Chapter 28 - The Question Ismerie Asked

Children know how to arrive at the center of a family’s unfinished work with one clean sentence.
It happened on an August afternoon while Eirwen was sorting laundry and Theron was building a toy shelf in the playroom. Ismerie sat on the rug coloring suns with purple crayons—a choice she defended fiercely as beautiful.
Without looking up, she asked, “Why Daddy slap Mama?”
The room stilled.
There were many possible mistakes in such a moment: evasion, over-explanation, defensiveness, shame. Theron set down the screwdriver and looked at Eirwen. She met his eyes and gave a tiny nod. Truth, age-appropriate but true.
Theron moved to the floor and sat cross-legged a few feet from his daughter. “Because Daddy made a very bad choice,” he said.
Ismerie kept coloring. “Mad?”
“Yes. Scared and mad. But being scared and mad did not make it okay.”
She considered this. “Daddy say sorry.”
“I did.”
“Lots?”
A faint, helpless smile touched Eirwen’s mouth.
“Yes,” Theron said. “Lots.”
Ismerie looked up at him then, blue eyes wide with the gravity toddlers sometimes possess by accident. “No do again.”
It was both instruction and test.
Theron answered with the seriousness it deserved. “No. Never again.”
She seemed satisfied. “Okay.” Then she returned to her purple sun.
Afterward, once she had run off to inspect the half-built shelf, Theron remained on the rug, shoulders bowed. Eirwen came and sat beside him.
“You answered well,” she said.
“I answered the smallest part,” he replied. “The rest I have to keep answering with my life.”
She did not disagree.
That night in bed—still a shared bed some nights now, though not all, because they had rebuilt intimacy the way they rebuilt trust, in increments rather than declarations—Eirwen lay awake listening to the quiet breathing of the house.
May you like
“No do again,” she thought.
Simple sentences could be vows if adults treated them as such.