choice to Stay

Marianne expected herself to say no immediately. She had spent days imagining another school, another classroom, another beginning untouched by the mouse. But Cressie’s therapist encouraged them to separate escape from choice.
“What do you want?” Marianne asked.
“I don’t know.”
That was allowed.
They visited two other schools. Cressie liked one library and disliked another cafeteria. She imagined being the new girl, carrying the secret of why she transferred. Hawthorne Vale frightened her, but it also contained Ms. Harcourt, the art room she loved, and classmates who were beginning to see her differently.
At the end of the week, Cressie said, “I want to try staying until summer.”
Marianne nodded. “And if you change your mind?”
“I can leave.”
“Yes.”
The knowledge that staying was reversible made it feel less like being trapped.
Hawthorne Vale’s independent review began. Penrose discovered the school’s reporting system relied too heavily on individual staff judgment. Minor incidents could remain isolated unless someone manually recognized a pattern. The academy adopted centralized documentation for repeated peer conflict, required follow-up when a child expressed fear of retaliation and locked utility cabinets that controlled security equipment.
Ms. Harcourt participated openly, including acknowledging her own missed report.
Some colleagues told her she was being too hard on herself.
She disagreed. Shame was useful only if converted into changed behavior.
Cressie returned full-time on a Monday when the rain finally stopped. Sunlight reflected off wet pavement. At lunch, a classmate named Mae invited her to sit with two other girls.
Cressie nearly refused. She worried invitation could become another setup.
Then she remembered that fear had been making decisions for her.
“Okay,” she said.
Across the cafeteria, Delphine sat with Imogen. Their friendship with Vesta had fractured, but neither girl was suddenly transformed into a hero. Imogen looked ashamed whenever she saw Cressie. Delphine sometimes nodded hello and accepted when Cressie did not respond.
After lunch, Cressie approached Ms. Harcourt.
“I want my old desk back.”
“The vandalized one?”
“Not with the writing. I mean the place where it was.”
Ms. Harcourt understood. They moved Cressie from the window table to the original row.
Cressie sat down and placed her backpack beside her chair.
Her hand hovered over the zipper.
Then she opened it.
Nothing moved.
She breathed.
At the end of class, however, she found something on her desk: a tiny pencil drawing of a mouse.
May you like
Her heart slammed.
Underneath it were the words: YOU CAN’T GET RID OF ME.